has anyone ever been arrested for carrying a knife?

Joined
Apr 7, 1999
Messages
514
Just want to know if anyone has ever been arrested and charged with a crime for having the wrong knife on them at the wrong time. I'm sort of afraid that it is just a matter of time before it happens to me. Since I live in CA, and I do own a couple small fixed blades, I have the choice of either not using them at all outside my house, carrying them concealed, or carrying them unconcealed--which I will not do. If I do not carry them concealed, then they never get used at all.
 
Almost. I had a cop ask me to stand by his car one time after a guy was arrested in a hotel I was in. He thought I had something to do with whatever the guy did. He asked me to empty my pockets onto the hood of his car. Well as you could imagine I had several knives and most were autos.

He said he could arrest me for carrying the knives and he told me autos were not legal. I asked under what statute? He bumbled around a bit and then I showed him my CWP as well. He then said that the CWP does not cover autos. I said really? Show where there is any law in Florida on autos. He could not produce the statute and when he called his supervisor he was educated real quick.

I was very nice about the whole thing and I even explained Florida laws to him. In the beginning he was still worked up over the first arrest and he was still not sure about me.

The next day he came to the Gun Show I was working at the Coconut Grove Convention Center in Miami and bought a Benchmade Mini-Reflex from me
smile.gif


------------------
Best Regards,
Mike Turber
BladeForums Site Owner and Administrator
Do it! Do it right! Do it right NOW!
Show Your Support -Visit Our Sponsors - Click On The Banners!

[This message has been edited by Mike Turber (edited 02-22-2000).]
 
NICE.... Mike
Who woulda thunk it, that just goes to show how un educated, even the cops, are in the world.......
 
No arrest, but a couple of years ago I carried some fixed blade knives in my hand, from my car, up the elevator, and to my office. Some nervous person in the elevator called the cops.

About a half hour later, which would have been a long time if I'd been on a mission of destruction, two Glendale police officers showed up on my office, and asked the receptionist if she'd seen some guy going around with knives. She said that Jim - in there - makes knives, and one of the cops sighed with relief.

When I got off the phone, they asked me to come out - away from all the knives on my desk - and gave me a little talk. They told me that I should keep my fixed blade knives out of sight when I move them about, to avoid scaring people. I asked if that wouldn't make them "concealed," and they said to just keep them out of sight.

The cops clearly wanted to end the conversation and move on, so I decided not to annoy them by arguing, and what they advised actually makes good practical and social sense, but it's not every day that an officer of the law tells me to commit a felony.
rolleyes.gif



------------------
- JKM
www.chaicutlery.com
AKTI Member # SA00001
 
When I was a teen I came pretty close a couple times. Both cases I was clearly over the legal line. Once in La Canada some friends and I were stopped and searched by L.A. Sheriffs deputies. They took a brand new 5"-bladed Italian push button off me and two gravity knives off my friend. We were about to be taken to the station when a hotter call came up on the car radio. Our stuff was confiscated (all clearly illegal under California switch blade statutes) and the cops blew out of there with their siren blaring. It made quite an impression with the crowd at the Foster's Freeze across the street. We were glad not to be taken in. My friend still had a commando dagger up one sleeve, a throwing spike up the other sleeve and a straight razor in his boot. I had a box cutter in one back pocket, a 4" bladed folding fishing knife with the side panels removed behind my wallet, and another switch blade in a shirt pocket.

A couple years later the same group of guys were crossing the border at Tijuana when we were strip-searched. This time it was just me carrying. I again was carrying a brand new Italian push button when searched. They didn't find it till I dropped my Jockey shorts. I'd done a pretty good job of concealment, just a bad job of looking cool. The border guards were really looking for drugs, so they just fined me $10.00 and took the knife away. I just can't keep those 5" push buttons. I broke the point off the last one I got throwing it into a wooden fence.

 
Talked myself out of an arrest for a 4" Italian Switchblade at a concert when I was a teenager by explaining to the arrresting officer that the last concert I had been to I was accosted by a pervert in the bathroom who tried to molest me(I think he had rape on his mind, actually, But I exercised rule number one in potentially violent situations. I RAN!).
Of course, that is carrying for self defense, which for some perverted reason is VERBOTTEN here in the "land of the free", however, the officer understood my predicament and let me off. Of course, he kept the knife.
mad.gif


------------------
My new bumper sticker:

Let me tell you about my SIFU!
 
Quote: "the next day he came to the Gun Show I was working at the Coconut Grove Convention Center in Miami and bought a Benchmade Mini-Reflex from me"

Is it just me - or is it that every encounter Mr. Turber has with the law ends up by him selling them knives???

I wouldn’t want to meet him in a dark alley with my credit card in hand
wink.gif



 
About 25 years ago, me and a buddy did a six week camping trip across the northern states, into Canada through Vancouver then back east. We were of legal drinking age and declared some beer we had when we entered Canada. All went well till we got to Ontario. We were pulled over in mid afternoon for no apparent reason. The rotund jolly cop asked what we were doing. We told him camping. He then asked if we had any firearms, the answer was no. Next he asked if we had any alcohol. We said yes, there is beer in the trunk. He went apes**t and told us we were under arrest and would have to go with him. He took my buddy in the squad car and told be to follow in our car. He was doing about 90 on the way to the station house. He confiscated the beer and we had to pay a fine. According to him, it was legal to buy beer and legal to have it in your house but it was NOT legal to transport it in your car! What a crock but we wanted to get going so we paid. Several hours later we had stopped by the side of the road to look at a map. We were trying to find a provincial park to camp at. We were miles from any town and as it was November, I was wearing a parka that came below my waist. A car pulls up behind us and my buddy says "its a cop, I'll go talk to him". I was still studying the map when the cop shines a flashlight in my face, asks for ID and tells me to step out of the car. I did what I was told, and he started to pat me down. I had a Buck 110 in a belt sheath. When he felt that he tensed up, took it, and told me I was under arrest for possession of a concealed weapon! Then he called for back up. They took us in and tore the car apart--to the point of removing hubcaps and air filter cover. They gave us a hard time about our ax, and we tried to explain we were camping.
I was wearing a Rolex and had two Nikons with me. In a snide voice, the original cop says: "you sure have a nice watch and camera equipment there, I sure hope you have some proof of ownership or you are going awaty for a long time". Lucky for me, I had gone to the Bahamas the previous spring and had registered my stuff with customs along with serial numbers before I went so I wouldn't have a problem coming back with customs. I had stuck the list in my wallet and forgotten about it. I pulled that out and you could see how disappointed he was. An older cop who had been very nice actually helped us put everything back in the car. The first guy said: "well I could still run you in on the weapons charge but whats the point". He then proceeded to lecture me about Canada being a civilized country and how knives like mine were not allowed. My buddy had a small two bladed Case and he said that was allowable. I was scared witless! I was in a foreign country and had no idea what my rights were. It ended well but left a bad taste in my mouth. Several points:
1. Although I was cuffed and put in a car, they were never physically abusive other than making the cuffs too tight.
2. After all that, they let me keep the Buck!
3. The car was an old Dodge with a center console that opened for storage. As I said I had been looking at the map when they nabbed me and had left it spread out over the console. That turned out to be incredible stroke of luck since I had a blackjack (not the knife kind) in there and they completely missed it in there otherwise thorough search. I guess if they had found that I'd probably be getting out of jail around now.
4. We were in downtown Montreal the next day and walked into a coffee shop for lunch. A guy was sitting at the counter with a 12" Bowie hanging from his belt. I looked at my buddy and said: "well, so much for whats allowed in this "civilized" country.
5. I was a very happy camper when we crossed back into New York and vowed I'd never go back. As it happens, I've never been back but I've softened my opinion a little. But I'll be damned careful what I take if I ever do go back.

phantom4

------------------
who dares, wins


 
My son has had his Spyderco Endura and BF Native (both serrated) taken off him by the local police. Both times we recovered the knife.
 
Now for the bad news, and this is in my capacity as a Police Officer in the UK !

If you carry any blade here, ANY blade, you can and probably will be arrested as all knives are banned in a public place unless you use them for work purposes or 'can show godd and lawful reason' for carrying them.

This includes any of the multi-tools or any item with a blade.

And you think the US has some harsh laws !

 
When I was younger I had quite A reputation as A knife nut even the county sherriff knew about it.At any rate one night in my neighborhood someone used A buck-lite knife to cut A gas pump hose and break into A store.(Buck-lite knives had just came out and where not common)So of course the cops come to me. I knew who's knife it was and I even told them, they didn't beleive me. Anyway they put me in the back seat so they could question me,and I stuck my Italin switchblade down between the back of the seat and the cushion.They did not even search me, although they did ask if I was carrying....I wonder if it is still there...?

------------------
Are you A member? www.AKTI.org
 
When I was younger I had quite A reputation as A knife nut even the county sherriff knew about it.At any rate one night in my neighborhood someone used A buck-lite knife to cut A gas pump hose and break into A store.(Buck-lite knives had just came out and where not common)So of course the cops come to me. I knew who's knife it was and I even told them, they didn't beleive me. Anyway they put me in the back seat so they could question me,and I stuck my Italin switchblade down between the back of the seat and the cushion.They did not even search me, although they did ask if I was carrying....I wonder if it is still there...?

------------------
Are you A member? www.AKTI.org
 
I have never been arrested but when I was in High School I bought one of those Reproductions of the WWI trench daggers(brass knuckles and all) and I was showing it to a friend along the street. Somehow, I ended up on the back of a car(standing on the back bumper) with the knife in one hand as the car was driving down the street. Of course this looked suspicious to the passing cop so he pulled us over. I hopped off the bumper and tried to throw the knife in the car and my "friend" wouldn't unlock the door to let me in. Well it turns out the cop never saw me wielding the knife he was after us for riding on back of the car. Warnings all around, although I don't know how he missed that knife.
Eric

------------------
Outside of a dog, a Knife is man's best friend. Inside a dog it is very, very Dark.
 
Never gotten into trouble, but I did have some lady ask me " Are you old enough to carry that?" That was about a month ago, I was with my 4H club at a skating rink, we were done skating and I pulled out my delica to cut the wristband that showed I had payed.I just laughed and said yes, wasn't really sure what to think. I look alot older than I am,16, but even if I only looked 16 I would have tought that was old enough.

I had a good scare with the police too. I was at the state fair with 2 friends. I had my delica clipped in my back pocket and a gerber multi tool on my belt with my shirt tucked in as usual. I know that a delica is completely legal and I have never worried about it at all, except for then. We were standing there watching this old guy carve with a chainsaw. He was on a stage that is surrounded by a small pond. We were standing at the edge of the pond watching, and two cops walk up behind me. They just stand there talking to each other quietly and I didn't think anyhting of it, then 2 state highway patrol show up on my right. I still didn't really think anything of it until 2 more state highway patrol show up on my left. So now me and my friends are surrounded by six cops, and have the pond in front of us. None of the cops are saying anything and don't apear to be paying attention to the show. I was starting to get pretty worried, wondering if the laws had changed without me knowing or if they thought I had something different than I acutally did. Or if it was because of something other than my knives altogether. After a few minutes they just walked away one at a time though, I guess they must have been watching the show, but the 2 on my left were facing me more than the stage.

------------------
Fix it right the first time, use Baling Wire !
 
A friend of mine is Mexican by birth, but grew up in Pasadena, California. As a kid he took lots of odd jobs to help support the family. One time he was clearing an overgrown parking strip with his trusty old machete. A woman looked out her window and called the cops. He got hauled down to the station and charged with brandishing a deadly weapon. The charges were dropped before coming to trial.
 
I had an unfortunate experience with the police last week, but it ended well for my knives. The officer insisted on maintaining possession of my native while I danced around on the side of the road, but didn't seem to mind the swisstool or the flashlight on my belt, and didn't dig deep enough into my car, not that I would of given my approval anyways, to find any knives (Of which I know of two, and were probably more) lying around inside. He was kind enough to give it back when he let me go. He was also kind enough to let me sit in my car in between dealing with me, which I appreciated since it was somewhere below zero outside... Unfortunately, he wasn't kind enough not to ticket me.


Stryver
 
No arrests, but I live in such a rural area
that I can wear a large fixed blade on my
belt while shopping at Kroger's - and never
raise an eyebrow! However, just this week,
at my local Post Office, I pulled out my
large Wegner, snapped it open, and proceeded
to open a parcel. The guy behind the counter
got real wide-eyed and asked me to "please
put that away, if an inspector walks in here
he'll call a swat-team!" I did so, and then
pulled out my Kissing Crane traditional....
nothing more was said.
 
this is a good story:

A week ago, when I was getting dinner by myself at a local Chic-Fil-A, a local police officer was standing next to me in line. I had my Kershaw Whirlwind in my pocket that is legal (by about 2/3rds of the laws in virginia) and he saw the clip coming out of the edge of my pocket. He said, "is that a knife" and i said, "yep" and then ordered and he didn't say anything else to me.
confused.gif


I feel really safe now. I coulda had a SIFU (which is much too long) in my pocket with the clip out and I probably woulda gotten the same response. oh well.

oh yeah- I look like a punk kid, with a polo shirt and khaki pants. it was my dinner break from work so I was in friday professional casual. Which is funny, because the rest of the days I work, when it's supposed to be professional business clothing, I wear cargo pants, a tee-shirt and boots.
smile.gif


------------------
"If the only tool you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail"
Such a funny quote, true or not.
-ediconu
 
Back
Top