That's odd, because you should be able to put a good edge on any blade, as long as the correct angle is used. If i cannot take a good edge, the bevel may not be done correctly. Even then it would just need to be re profiled. If yours is not beveled correctly, you can send it back to Emerson, and they will fix it. It would be a shame for a nice RH to sit in a drawer forever.
All of my Emersons are at least razor sharp. I find they tend to be sharper out of the box than most other brands. Maybe you just got the odd one that has a problem.
I got my roadhouse razor sharp again today. Re profiled it to to approximately 23 degrees. I'm now a happy camper again!
