Help me pick my next Spyder!

[Wild West]

Yeah, that thread can be a little nerdy. The numbers in the second half are the total number of cuts made prior to needing 20 lbs. of down force to start the cut. So higher is better.

I find the thread's info more helpful for figuring out analogs of a steel. For example, I just picked up a knife in 3V, and I need to know what steel it will perform most similarly to.

Unfortunately, Cruwear isn't in the first list, but you can see that it's on the lower end as the Spydie Military in the second listing. However, you can't take that as gospel. Just that, in those conditions for that test, it compares in that way to other steels.

From what I understand, Cruwear is a tough steel that takes and hold a good edge and handles tough cutting well without the risk of chipping or rolling the edge. And it touches up quickly.

I have no experience with Cruwear, but I'm very familiar with M4. With the right edge geometry and finish, it's stupid aggressive, tough, and takes only a light stropping to maintain the edge. I chopped up a fallen tree branch the other day, and a few swipes on the ultra fine stones had it back to whittling hair.

Other guys will give you a good perspective on Cruwear. 3rdGenRigger has a lot of good to say about it and 3V.

Ok, thanks!

So by that chart, easily the best value knife is Manix 2 with S110V or the Native 5 with CPM S35VN for under $100. Only problem is that I'd want the Fluted TI version of the Native 5 which makes it WAY more. I don't like the way the Manix opens or closes though, so that one is out.
But, if you're going by that chart, then you'd have to say that the Manix 2 with S110V or the Farid Mehr K2 made with CPM-10V are the best of the best. Would you agree?

Thanks man, you've been very helpful.

 

[spketch]

Best for edge retention maybe, which can be a fun thing to chase and discuss. There's a lot more to a knife than that though, and some of the "lower end" alloys on that list won't be dull after a full day of cutting for many people.

Consider this: if I'm not mistaken, Ankerson himself most often carries an s30v military. Take the results with a grain of salt, and try not to get too wrapped up in "best".

Regarding steel alloys, Sal has stated his opinion as, " All good, just different".

 

[Wild West]

Best for edge retention maybe, which can be a fun thing to chase and discuss. There's a lot more to a knife than that though, and some of the "lower end" alloys on that list won't be dull after a full day of cutting for many people.

Consider this: if I'm not mistaken, Ankerson himself most often carries an s30v military. Take the results with a grain of salt, and try not to get too wrapped up in "best".

Regarding steel alloys, Sal has stated his opinion as, " All good, just different".

Understood.

On another note, I've been meaning to contact you about a special request. I'll get in touch. Thanks!