Hey guys, New here. Need help picking a knife

B

bigb32

Joined
Mar 23, 2005
Messages
6
Hi ,

I am looking for a carry knife. I live in NY so I cannot have a auto but I can have the kind that open with a flick of the wrist right? I would like a slim so its not bulky on my side but still be able to get a good grip. I like the SOG Trident because it has the little knotch to cut the rope, but im not to sold on the blade or looks. Is there any that are like this? What would you suggest? I would like to spend around 50 if I can get something good for that. thanks
 
I'm surprised that dispite saying you have $50 to spend there havent been over 200 posts suggesting either a Sebenza or a Strider :rolleyes:

For $50 you will get a pretty decent folder.

My choice would be a Spyderco Native III with a plain edge not serrated

C78BK_M.jpg



Image taken from www.spyderco.com

Or a Benchmade Monochrome


bm-10300.jpg


* Note One stop knife shop pays for this forum.

Both retail for around $60 but you can get them for significantly less.
 
Welcome aboard bigb32.
I think you would be well-advised to start out with a Spyderco Calypso Jr. or a Camillus EDC. Both are quality knives and constructed of good materials and made by companies with good reputations on this forum due to their good customer service and participation here. Additionally, their prices are reasonable. You should be able to find either knife for under $50. I have had very good buying experiences with New Graham Knives, and One Stop Knife Shop, which pays for this forum..
 
Buy a couple of knife magazines, peruse some sites, look here at the EDC threads, look over what you want in an EDC, does it need to be fast, does it need serrations, a spear point? Currently, I EDC these FOUR knives! A Spyderco Ladybug, a SOG Blink, a Spyderco Cricket and my big EDC, a Spyderco Native III. I like the Native III the best, mainly because it feels so good in the hand. As for what is legal in your hood, I would check with a lawyer, or your local LEO.
 
Welcome to BFC sir!

I live in NY and here is what I carry, all of which were under $40!

Benchmade Mini-Pika $20
Spyderco Calypso Jr. $35
Spyderco Merlin $25
Kershaw Leek $40

I also carry a Victorinox Climber and Rally. :)

I would also suggest a classic Endura or Delica from Spyderco, they are great great user knives.
 
fudo said:
Welcome aboard bigb32.
I think you would be well-advised to start out with a Spyderco Calypso Jr. or a Camillus EDC. Both are quality knives and constructed of good materials and made by companies with good reputations on this forum due to their good customer service and participation here. Additionally, their prices are reasonable. You should be able to find either knife for under $50. I have had very good buying experiences with New Graham Knives, and One Stop Knife Shop, which pays for this forum..
Click to expand...

Thank you for the help guys. I would like it to be a fast opener. I really dont know much, but what are the ones called that can quickly be opened by flick of a wrist? (all legal in NY right?) I am not sure what tupe of blade I should get. I would say I might use it for protection but thats very rare, I really would use it as a tool, opeb boxes, or on my boat. I like that Benchmade Monochrome how is that? I also like the SOG trident because it had the little knotch that exposes the blade to cut line. Is this really useful or just a gimmick? I guess if I can open it quickly to cut line or string I dont really need the knotch. I am looking into the other knives you guys suggested, thanks

TF4.jpg
 
I've heard the notched line cutter on the sog doesn't work as well as it appears it would but I've never handled one to try it so take that with a grain of salt. I like the Spyderco Calypso Jr. suggestion. Great blade steel, one hand opening at a great price.
 
I'd just get a separate rescue hook. Assisted opening isn't much faster than a thumbstud and could be called as a "switchblade" by nazi cops
 
Don't be afraid to spend just alittle bit more than $50 and get yourself a Benchmade 556 Mini-Griptilian.

...You'll thank me for this advice later.:).
 
If the knife will open solely through movement, without your having to touch the blade, then it falls into the nebulous category of a "gravity knife", which is usually verboten. However, if you first have to start it by pushing against a thumbstud, for example, I think you're okay. Some knives (e.g. CRKT M16) have flippers on the back that can be pressed to get the blade started - I think that is okay too.
 
In addition to what GarageBoy has recommended I would recommend staying away form knives that are easily opened by a flick of the wrist. It could be pegged as an inertia opening knife which would also be illegal and could get you in some trouble.

Not to worry though as there are still many many good knives available to you in your price range. One of my personal favorites in the $50 and inder category is the Camillus EDC. I had one and just really beat it up for about a year before it finally bit the big one. I would bet that someone who doesn't beat and abuse it so badly would be able to get a lifetime of service out of it. Also no need to worry about breaking any laws, unless of course you use it as a weapon.

And remember in NY you MUST carry concealed!
 
First off, you can get away with a bigger knife in NYC IAW relevent laws (I have checked) if you are a legitimate BOYSCOUT. Literally.

I carried a Police Model, an AFCK, a SOCOM, then a REKAT Pioneer II over 10 yrs of knife carrying in NYC. Not to mention...a DELICA.

I highly rek'mnd the SS Native, Delica, and any medium axis lock from Benchmade. If you can find a G2 Delica, jump on it. I have had mine since the early 90's and it's still aweome.

Check out the BM Mel Pardue's with Axis on them. SWEET.

NYC Law...smaller then 3" for the blade I think...but the COPS are ALWAYS RIGHT...No matter what.

R/S

Formerly...
NYC
CT

Now Seattle
Soon San Diego
Then Vickers, UK.

UGHH!!! I love the NAVY!!!
 
Be real careful listening to all the experts around here, and be sure to define your terms carefully when you ask questions.

New York City might as well not even be in New York State. I lived in NYC for years, but the definitions there are changing. Police -- NOT "nazi cops", d@mmit :( -- have been instructed to consider any knife that flicks open by centrifugal force to be a gravity knife. So tighten the pivot! And keep the blade length UNDER 4".

Speed is not as important as safety, and familiarity with your knife will soon gain you both speed and safety. You don't need fancy mechanisms, just manual dexterity. :D
 
Esav Benyamin said:
Be real careful listening to all the experts around here, and be sure to define your terms carefully when you ask questions.

New York City might as well not even be in New York State. I lived in NYC for years, but the definitions there are changing. Police -- NOT "nazi cops", d@mmit :( -- have been instructed to consider any knife that flicks open by centrifugal force to be a gravity knife. So tighten the pivot! And keep the blade length UNDER 4".

Speed is not as important as safety, and familiarity with your knife will soon gain you both speed and safety. You don't need fancy mechanisms, just manual dexterity. :D
Click to expand...

Some sound advice there.

Paul
 
ErikD said:
In addition to what GarageBoy has recommended I would recommend staying away form knives that are easily opened by a flick of the wrist. It could be pegged as an inertia opening knife which would also be illegal and could get you in some trouble.

Not to worry though as there are still many many good knives available to you in your price range. One of my personal favorites in the $50 and inder category is the Camillus EDC. I had one and just really beat it up for about a year before it finally bit the big one. I would bet that someone who doesn't beat and abuse it so badly would be able to get a lifetime of service out of it. Also no need to worry about breaking any laws, unless of course you use it as a weapon.

And remember in NY you MUST carry concealed!
Click to expand...

Thanks, what if it is in your pocket and the clip can be seen clipped to your pocket? Does that count as concealed? I do not live in the city, I dont understand why its illegal to have a knife that opens fast. Whats the point if you cant quickly open it to protect yourself? The atttacker has time and could already have his gun or knife out. Crazy NY law. Asisted openers are not legal?
 
QUOTE "The atttacker has time and could already have his gun or knife out."

If a guy pulls a knife or a gun at you, leave yours in the pocket and use your running shoes-- it is a much better solution :D


Jose
 
I recomend a Buck 110. With practice, Buck 110's can be opened quite fast with 2 hands, and they are nothing close to a switchblade or gravity knife. With their 3 1/2" clip point blade they are quite good at anything from shaving bark off a stick to fighting. I used mine hard for several years and it was still in good shape when I gave it to my buddy. Besides, Buck 110's can easily be purchased for as little as $30. so if they break you can get a new one.
 
Ohhh I thought he ment Upstate NY, where I live in the middle of nowhere Heh.. Yeah NYC laws are bad, darn. In that case maybe a Spyderco Cricket, it's a neat little knife and a big cutter.. But yeah keep it concealed and don't advertise you got one, better safe than sorry, cops love taking knives away (just ask my dad, he took prolly 1000 knives away from people when he was a LEO)... :)
 
I highly recommend the Wegner Mouse Lite -1-5/8" 440C blade Rc 58-60, Overall Open Length 4-15/16". Only 37.95 @ http://blade-tech.com This makes a great EDC in places where knives are likely to be scrutinized.(like NYC) It's a very solid knife with a stout lock and the 1 5/8" blade won't upset the sheeple or the NYC police.
multimedia_51229_1099613489447.jpg


something a little bigger-Buck Sirus-3 1/2" ATS-34 blade, anodized aluminum handles, OAL-7 3/4 ".
$59.95 @ www.knifeworks.com.
bu298gy.jpg
 
For your price range, I'd agree with the suggestion of a Spyderco Delica. Long enough, but probably legal in NYC (?), not heavy, very available online for around $40 or so. I've had mine for years, and while I've traded quite a few knives, I would never trade my Delica away ;)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top