since we're talking sharpening, here's a long thread on the topic:
http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=286222
Inside the above thread I have a couple of posts, but of particular note is Post #54 of the thread, here are the words I wrote:
"Dan,
great info and insight, Thank You !!
As luck would have it, yesterday afternoon Mr FedEx brought me some green micro-fine compound (0.5 micron ??) so I staged another please-work-this-time-and-get-sharp experiment for the WWII Robeson.
I spray-glued a 10" long by 4" wide strip of leather (fuzzy side up) to a mouse pad, duct taped the pad to the workbench, and more-than-liberally applied compound to leather. Then using both hands on the knife handle and applying reasonable pressure I began what you might consider a power strop.
I played around like this for about 45 minutes, adding more compound at times.... at other times using a wire brush to clean off the leather and then reapply compound. Great fun !!
Final result: (apparently) not scary sharp but at least arm hair was being cut, but not in the mass quantities I'd hoped for.
What was Most Very Interesting: I then stropped a nothing-fancy cheapie folder for 120 seconds and it oh-so-easily harvested massive quantities of arm hair !!
So I grabbed a $2 super-cheap-piece-o-trash China-stainless-steel fishing knife and stropped it for 60 seconds.... and it too commenced the oh-to-easy harvesting.
Bottom Line # 1: Go Figure !! Makes no sense to me. The Robeson just doesn't seem to cut it (pun intended) and the cheapies become apparently dangerously sharp.
Are we talking blade angles here ??? Might the Robeson need to be re-profiled ?? Or is that detail unimportant when stropping ??
Bottom Line # 2: the Robeson is certainly sharp enough to use as my EveryDayDinnerKnife (EDDK), but it is just not "that" sharp. If nothing else the stropped edge sure is nice and shiny.
Oh, one more proof it is not "that" sharp: on the rubber mouse pad is a cloth covering. Using a sawing motion the Robeson would not cut the cloth. It cut the rubber easily enough, but not the cloth. By comparison my SOG Field Knife had no problem cutting through the cloth.
Plan Of Action: get busy using my new mousestrop setup and wail away on my SOG Tech I. I reckon that particular steel composition is capable of becoming scary sharp and will test that theory this very evening."
---------------------------------------------------------
then Post #66 has more info I wrote as I learned more:
"OK, more the Robeson and the SOG....
yesterday I posted:
-- Bottom Line # 1: Go Figure !! Makes no sense to me.
-- Plan Of Action: get busy..... on my SOG Tech I.
Well, I got busy on the SOG. I first spent 5 minutes running it back and forth on my sharpening steel. I could actually see and feel what I guess is the "wire edge." (translation: novice).
-- Then I cleaned the mousestrop, reapplied the green micro-stuff, and commenced to stropping. Heeding Pendentive's advice I raised the spine a bit higher to increase the blade angle.
-- It took about 15 minutes to wear away the "wire" and.... holy smokes, that thing is sharp !! I don't know if it qualifies as "scary" to you folks who actually know what you're doing, but it sure 'nuff scared me. I'm still smiling in satisfaction and utter amazement at the ease with which the hair was separated from the forearm.
Therefore, with nothing to lose, I grabbed the Robeson and wailed away on the sharpening steel for 5 minutes or so, then took it to task on the re-cleaned and re-green'ed mousestrop.
-- Within 5 minutes it too was scary sharp in this newly-defined way of looking at things.
When I walked in the house the wife spied the clear-cut patches on my arms and said, "You've been playin' with your knives again...." Weren't nothing for me to do but smile even larger.
What did I learn ?? Not sure, but I'm having fun trying to figure it all out. At least I've got a system that works better than the one I had before.
Cheers and Many Thanks to Dan !!
Carl
---------------------------
I'm one of those guys that can't sharpen, but the leather-mousepad setup with green honing compound really does the job for me !!!!
Cheers,
Carl