How did YOU learn to sharpen a knife?

Learned how to use a whetstone and file in survival school and took it from there-trial and error with different arkansas stones and daimond sharpeners, then added wet and dry sandpaper to the mix. It's what I still use today, though I'm in the process of making my own strop bat. Can't wait to try it!
 
Started by reading some website about angles and burrs. Then pulled out an old hardware store alum ox stone, and started working at it with kitchen knives. I think I found a pocket knife in my room, and wondered how sharp could I get this, and I googled it.

Now two years later I have a powered sharpener with which I have ruined a carbon fiber native and s30v paramilitary. both are crazy sharp, but I can't make the edges even, or aesthetic.

Now I am obsessed, and love polishing up my edges by hand. I reprofile with the powered water stone, then work the edge on some dmt fine and then spyderco fine, and finish with a power strop on the same machine. Also I have some hand held strops for extra sharpness and touch ups.
 
Come on mate!! Aussies are famous for their stories... Tell us more. Tell us HOW you taught yourself? Did you use stones or the curb of the sidewalk? How old were you when you 'discovered' knives and wanted a sharp one? Give us 'the rest of the story!' :eek:


Stitchawl

haha ok then I was maybe 8 years old, got a knife in a trade at school (back when kids weren't shooting schools up) and found a little round sharpening stone in a fishing box among my dads piles of crap in his tool shed. Needless to say my technique wasn't very good but played around working the edge on a low angle in a circular motion (i think i might have seen that in a rambo movie, i saw it in a movie though lol) and went from there...wasn't till i was about 17 that I really learnt to sharpen, more and more online articles popping up on the topic plus found some books at the local library on tool maintenance.

not the greatest of stories, and my granddad actually wasn't the best at sharpening a knife, ironic to be honest because his axe was shaving sharp!
 
I've been killing knife edges for quite some time, starting with a tiny little uncle henry LB1 (sharp now) to a mora (nothing but a power stone will re-bevel that poor thing) I used a lanky kit for quite some time, as a kid, but slowly migrated to small bench stones. now I use a couple of ceramic stones from Lee Valley. As I've bought better and better knives, I've had to ramp up my skill level to avoid ruining them. My dad taught me quite a bit about it though, and the value of a sharp knife, but that said, my knives were only ever as sharp as I could get them, which I think was part of learning about them.
 
Different folks... different stories.... Very interesting!
My father was an oral surgeon and I remember him sharpening a scalpel on (what I now realize was) a hard black Arkansas stone. At the time I thought is was black glass. But he never taught me anything about sharpening...
My grandfather was a butcher and I remember him using a butcher's steel a long as his arm before carving the Thanksgiving turkey.
But he never taught me anything about sharpening...
It took a stranger who thought it was wonderful that a young boy could have so much curiosity in a modern world (well, modern at that time) to want to learn ancient skills, and was willing to take the time to teach me what he knew.
Different folks... Different stories... Very interesting!

Stitchawl
 
Here is how I went about it
002-16.jpg

001-30.jpg

Reason for 2 different size wheels I was in the middle of changing wheels when I took the pic
 
I think I was 9 or 10 when I first got a Arkansas stone from my uncle. He showed me how to apply the oil, hold a angle, and the basics of what I needed to do to sharpen a knife. He in a way explained the burr but showed me more on how to check for it, showing me how a knife would shave one way and not the other and a method I still use today of dragging/stropping the edge on my finger nail to feel the imperfections. I was in awe that a piece of metal could get so sharp and that a stone was doing it.

My memory of sharpening is a little foggy from then until now, I didn't have the passion and focus I have for it now and payed more attention to getting it done rather than HOW i was doing it. I'm the type that's never happy with "good enough" though, and due to some of the jobs I've had my quality standards are exceptionally high and my love of science keeps me looking deeper into the subject. Before the internet I had no idea the amount of stones or sharpening tools you could get and used nothing more than a medium Arkansas stone. But one day I thought "there must be a better way" so I went in search of a new stone. I found the spyderco ceramics and decided to try out the medium stone, I was amazed by the speed that the stone worked and nearly double the sharpness I was getting. I went on to researching all I could about sharpening at this point (thanks to the web) and started picking up more tools to get sharper.

I stumbled upon the HandAmerican web site and read everything before finally buying some leather and liquid Chromium Oxide. Just as described my edges became duller before they got sharper, I practiced until I got it right though and started getting edges so sharp I was amazed once again at what I had found. I was happy at this point and saw no need to try anything different so I stuck with it for a good long time, but then I found Blade forums.

Before signing up I read through pages and pages on sharpening, I never had anyone to tell me what I was doing wrong or answer the questions I had so most of what I knew was from trial and error. After reading I decided to sign up and dig deeper into what all of the sudden became an obsession. It was like the flood gates opened and all the things I didn't understand became clear, filling in the blanks on 15 years of learning it myself. I found a thread on splitting hairs and thought dam that's sharp, so I wanted to see if I could do it. I took my sharpest knife and not surprisingly I couldn't do it. So I sat down with my strop and stropped until my edge was sharper than ever and able to split a hair.

This is the point I started looking back and looking close, and in a way relearned sharpening from finish to start instead of start to finish. So in other words I started learning more about setting a proper bevel and how to take that to a finished state. I also started looking very close at the edge and as they say a picture is worth a 1000 words. It has brought me answers for the sharpening side and the cutting side, showing me what was really happening and broken a lot of myths I've heard in the past.

I finally progressed on to Diamond stones and compounds as I feel they give me the very best results. I've used them for about 2 years now and will probably never change from here, until I get too old to see what I'm doing then I might buy a EP :p

So 19-20 years later I'm here typing out my story of sharpening and expanding my knowledge to what I've discovered as a art that I love.
 
...[SNIP]
I stumbled upon the HandAmerican web site and read everything before finally buying some leather and liquid Chromium Oxide. Just as described my edges became duller before they got sharper, I practiced until I got it right though and started getting edges so sharp I was amazed once again at what I had found.

Just a quick note here... You know my love of horsehide for a strop, and quality horsehide at that, especially Horween's quality horsehide shells... The horsehide strops that HandAmerican is selling are made of Horween's horsehide butts!!!!!! They aren't 'shells' but the 'butt' is right next to the 'shell' in the cutting pattern. Just not quite as thick. Now everyone can have the best of the best!! Just remember that these are ALWAYS used bare! Don't goop them up with any compound. They are the FINAL strop in the process.

I finally progressed on to Diamond stones and compounds as I feel they give me the very best results. I've used them for about 2 years now and will probably never change from here, until I get too old to see what I'm doing then I might buy a EP :p

I've got a dollar to bet with anyone that Knifeknut1013 gets an EdgePro before he turns 35.... ;)
(Remember this; it's ALWAYS easier to get one BEFORE you get married. :D)

Stitchawl
 
Last edited:
Looks like I need to check out some of that leather, sounds really good. I have a piece now but I think its dirty, it works extremely well but will scratch a mirror finish.


No plans to get married at this time ;)
 
Looks like I need to check out some of that leather, sounds really good. I have a piece now but I think its dirty, it works extremely well but will scratch a mirror finish.

If you look at the Horween site http://horween.com/index.php/leathers/ and click on the "equine hide shapes" you can see where the butt leather fits into the hide. It's just behind and below the shells. It's just a tad thinner and not quite as dense as the shell leather but that shouldn't have any effect on its stropping power. It will still have the same great high silicate content and be the pefect finishing strop! :thumbup:

No plans to get married at this time ;)

Any of you married guys want to tell him? Or should we just let him find out the hard way... :D


Stitchawl
 
Stitchawl, you are really making me want one of the horsehide strops. The bare veg-tanned leather I have been using appears to make a noticeable difference in sharpness, so it really whets my desire to try the horse leather. :thumbup:
 
i was probably around 9 or 10 when i was first shown how to sharpen a knife on a stone.

i didn't practise much until i got a SAK for my 13th birthday which i religiously kept silly sharp and stropped on my school belt.

now, 27 years later, i'm looking at getting some paper wheels and relegating the whetstones for field touch-up duties.
 
Well I was almost married but got out just in time :) we were together long enough so trust me I know what your saying .

Any Cal, night and day difference, try some horse leather.
 
Stitchawl, you are really making me want one of the horsehide strops. The bare veg-tanned leather I have been using appears to make a noticeable difference in sharpness, so it really whets my desire to try the horse leather. :thumbup:

Any Cal... let me put it this way...
If you try good quality horsehide side by side with good quality cowhide, and DON"T instantly fall in love with it... I'll buy it from you. :cool:
How's that for confidence! :)
You can feel the difference instantly. The very first stroke will show you why I think horsehide is sooooo damn good! But remember, this is always used bare, and is always the very last step in the sharpening process.


Stitchawl
 
Trial and error here.

My grandfather had a few whetstones and I was always trying to imitate that man. He had a Caterpillar cap, I HAD to have a Cat hat. He had a Schrade, I HAD to have a Schrade too. A sharpening stone seemed to be the next "must have" item.

I was young, probably seven or eight, when I started learning to sharpen. Different times back then as I had already been shooting .22s at that young age. A small soft Arkansas stone fit the bill and I had a bottle of honing oil, Smith's probably.

Then I had the tri hone, ceramic stones, crock sticks and other Arkansas stones over the course of my youth. In college, when I was running my own little woodworking shop, I had a set of 8 inch stones from Woodcraft; Washita, soft Ark, hard Ark, and black Ark that cost me a pretty penny.

Used them for years and still have them. Wife bought me a Lansky kit for Christmas one year and then a Sharpmaker a few years later. Went on to learn about stropping some moons ago and have just now discovered Hand American one micron diamond spray on a piece of wood as a strop.

I doubt I can get a blade much sharper than I can get them now. But it has been an evolving process over a lifetime and has occupied my time and relaxed me when I needed to de-stress.

Great hobby and useful too. I keep half my department going with their knives as very few know how to do it themselves.
 
I researched sharpening techniques and found the best method for home to be the bottom of a porcelain cup, plate or bowl. I have a mish mash of cups so I have some course and some fine, to varying degrees. I can get my knives razor sharp using this method. I also learned to strop on an old belt. In the bush I carry a cheap 2 sided stone and a pocket sharpener, if all else fails I can use rocks. The whole point of sharpening for me is to put a sharp, sustainable edge on my buck 110, not using fancy expensive tools or techniques. I know it is sharp because just the other day I was cutting a plastic fastener and when the knife came through is just bumped my finger and cut it to the bone. At first I didn't know I was cut, it was such a light tap and it didn't hurt much or bleed but I felt it hit the bone. Then it started to itch and bleed. To the touch it feels like the edge of a piece of broken glass, smooth and almost dull but with light pressure it cuts easily. It is extremely sharp, easy to maintain and the edge does not fall over.
 
I started sharpening on a cheap stone that came with an imitation rambo knife before I was 10. The first knife I tried to sharpen on my own was a rip-off SAK.

I watched my dad sharpen on a CrockStix setup as long as I can remember. When I turned 12 and passed my Hunter's Safety course, Dad gave me a Buck Squire with Cocobolo scales in a beautiful black leather sheath. To be quite honest, I have never used that knife. I graduated to using Dad's sharpener that same year circa 1988.

I took a metal working class in 12th grade and one of the tests was to sharpen a 1" folding knife. The only sharpening supplies we were allowed to use was a tri-stone set similar to what booker purchased. I got a "C" on that test and was very upset because at home with the CrockStix I could get hair shaving sharpness. That same year I took over the family sharpening responsiblities for kitchen, utility and hunting knives.

I went to college and met a really excellent family of missionaries. At Christmas time, I received from the eldest son in that family a Spyderco imported knife. That was December 1995 and I bought the Spyderco Sharpmaker in January 1996 after researching the company. I was hooked. A few years later, I picked up the Spyderco Diamond rods for the sharpmaker.

I used that setup exclusively up through February 2007 when I moved back to PA from CO. That is when I started investing more time in online forums and when I picked up my first Scandi ground and convex ground knives. That is when I started experimenting with sandpaper over various materials.

Then I remembered that I had purchased a set of wheels from Rocky Mtn Speciaty Gear which I mounted and started to use. Then I ordered a set of the wheels richardj promotes for my mobile sharpening efforts. I also picked up a couple of 1"x30" belt sanders from Grizzly and Harbor Freight. I also have a 2"x72" belt grinder from Grizzly.
 
Back
Top