How long it will take me to start saving money by wet shaving: a calculation

I bought a Futur (love it), a Futur-style brush (love it), a Merkur bowl, and a nice stand. It was expensive, $270 as I recall.

The last time I bought them, Sensor cartridges cost $30 for a package of five. I typically got six shaves from a Sensor cartridge. That is one dollar per shave.

Canned lather costs about four bucks per can and there's typically about twenty shaves per can. That's about 16-20 cents per shave.

Feather blades are the most expensive DE blades. Westcoastshaving sells them for $40 per hundred, 40 cents each. I reliably get four good shaves from each, so that is ten cents per shave.

I just finished a cake of DR Harris soap that cost $15 (yes, fifteen dollars for a cake of soap!). But, that cake of soap, pricey as it is, has 120 shaves in it, 12.5 cents per shave.

$1 + $0.16 = $1.16 per shave with cartridge and can

$0.10 + $0.125 = $0.225 per shave with deluxe DE

$1.16 - $0.225 = $0.935 savings per day, $341 per year.

So, my very top-of-the-line kit was paid for in about nine months and I made $70 the first year. Now, I make a real savings of $341 per year. The razor, bowl, and stand will, with minimal care, last for a lifetime. The brush will need to be re-knotted perhaps every ten years at a cost of about $50.

I want to emphasize that that $341 per year is real savings. It's hard to see it because it comes 93.5 cents per day. It is money you don't spend at the grocery store for cartridges and cans. Instead of spending four bucks every three weeks for another can and thirty more every month for cartridges (notice that they stagger those so you rarely buy both at the same time), all through the year, you will go to westcoastshaving and order a hundred blades for $40 (400 shaves) and three cakes of DR Harris soap for $45 (thus qualifying for free shipping) and you are set for the year.

And Bic blades are, in my opinion, 97% as good as Feathers for literally half the price and I get six good shaves from each of them. Redo the math with those and the savings is even better.

$341 will pay for three nights in a nice hotel near the Cobb Galeria Center in Atlanta, Georgia each year with a little left over for ground transportation and even meals.

And here's the other thing to consider. You can a nice razor for less than $20. A very nice brush can be had in the $50 range. I think a stand is nice to have, but you can get a nice one in the $20 range. And there are plenty of options for a bowl in the $5 range. So, you can get a great kit together for under $100 without much effort. Then, your payoff is in about three or four months.
 
If you go to an "antique store" or flea market, you can often find excellent DE razors which, after an hour of TLC will be ready to give a lifetime of shaves, in the $10 range. There are nice brushes available in the $25 range. A stand isn't necessary. Bowls are available in the $5 range. So, $40 can assemble a good kit.

And there are serviceable brushes for $10 and you can probably find a usable bowl in your kitchen, so you can get a kit together for about $20. Now, your payoff is in weeks.

Of course, the question then is what is the difference? How much better is the shaving experience with a $300 top-of-the-line kit vs. that $20 kit? The answer is that it is a bit easier and faster to get a lather with a better brush and the better brush is a more luxurious feel. But, those old razors shave just as well as the new ones (the magic is in the blade and the same blades are used in both). So the difference is going to be mostly in the making of the lather and the experience of the brush, and that's really minor. bIt also means that if you're contemplating how to spend a limited budget getting set for DE shaving, focus on the brush more than anything.
 
Last edited:
The brush will need to be re-knotted perhaps every ten years at a cost of about $50

I just wanted to let you know that you are guessing a little high on that, unless you are either going to have someone else do the work for you, or you are factoring in inflation over the 10 years. You can get a 22mm Silvertip knot for under $17 from TGN and shipping is cheap because it is just a bunch of hair that gets sent in an envelope. There are more expensive knots there but there are also cheaper ones. Even then $50 over 10 years, that means that you brush cost less than 2 cents a day to maintain:eek:
 
Why not get a Nice straight razor,a fine grit water stone, a decent leather strop in addition to the brush, soap, and maybe a styptic pen. Drop the disposable blades, the stand, the kettle, the expensive handmade scuttle. Now that you aren't using any disposable blades, and are now sharpening and honing the same piece of steel, you are bound to save money a lot faster than 3.5 years. Possibly even cut it in half. Remember, it is the quality of the razor itself, not of the scales. If the only decent one within your price range has composite handles, get that, as long as it has a properly heat treated high carbon steel with a nice angle on it. A little more practice and experience is involved, but it is a joy to shave with a real straight razor.
-Febeleh
2011
 
Last day I shaved was Easter 9 years ago. Best. Decision. Ever. Now I have a burly well groomed man beard that costs me ZERO dollars and commands respect. Unless your LEO or military why not just go full beard? It makes young men look wiser and old men look stronger.
 
Last day I shaved was Easter 9 years ago. Best. Decision. Ever. Now I have a burly well groomed man beard that costs me ZERO dollars and commands respect. Unless your LEO or military why not just go full beard? It makes young men look wiser and old men look stronger.

Had a full beard for about 25 years. When it went white I shaved it off. Got tired being constantly asked if I qualified for seniors discount when I was in my 40's. Learned how to properly shave and enjoy it.
 
I had a beard for about a year before I joined the army, but it was patchy thanks to my genes. I've been wet shaving for about a year now and love it. I had an initial investment of probably around 200 or so, with must stuff picked up off the forums of badger and blade. Since then ive invested maybe 50 dollars because I had acquired so much from my initial investment. I probably have around 10 tubs of shaving cream, 3 soaps, 3 razors, 2 brushes, and about 200 blades. I figured I've got years and years of shaving left from the money I have spent so far. It probably will eventually become cheaper than cartridge shaving, but I have no idea when. It's really more of a matter of personal preferance because the money saved doesn't even compare with anyones other expenses for a month.
 
BiC single blade (99 cents for a bag of 10 if you happen on a deal). Shave after a shower, no gel needed. Say, about 1 cent a shave.

Ditto. Except I shave in the shower while the water is nice and hot, no cream needed or goo needed.
 
To be brutally honest one DE razor if taken care of will last a few generations. My oldest razor is a 1921 Gillette Single Ring, yes the silver plating is getting thin in places, but the razor itself works just a good as the day it was made, and I think it will still be going strong when I am gone

I learned to shave (and still do) with my great grandfather's adjustable Gillette DE. Not sure what model it is, but it gives a great shave.
 
I learned to shave (and still do) with my great grandfather's adjustable Gillette DE. Not sure what model it is, but it gives a great shave.

See there is 3 generations right there, and I think unless it befalls an unfortunate accident it could probably make a couple more, my 1962 Slim has a good 70+ years left in it.
 
Late to the party as usual.

I'm still using a $15 red tip Gillette I got off B&B and a $10 boar brush (Jeff likes his brushes bristly for exfoliation). They only thing I sampled were blades, soaps, and creams. I'm content with Proraso shave cream (I prefer creams) and Crystal blades aka Israeli personnas. Both are easy to find. I know I've saved a lot of money and my face/skin looks and feels better.

Much like knives, I just don't go for the expensive products (I've tried Trumpers, TOBS, AoS, T&H, etc).
 
Back
Top