Way back when, I, along with a group of other people, had the effects of hypothermia demonstrated rather forcefully.
We were trying to be accepted (it was called indoc phase) into an organization. It was actually a pretty simple procedure: we were made to lie, fully dressed, in water for for two hours (seemed like two days), then come out and try to accomplish simple tasks involving childrens toys. The toys were meant for toddlers: you know the kind; put shapes (stars, rectangles, circles, etc.) into a matching board, and to stack various size rings in size order on a little pole. Pretty simple stuff, right? Well, the first time we tried it, it was exceedingly difficult: the cold water had made us so numb that our motor skills had suffered tremendously, and our thought processes had slowed down as well. We then donned a heavy pack, ran a couple of miles, then repeated the entire process (back in the water, and start over). We did that three times. At the end, only four of us (out of twenty-nine) were left to go further in the testing: the others had either quit or were dropped.
By the third time we came out of the water, it was taking us an incredibly long time to complete the tasks: neither mind nor body was functioning correctly. Hell, we didn't even know who we were anymore.
Did all this take place in some frozen lake somewhere? No, it took place in the surf and on the beach in sunny Southern California, in September. The water at that time of year is probably 50 to 60 degrees F., and the air temperature was probably in the high 60s or low 70s. Were we in actual danger of dying from this at the time? No, we were monitored pretty closely, but it pounded home the effects of simple hypothermia.
Now think of what happens when you fall into icy freezing water on a day where the air temperature is maybe just above freezing, and theres any kind of wind at all. Thats right: your bodys going to try to shut down. Assuming you can even pull yourself out of the water, your chances of survival are very slim, unless you have someone there to help. You, yourself, will probably be incapable of the mental or physical things that would be necessary to save your life.
Whats the moral of this story, boys and girls? Take precautions. Take a friend. Think about how to get warm before you venture onto the ice.