I admit that I am a Benchmade guy over Spyderco

Over time, I've found that the monetarily accessible options in steel mixed with practical aspects of design have led me to Spyderco again and again.
 
Oakengroves said:
Spyderco and Benchmade are the worst companies to compare.

Both set industry standards for high-quality that come in at an incredibly high value. Each company offers superb warranty services, excellent designs, and lead the industry in terms of innovation and style.
Click to expand...


I'm confused. You say they aren't good companies to compare, then list a handful of reasons why they would be great companies to compare.

I'm an AXIS fan over anything else. I own more Spyderco though.
 
I don't consider the Manix to be the best knife to judge Spyderco, it is probably my least favorite.
I tend to like both manufacturers about equally, with a slight nod going towards Spyderco.
 
Considering that I have four of the Gold Class models I definitely have spent more on Benchmade but I own more Spydercos <shrug>
 
estate4life said:
I think it really varies from person to person. I've heard so many go review on Spyderco. After getting my first Spyderco Manix 2 XL today, I was disappointed. Everything about it feels awkward? Somewhat uncomfortable....guess maybe it's just me. I mean, it looks nice, feels good but somehow I am unable to open blade smoothly. The ball lock so stiff....cannot close normally.

IDK....I think maybe it's every knife must be compatible with user. Or just my hands....
Click to expand...


I guess ergonomics are largely preferential, but in house Spyderco designs are made "in the dark", giving almost no consideration to looks. Once you know that Spyderco knives look so "different" largely because they're made to appeal to your hand and not your eye, things take on a different perspective.
If it weren't for Sal I would be, a Kershaw guy, but Benchmade would probably still come in a close second place. My Benchmade knives have had some of the best fit and finish I've ever seen (Benchmade seems to be able to get super smooth pivot action with no blade play much more consistently than the competition).

But, Spyderco interacts with their customers, and that's more valuable to me than extra fit and finish.
 
Joshua J. said:
I guess ergonomics are largely preferential, but in house Spyderco designs are made "in the dark", giving almost no consideration to looks. Once you know that Spyderco knives look so "different" largely because they're made to appeal to your hand and not your eye, things take on a different perspective.
If it weren't for Sal I would be, a Kershaw guy, but Benchmade would probably still come in a close second place. My Benchmade knives have had some of the best fit and finish I've ever seen (Benchmade seems to be able to get super smooth pivot action with no blade play much more consistently than the competition).

But, Spyderco interacts with their customers, and that's more valuable to me than extra fit and finish.
Click to expand...

+1

Exactly. And Sal's interaction and integration of user/collector suggestion into design and revision is and has been paramount.
It's an example that really should be implemented in other industries.
 
They are both great knife companies. For me personally brand loyalty plays no part. I have more Spyderco only because I have been attracted to more of their designs. Both companies make knives of all shapes and sizes from big (Adamas or Manix XL) to small and narrow (Sequel 707 and Air) and everything in between so most everyone can find something that fits them well no matter the brand. I have not had enough fit and finish issues with either company that I think that is a factor either. I buy from both with a big cheesy grin on my face. :D (until I see my bank statement :thumbdn:)

I used to think Benchmades were more expensive but at the price point most of the new Spydercos are coming out at I no longer feel that is the case.
 
Sounds to me like you are trying to compare an apple to an orange. The Axis lock and the CBBL are very differeent mechanically as well as visually. No problem opening the blade for me. You can't really close the knife with the thumb alone.
 
Wow...I never thought this thread will have so many great feedback...tks! i THINK I FOUND my problem with this particular Manix XL. Believe it or not, i try using my left hand (i'm right handed) and it works well when i use my left hand. Open & close smoothly. But not my right....It happens to be the pocket clip position which do not allow me to pinch the handle with my middle, ring fingers... the pocket clip gets in the way. Not only that you need to pinch the lock, you need to pull it down a bit to release blade.
 
Yup, the pocket clip is not allowing me to pinch the handle with my right hand, middle, ring & pinky fingers.

IMG_0615_zps1d977907.jpg


i was able to do it with my left hand, even if I am not left handed. I swap the pocket clip to the other side.
 
I can agree.
My Native 5 didn't really please.
I'm not saying it "sucks", but beleive it or not, I like my Griptilian more.
Plus I think Benchmade knives look better.
 
I am keeping this Spyderco just because I want the own one...I'll try practicing with this and see how it goes...but to me, Benchmade is so much easier on the hands...I have rough hand, like mechanic or construction worker so for some reason, all the Benchmade I've own, I just pick up and use it, no need thinking...AXIS lock rocks...the Kershaw speedsafe opens smooths too...some knive under $30 are best beaters...

IDK, I may try a few more Spydie and see...but from what I've learn, thumbs down on the Ball Lock.
 
Spyerco has a few things that are important to me:

1. Thumb hole
2. choil
3. great steel
4. price

I love my BMs, but i'd rank as the following:

#1 of all time: Manix 2
2: BM 15020
3. Manix 2 XL
4. BM 550

You can tell I love both companies. The CBBL is amazing, I like it more than the Axis lock due to only having one spring.

I can agree.
My Native 5 didn't really please.
Click to expand...

DId you have the FRN Native prior to getting the Native 5? I only ask as the Native is a neat knife, but you really had to love the design to pay the increase for the 5.
 
estate4life said:
Maybe yeah, I was trying to thumb down rather than pinch....
Click to expand...

Happened to me too, the pinch technique takes a bit of practice. It's just as quick once you get the hang of it. The ergonomics of the M2 and MXL are extraordinary, again it just takes a bit of getting used to. Overall, it's a great value for the price tag, hard to beat such a beefy knife for the price.
 
I would own a military and para 2 if they had an axis lock on them.
I have only owned one Spyderco, about 15 years ago. I think it was called the pro venator?
 
The compression lock is hands down my favorite locking mechanism. I don't even own my para2 any more but god damn is that compression lock awesome.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top