I know absolutely nothing about traditionals.

The only problem with that outlook is, you'll waste a lot of money trying to find out what you really like. Somebody may be attracted to the history of the barlow, but when they gt it, they don't like the feel, or the way it lays in the pocket. Or they may want to try a peanut. Then they spend 30 something dollars to find out that it's too small for their hand.

Better to try a 10 dollar Rough Rider and end you don't like it, than a three or even four times as expensive a knife and be stuck for the full price. At the worst, with knives like Rough Rider and Steel Warrior, you'll have a very workable beater knife in the drawer for those jbs that you know absolutely, positively will mess up a "good" blade! :)

Most people will baby the Case. But they will feel free to use the 10 dollar knife to abuse.

I generally recommend Rough Rider traditional knives. I don't know if I would baby a typical Case knife, but I do pay attention to what I cut with GEC's. Of the ones I use, I don't really baby the GEC's either.

I have bought a number of GEC slippies in the last month. It came to me today when I ordered the two blade weasel that if I am not excited about a purchase enough to look forward to it arriving in the mail, I'm not going to bother. Some of the one's I purchased earlier are "just knives", but I'm excited about the weasel. No more GEC purchases "just because"; I have enough of them. I do think I will buy a two blade #54 when it comes out.
 
Call me a broken record, because I've said this a dozen times before and probably will several times over again, but:

USA made Old Timer! They make a great starter traditional! You can get them used on Ebay (kinda dirty but solid) for $15-$20. I have a bunch of them, they're plain but good, no-nonsense user knives. If you're patient/lucky like me then you can find them in bunches for a significantly lower per-knife cost. I own about 20 Old Timers of varying condition, and have paid about an average of $5 per knife by buying them in lots. Especially when you're new, there's a difference between what a knife looks like online and how it actually is in real life, it's good to learn the ropes on the cheapies before you spend $100+ on a GEC and don't get what you expect.

The low price and relatively high quality lets you test out different patterns without breaking the bank or spoiling a good pattern with poor quality. Once you find a pattern you like, then go ahead and buy a more expensive brand if you want. Avoid the Taylor/China ones, their QC is very poor and it's easy to end up with a lemon.

This is my current carry knife, a 106OT and also my most expensive OT at $22 because it's a less common pattern. Even the tiny little stockman patterns have good blade alignment. I've had a few 108s and none of them had any blade rub.

The lower picture is one of my 108s, the stockman is a good starter patterns because it lets you try three different blade styles in one knife and they come in a wide variety of sizes, and every brand makes them.

onu28E0.jpg

e3GNgxT.jpg
 
When I mentioned wharncliffe, I really meant anything​ with a straight or mostly straight edge--sheepsfoot etc.

In that I'm used to spending well over $100 on modern folders, the price for a "nicer" slipjoint is not particularly daunting. I know that if it's too small or I don't like it, I will hang on to it to give to one of my nephews when they are old enough.

I already carry a medium Vic, so multiple bladed/scissors do not interest me, such as stockmans.

I've been doing a lot of browsing, and have narrowed down quite a bit.

I thank y'all for all your help, and will keep you informed of what I choose.

Btw, what is y'all's opinion of kirinite?

Sent via carrier pigeon
 
When I mentioned wharncliffe, I really meant anything​ with a straight or mostly straight edge--sheepsfoot etc.

In that I'm used to spending well over $100 on modern folders, the price for a "nicer" slipjoint is not particularly daunting. I know that if it's too small or I don't like it, I will hang on to it to give to one of my nephews when they are old enough.

I already carry a medium Vic, so multiple bladed/scissors do not interest me, such as stockmans.

I've been doing a lot of browsing, and have narrowed down quite a bit.

I thank y'all for all your help, and will keep you informed of what I choose.

Btw, what is y'all's opinion of kirinite?

Sent via carrier pigeon

It's alright I guess if you want something a little flashier on your traditional knife. Case made it in a patriotic color I think is why I like it.

Case also makes the best kirinite of all the companies.
 
How about trying out a GEC 73? One of their first models and available in a vast range of scales/finishes. Some even have a liner-lock as well as the backspring. Good size for most, not too big or small, 3.75" closed.

IMG_1532.jpg
 
Gec 72 in wharnie great knife, I traded mine out not too long ago.

868f75453f55d04de17f4640b85bdd84.jpg



PS in case you are wondering why I got rid of a knife I thought was stupendous. I figured out not too long ago that I like to carry 3.5" or smaller traditionals or larger moderns.
 
Last edited:
There are two patterns that I would recommend you check out

First is the Case Swayback Jack. This is just an amazing traditional pattern
IMG_2829_zps5iutgpot.jpg


Second is the classic stockman. My 1st choice is always this one that I've carried and used on and off over the last 7+ years (knife on the bottom)
IMG_0557_zps0f6037f2.jpg
 
KOD if you are interested in trying out a mini copperlock or the mini wharncliffe trapper let let me know and I can send them over to you to check out. Send em back after. You mentioned that you might not like traditionals that were too small. The regular size copperlock is pretty awesome in hand it kinda reminds me of a Ti Sebenza. Just let me know and I'll put em in the mail.

Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk
 
...in case you are wondering why I got rid of a knife I thought was stupendous. I figured out not too long ago that I like to carry 3.5" or smaller traditionals or larger moderns.

I believe the #72 is 3 7/8", not a lot of difference from 3.5". I have also been trying out the smaller GEC's with the acquisition of the #14 Lick Creek Boys knife and the #14 Barlow that CC had made. They are great little knives and run about 3.1" closed (3.07" if you want to be technical).

The Acrylics that are made today are pretty durable.
 
Last edited:
I actually went ahead and bought something. Used my birthday money. Or some of it. The only hint I'll give is that it's a Case. The mail lady is bringing it tomorrow. Hopefully she doesn't bring along a son or daughter I don't know about.

Sent from my Pixel using Tapatalk
 
I actually went ahead and bought something. Used my birthday money. Or some of it. The only hint I'll give is that it's a Case. The mail lady is bringing it tomorrow. Hopefully she doesn't bring along a son or daughter I don't know about.

Sent from my Pixel using Tapatalk
Nice! Traditionals are really enjoyable to edc! There's just something aesthetically pleasing about how compact they are. It's funny I've actually been searching for a modern that feels like a traditional and am leaning towards an al Mar or moki lockback.

Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk
 
My advice after buying waaaay too many knives is: Get 3 Rough Riders, a large single blade (4"+), a medium stockman (3⅜-3¾") and a small two-blade (3"-) and see which one you like the most. Give 'em each a good week or two carry before you decide, then buy a nicer one in the pattern you know you'll appreciate.
 
I actually went ahead and bought something. Used my birthday money. Or some of it. The only hint I'll give is that it's a Case. The mail lady is bringing it tomorrow. Hopefully she doesn't bring along a son or daughter I don't know about.

Looking forward to seeing which Case you chose. Just for the fun of it, I'll take a wild guess. Swayback Gent with Krinite covers.
 
Nice! Traditionals are really enjoyable to edc! There's just something aesthetically pleasing about how compact they are. It's funny I've actually been searching for a modern that feels like a traditional and am leaning towards an al Mar or moki lockback.

Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk


Nice! Traditionals are really enjoyable to edc! There's just something aesthetically pleasing about how compact they are. It's funny I've actually been searching for a modern that feels like a traditional and am leaning towards an al Mar or moki lockback.

Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk

For the first time in probably twenty years, I've only been carrying an SAK, my new super tinker. At first I've felt naked not having a modern folder clipped to my pocket, but I'm​ getting used to it.

Friday, Saturday and part of Sunday I was at a water park hotel in Lake Geneva, birthday party for me with my 3 and 4 year old nephews. I only brought the SAK. I figured with the little ones around, it'd be too easy for them to open a modern folder and hurt themselves. I used the scissors more than anything, cutting off the water park wrist bands at the end of the day.

I'm very excited about the new knife, though it's still a new experience leaving my modern folders in the case. My primary reason for getting into traditional slipjoints is because I like how they look and are less likely to cause a problem if I need to cut something in public.

With the stupid blade length law in Chicago, the less attention drawn, the better.

Now I'm anxiously waiting for the mail.
Your mail lady delivers children?
I'm hoping not, or I may have some explaining to do, even if I'm no longer married.

Sent from my Pixel using Tapatalk
 
Checked USPS tracking and I will be picking up my new two blade Weasel today. I just have to resist these urges. I don't collect but I am certainly accumulating more than enough.

Really hard to beat a Vic SAK. I am about to go back to mostly carrying my Vic Adventurer (discontinued) after about a two month visit with the GEC #71. I just find it too useful to leave behind.
 
For the first time in probably twenty years, I've only been carrying an SAK, my new super tinker. At first I've felt naked not having a modern folder clipped to my pocket, but I'm​ getting used to it.

Friday, Saturday and part of Sunday I was at a water park hotel in Lake Geneva, birthday party for me with my 3 and 4 year old nephews. I only brought the SAK. I figured with the little ones around, it'd be too easy for them to open a modern folder and hurt themselves. I used the scissors more than anything, cutting off the water park wrist bands at the end of the day.

I'm very excited about the new knife, though it's still a new experience leaving my modern folders in the case. My primary reason for getting into traditional slipjoints is because I like how they look and are less likely to cause a problem if I need to cut something in public.

With the stupid blade length law in Chicago, the less attention drawn, the better.


I strongly prefer traditionals for many reasons and the people friendly aspect of them is high on that list. One thing I've found is that they are so people friendly, they allow me to carry more blade than the letter of the law might dictate - sort of like the way a Camry doing 80 is safer than a Vette doing 75 in terms of getting a ticket.

Huge ditto on the utility of a few tools and scissors. I get frustrated with the ergos of multi blade slip joints so my combo is a single blade traditional and a small tool like this. Key is to pocket carry the tool. Get it off of the key ring.

Schrade 5OT & Micra by Pinnah, on Flickr

That knife is a Schrade 5OT and will give you a familiar feel to many traditionals. The Buck 501 is of similar size. Good luck on the journey.
 
For the first time in probably twenty years, I've only been carrying an SAK, my new super tinker. At first I've felt naked not having a modern folder clipped to my pocket, but I'm​ getting used to it.

Friday, Saturday and part of Sunday I was at a water park hotel in Lake Geneva, birthday party for me with my 3 and 4 year old nephews. I only brought the SAK. I figured with the little ones around, it'd be too easy for them to open a modern folder and hurt themselves. I used the scissors more than anything, cutting off the water park wrist bands at the end of the day.

I'm very excited about the new knife, though it's still a new experience leaving my modern folders in the case. My primary reason for getting into traditional slipjoints is because I like how they look and are less likely to cause a problem if I need to cut something in public.

With the stupid blade length law in Chicago, the less attention drawn, the better.

Now I'm anxiously waiting for the mail.

I'm hoping not, or I may have some explaining to do, even if I'm no longer married.

Sent from my Pixel using Tapatalk

K.O.D., your post rings a few bells with me.

I've gravitated to smaller knives my whole life, one reason being that most of the menfolks in my life growing up in an age when cars had tail fins and James Dean was alive and rebelling, almost al carried a smallish two blade jack of some pattern or another. Serpintine jack, dogleg jack, equal end jack. The other reason was, grown cup in and around Washington D.C., knife laws were on the strict side. So many government buildings, so much scrutiny on what you carried in some places. Toss into that mix, a father who carried a small Case peanut, and that cemented things.

For a very brief period, I got int some larger knives, like large sodbusters by Eye-Brand and Case, some large lock blades like the Mercator K55 and large Puma's. Then I did a downsize and at first it seemed like I was under knifed. Especially when I started to carry a peanut. But the more I stuck it out, the more I got used to and noticed how the smaller blades really did everything a pocket knife was supposed to do. And the multi blade thing got me too used to having an extra blade to tool on hand. When I got into SAK's, I found it hard to go with a "regular" knife anymore. It got very handy to have a few basic tools in the pocket on a small pocketable package. A screw driver was very nice, and scissors are so handy that when you need them, nothing else will really do. Especially if theres kids around.

Even now living in Texas, having moved from my high restrictive state of Maryland, I'm still carrying small traditional pocket knives and SAK's. Just too handy to go without. The kids are all grown and gone now, but that leaves grandkids, and our youngest is visiting from California for spring break. We needed to replace some batteries on one of her electronic do-hickies, and it was nice just stopping by a convenience store for two AAA batteries, and using the little screw driver on a keychain SAK to remove the battery cover and stick in the new ones and screw back the cover and we were on the way. I don't think a so called tactical one hander would have done the job.

I think there is a very good reason the traditional pocket knives and SAK's have stood up to the test of centuries. They do flat out work for a very wide variety of situations. The more you use the traditional's the more you will come to appreciate the increased real estate in the pocket, and the easy way they cut, and the low profile of the tool. Someday, a year from now, or two years from now, you find yourself selling off the 'other' knives.
 
I always keep this Cadet in my work bag. I'm a little embarrassed to say that I fimd the nail cleaning tool supremely handy as I often absent minded switch from household chore mode to office work mode and find my fingernails to be dirty from the prior evenings tasks at home.

I wonder why I don't edc the Cadet more except that I rotate some smaller traditionals that I really enjoy.
4f13c70ee5efb44f292fa6647bffb955.jpg


Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk
 
I always keep this Cadet in my work bag. I'm a little embarrassed to say that I fimd the nail cleaning tool supremely handy as I often absent minded switch from household chore mode to office work mode and find my fingernails to be dirty from the prior evenings tasks at home.

I wonder why I don't edc the Cadet more except that I rotate some smaller traditionals that I really enjoy.
4f13c70ee5efb44f292fa6647bffb955.jpg


Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk

And that nail file tip makes a very good tiny phillips driver in a pinch.:thumbup:
 
Back
Top