Jerry is right. Side by side, no BS testing is what we'd all like to see. You'd think that publications like Blade Magazine would be happy to do unbiased comparison testing, but then they survive by selling ads -- and if some of their clients came out poorly...
I subscribed to Gun Tests for a number of years. Is there an no-ads publication for knives? Maybe that would do it.
Naturally, we'd all LIKE to see Lynn Thompson and Jerry Busse, side by side, hacking thousands of pieces of 1" rope, chopping 2x4s, shaving, etc. But it's not likely. And if any one maker conducts such a test, people will say he rigged it to make his products look good.
We need a respected source like a knife publication. Letter writing campaign anyone?
Heck, I'm even curious about other things. I'd like to take three identical knives (like SHII, since I have one), put the convex grind on one, a straight tapered edge on another, and the unique asymmetrical "Busse edge" on another. Then run a comparison test. Of course, it might show quicker results if we ran the test with three knives of lesser material...
All the Best, friends. I guess for now I'll do my own field testing. And put me with the group that has more use for tools that don't break, than for written guarantees.
Lane