I need help finding the right knife!

Joined
May 20, 2014
Messages
6
I have been looking for a good knife for the past 6 months now and im looking for a knife that is good for hunting, fishing, camping, hiking and general bushcraft. i was thinking for a price of under 200$ and something i can baton with, skin animals, carve, chop, and defend myself with. also something with good steel that can take beating and still hold up good along with a comfy handle and is anywheres from 9"-10" OA length! I would like a knife that comes with a good sheath or a knife cheap enough that i can order a custom one without going over 200$! I need help!!!
 
Take a look at the KAR-BAR USN mark 1 .it's a good all round knife . welcome to bf :)
 
Last edited:
I have been looking for a good knife for the past 6 months now and im looking for a knife that is good for hunting, fishing, camping, hiking and general bushcraft. i was thinking for a price of under 200$ and something i can baton with, skin animals, carve, chop, and defend myself with. also something with good steel that can take beating and still hold up good along with a comfy handle and is anywheres from 9"-10" OA length! I would like a knife that comes with a good sheath or a knife cheap enough that i can order a custom one without going over 200$! I need help!!!

If you have been looking for 6 months already you already know there isn't one, not really....

You are asking a lot of one knife in the $200 and under range.

Take away the batoning, chopping and all that other stuff and your options open up a lot because all of that makes the knife pretty useless for the rest of your list.

Start looking for a nice fixed blade that will fit your hunting, skinning, fishing etc... Normal uses.... Things that you actually will use the knife for.....

Then get a Machete or a hatchet for the rest of the stuff......
 
If you have been looking for 6 months already you already know there isn't one, not really....

You are asking a lot of one knife in the $200 and under range.

Take away the batoning, chopping and all that other stuff and your options open up a lot because all of that makes the knife pretty useless for the rest of your list.

Start looking for a nice fixed blade that will fit your hunting, skinning, fishing etc... Normal uses.... Things that you actually will use the knife for.....

Then get a Machete or a hatchet for the rest of the stuff......


655B-500x.jpg

(655B) Curved Skinner/Sticker/Boning 6 "

870BB-500x.jpg

(870BB) General Purpose 6 1/4 "

677BB-500x.jpg

(677BB) Curved Skinner 5 3/4 "
http://www.svord.com/
 
Welcome, and yes, you do need help. The knife you're looking for does not exist.
In the interim, get a Mora Companion and any good hatchet, to cover the uses you describe. They won't impress your friends, but they will impress you, once you learn how to use and maintain them properly.
 
Soo if a hatchet would be my best choice? What hatchet should i get? I would need it light enough to pack on hikes and such?
 
Under $200 to do all of that?

EnZo Trapper: $111
trapper01blackB.jpg

http://www.thompsonsknives.com/enzoknives.html

Husqvarna Hatchet: $44.95
778369cb.jpg

http://www.amazon.com/Husqvarna-Hatchet-1-2-lbs-Handle/dp/B004VLKLJE/ref=sr_1_25?ie=UTF8&qid=1400612144&sr=8-25&keywords=hatchet

Bahco Lapplander: $19.90
71VOxs10mRL._SL1500_.jpg

http://www.amazon.com/Bahco-396-LAP-Laplander-Folding-8-Inch/dp/B0001IX7OW/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1400612263&sr=8-1&keywords=bahco+laplander+folding+saw

Total: $175.85

That is more than enough tool to solve 99% of the problems you will ever encounter while backpacking, hiking, hunting, etc. If you need a little extra insurance, get a Victorinox Hiker.
 
Yes i was thinking of getting the bahco and i really like the hatchet but thank you! what do you think of the tops bob?
 
Where'd you get those handles for your 140?

Those are the stock G-10 handles that came on the knife before they started putting those monstrous aluminum slabs on them. WAY preferred over the Al.
 
Yes i was thinking of getting the bahco and i really like the hatchet but thank you! what do you think of the tops bob?

Honestly, you'd have way better luck with the EnZo trapper. Its a simple but utilitarian design made of good materials and a wonderful heat treat. Its also a scandi-grind which really lends itself to wood working tasks. A lot of people really like the EnZo trapper for a reason. However if you really like the bob then go for the bob, never let someone talk you out of something you want, because then you'll never be happy with it! I always recommend the trapper because of its amazing bang vs buck, maybe its for you, maybe it isnt.
 
Yes i just watched some reviews on it and although it seems a bit small for my liking i see it would deffenetly get most taskes of mine done and its just overall very nice looking and seems like good quality although i only watched a few reviews! i think i might consider getting this knife! The curly birch version looks fantastic! Thank you for recommending it!
 
If it was still available, I'd call your attention to these tools. A Buck 119 knife hooked up
with an Estwing hatchet in one neat package...


0775a3cd-a1b2-4eb8-a097-26fb183eab17.jpg
 
Soo if a hatchet would be my best choice? What hatchet should i get? I would need it light enough to pack on hikes and such?


Can you tell us where you hike and camp, how far you typically hike in from the road and what other (if any) stove you carry?

I've been doing backcountry trips in all 4 seasons for many decades, mostly in woodsy New England, and can attest that you can safely travel in the backcountry with nothing more than a key-chain sized tool. Heck, people climb peaks like Everest with no more knife than that.

IME, fire making is fun and gratifying but is largely recreational. Life and death means packing the right shelter, a decent stove and knowing how to use both. Well, that and knowledge enough to stay out of trouble.

Add to this that many areas where one is likely to backpack and hike are heavily traveled by others, so wood harvesting impact can cause a lot of damage.

IMO, hatchets make sense for car camping (where you can buy wood) and for canoe camping (provided the local woods can support the wood harvest). For lowland hiking with plenty of wood and assuming fairly good distributed camping and careful wood harvest, I think a small wood stove makes sense. I use the Emberlit but there are many others. This allows the use of a campfire with really minimal fuss and impact. Also pretty much eliminates the need for heavy duty and heavy in the pack wood processing tools. At most, a small folding saw and a 4" to 5" fixed blade is more than enough to keep an Emberlit well fed, even in the rain.

Obviously, if you have a place to go where harvesting wood is not an impact issue and if having fun means cutting and chopping and burning, then by all means, have at it. Gerber and Fiskars both make light weight camping hatchets.

FWIW, here is my standard in the woods carry.
Outdoor Carry by Pinnah, on Flickr

The Opinel handles general cutting and food prep and making wood shavings. The PS4 handles gear repairs (pushing a needle through pack cloth) and bandage prep (scissors).

EDITED to ADD: the Opinel is enough to batton wood for the Emberlit, on trips where I take it. I generally carry white gas (winter) or alcohol stoves (3 season) as they're just so much easier to deal with.

Hope this helps.
 
Back
Top