I think I have a knife problem

I'm still looking for the right Mnandi...
On the lighter side of the news, I think I'm finally starting to (almost) like my small 31. It probably won't take the place of my small WC; but I'll take it.
 
Hhmoore

I’ve carried a browning 612 for 24 years.
It went through the washing machine so many times that the rubber inlay spots rotted and dissolved. I found another one on eBay about 5 years ago to replace it.
I live in rural Canada 20 miles out of town.

I say all this because the Mnandi is twice the knife that this thing is. It is plenty for EDC. I mean how much cutting are we doing?

If I go hunting I bring a skinner.
If I go fishing I bring a leather man.
If I go camping or hiking I’ll bring something larger.

The small Sebenza sure is nice though 🙂
And I can’t seem to satisfy my hunger for them CRKs

IMG_2969.png
 
I had about 15 inlay CRKs at one point and only have a S45VN large PJ Inkosi drop point now. Don't regret selling any of them. Don't believe the there is no #1 posts.
 
XL883N said:
I had about 15 inlay CRKs at one point and only have a S45VN large PJ Inkosi drop point now. Don't regret selling any of them. Don't believe the there is no #1 posts.
Click to expand...
Sounds fair to me. Different strokes, for different folks.
 
Froggy114 said:
Hhmoore

I’ve carried a browning 612 for 24 years.
It went through the washing machine so many times that the rubber inlay spots rotted and dissolved. I found another one on eBay about 5 years ago to replace it.
I live in rural Canada 20 miles out of town.

I say all this because the Mnandi is twice the knife that this thing is. It is plenty for EDC. I mean how much cutting are we doing?

If I go hunting I bring a skinner.
If I go fishing I bring a leather man.
If I go camping or hiking I’ll bring something larger.

The small Sebenza sure is nice though 🙂
And I can’t seem to satisfy my hunger for them CRKs

View attachment 2491474
Click to expand...
I carried my Mnandi as my only pocket knife for 18 months ( actually my only knife) before finding myself on a roof, in pouring drizzle/snow needing to cut a blower motor belt off a 20 ton RTU…

Back into the rabbit hole I climbed.
 
Kettleman said:
I carried my Mnandi as my only pocket knife for 18 months ( actually my only knife) before finding myself on a roof, in pouring drizzle/snow needing to cut a blower motor belt off a 20 ton RTU…

Back into the rabbit hole I climbed.
Click to expand...
Touché
 
F Froggy114 , how long did it take you to get the ones you’ve got now ? Have you carried the Mnandi? I avoided the Mnandi for years thinking it was too small. Then, a co worker wanted one and I got two, one for him and one to try out. Can’t tell you how wrong I was about it. I carry it way more than I thought I would. Here’s the problem you’re going to have, each CRK you acquire will have qualities you like and will enjoy. Logic says you don’t need all of them. Passion says you’ll need to keep them all because after all it’s not that big of a collection and they’re not readily in stock.
A bakers dozen is considered a collection ( my reasoning/justification for the ones I have), as of now you don’t have a problem, so don’t feel like you need to stop. You’ll know when that time comes. How can you really know which CRK is perfect for you unless you have a variety to choose from.
 
Ajack60 said:
F Froggy114 , how long did it take you to get the ones you’ve got now ? Have you carried the Mnandi? I avoided the Mnandi for years thinking it was too small. Then, a co worker wanted one and I got two, one for him and one to try out. Can’t tell you how wrong I was about it. I carry it way more than I thought I would. Here’s the problem you’re going to have, each CRK you acquire will have qualities you like and will enjoy. Logic says you don’t need all of them. Passion says you’ll need to keep them all because after all it’s not that big of a collection and they’re not readily in stock.
A bakers dozen is considered a collection ( my reasoning/justification for the ones I have), as of now you don’t have a problem, so don’t feel like you need to stop. You’ll know when that time comes. How can you really know which CRK is perfect for you unless you have a variety to choose from.
Click to expand...
I hear you ajak60, and I know I’m just barking up the wrong tree by saying anything other than to collect the knives.
I also understand that these things are a great investment. Would probably make me a few bucks if I hold them for a bit, or at least break even.
Thing is I am somewhat of a minimalist in general. I like to use the things I own and would have a hard time driving a different car, wearing a different jacket, or pocketing a different knife each day of the week.
One COULD say I’m in the wrong place then…

To answer your question these CRKs are all New. Within the week except the Mnandi I’ve carried it for a full week at work, but did not use it once. (I am a heavy equipment operator…Big Dozers and such)
I have tools in my truck if something really goes wrong, also there is a mechanic to call for larger issues.
It’s not that I didn’t have the chance to use it, I just improvised I’m many cases and carried my other knife as well out of fear that I would lower the value of the $850CAD Mnandi.
However in any spare time I stroked and caressed the “precious”. Lol.

I already know it would be an excellent replacement and upgrade to my beater knife. It feels better it the hand and I evaluated that it would have done every job as well or better.

If I decided to keep it as my daily carry, I would not hold back, it will be put to work with no holds barred (common sense applied of course)

I think a Mnandi and a Large inkosi will cover all the basic needs.

But ya know…. that Sebenza sure seems to be the sweet spot in the middle 😉😉

Thanks to everyone for the conversation so far, just so y’all know it really does help me while I’m wrestling with my own thoughts.

Took the clip off the larges. OH SO MUCH better in the hand!
 

Attachments

  • IMG_2971.jpeg
    IMG_2971.jpeg
    530.1 KB · Views: 8
Froggy114 said:
I hear you ajak60, and I know I’m just barking up the wrong tree by saying anything other than to collect the knives.
I also understand that these things are a great investment. Would probably make me a few bucks if I hold them for a bit, or at least break even.
Thing is I am somewhat of a minimalist in general. I like to use the things I own and would have a hard time driving a different car, wearing a different jacket, or pocketing a different knife each day of the week.
One COULD say I’m in the wrong place then…

To answer your question these CRKs are all New. Within the week except the Mnandi I’ve carried it for a full week at work, but did not use it once. (I am a heavy equipment operator…Big Dozers and such)
I have tools in my truck if something really goes wrong, also there is a mechanic to call for larger issues.
It’s not that I didn’t have the chance to use it, I just improvised I’m many cases and carried my other knife as well out of fear that I would lower the value of the $850CAD Mnandi.
However in any spare time I stroked and caressed the “precious”. Lol.

I already know it would be an excellent replacement and upgrade to my beater knife. It feels better it the hand and I evaluated that it would have done every job as well or better.

If I decided to keep it as my daily carry, I would not hold back, it will be put to work with no holds barred (common sense applied of course)

I think a Mnandi and a Large inkosi will cover all the basic needs.

But ya know…. that Sebenza sure seems to be the sweet spot in the middle 😉😉

Thanks to everyone for the conversation so far, just so y’all know it really does help me while I’m wrestling with my own thoughts.

Took the clip off the larges. OH SO MUCH better in the hand!
Click to expand...
I often carry clipless, though not because the clip bothers my grip. Even with a clip I tend to drop it down in my pocket. If you decide to go that way the little filler tab is a nice edition.

I carry 2 knives regularly because it’s hard to have one knife ideally suited for every task, and 2 knives it twice the fun. Your idea of a large Inkosi or Large Sebenza plus a Mnandi would seem like perfect combo.

I cannot help with the Inkosi v Sebenza debate, but plenty around here will weigh in on both sides (and some will argue both sides simultaneously 😉)
IMG_2680.jpeg
 
I prefer the inkosi over the sebenza but it shouldn’t be taken as a knock against the sebenza.

I prefer the second choil, jimping on the blade, adjustable pivot and thicker blade stock of the inkosi.

It’s the opposite when it comes to the smalls, I prefer the sebenza over the inkosi. I truly believe the small sebenza is probably the greatest edc knife ever made. Great size for carrying in the pocket but built to be able to handle anything in its way.
 
mitchnola said:
I prefer the inkosi over the sebenza but it shouldn’t be taken as a knock against the sebenza.

I prefer the second choil, jimping on the blade, adjustable pivot and thicker blade stock of the inkosi.

It’s the opposite when it comes to the smalls, I prefer the sebenza over the inkosi. I truly believe the small sebenza is probably the greatest edc knife ever made. Great size for carrying in the pocket but built to be able to handle anything in its way.
Click to expand...
Now I want to try an Inkosi...thanks
 
I was about to say “then let the show begin” but you already got the party started Mitchnola!

I agree with the points you have made. Blade handle balance seems more equal on inkosi as well. Larger pivot looks stronger. Much easier to disassemble and re assemble. Screws and bronze are all practically (though maybe not preferably) interchangeable.

Lanyard is a hot spot for my hand heal though. I was taking it off as I read your message
 
Froggy114 said:
I was about to say “then let the show begin” but you already got the party started Mitchnola!

I agree with the points you have made. Blade handle balance seems more equal on inkosi as well. Larger pivot looks stronger. Much easier to disassemble and re assemble. Screws and bronze are all practically (though maybe not preferably) interchangeable.

Lanyard is a hot spot for my hand heal though. I was taking it off as I read your message
Click to expand...
Agreed, lanyard location is not ideal. I leave them on and have added lanyards to most of my knives because it really does help pulling out the pocket so I just deal with it. Doesn’t bother me that much.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top