Ok, Haebbie's assessment is sound. tex, the knife in the photo you post (thanks for the effort as it's a pain) is the paring knife from an early Empress Trio set, Buck's model 200. It is a Real Buck model. The handle material is not wood and has not been run thru the dishwasher too much. It is micarta and a very strong material. Just rub some mineral oil on it and it will look new. I've given the same asking price for one before as they are good kitchen knives.
NOW, rodb the Buck knife you mention is real as well. Only a different Buck model. The one you mention is from Buck's Windsor Set model 206. That set held 6 steak knives is a walnut display box and the front inch of their blade is serrated. The two knives mentioned here look the same only one has serrations. Both are hard to find. Plus, it is common that sellers will break up the set when offering them so, they can make more $$. DM