Yes, I too would very much like to see the CGs offered with an optional satin finish. I could see myself paying 40 to even 100 $ extra for a satin finished CG. But 210 $ as with the NMSFNO LE is pretty steep (although it does also include the tigerhide and full convex grind without a secondary bevel, and the fact that it's a limited edition).
Actually, I would call it
$270 more for the LE than the CG. The base price is $327 vs. $597 for an LE. That is almost twice as much. $387 includes a $60 premium for "Hand-Shaped".
I am more than happy to pass on a $60 premium for "Hand-Shaped" for my purposes. Machine shaped (if well shaped), is fine with me. And I can appreciate "Hand-Shaped" being an option for those who want it.
I used to have issue with many of my Busse blades coming with very fuzzy scales. But, I am happy to say most of my recent Busse knives have come with much better finished scales. Not polished and/or buffed, but good. :thumbup:
I "DO" prefer a full convex grind and I can appreciate a full convex edge having a value.... But, I can name at least 3 prominant companies that provide full convex edges as a standard on many, most or all of their blades at much less than INFI pricing.
Still, I could appreciate a Full convex grind/edge being a premium option at about $10 - $20 per small to larger sized knives. And I would pay a reasonable premium. (* I assume that was the trade off on Competition blades having nice convex edges, but no coating to cost the same as CG ???)
It takes me a while to modify a knife to a full convex grind with my piddly belt sander. But, that is what I ultimately do with my user knives. So, that is how I like and want them. The current LE "Package" is still WAY too steep.
A full blown knife maker/shop can do a full convex edge quickly - especially in volume production.
I would be happy to pay a "little" extra for a full convex edge, but putting my own full convex edge on a blade is WAY easier than having to put on a satin finish which to do properly requires "ME" to "Disassemble" a brand new knife, strip it down, grind out all the machine, marks, dimples and "Decarb", re-attach scales, etc. - all to save $270 that shouldn't have cost more than $40 (*Retail) on an 8" bladed knife - as it really probably only costs about $10 - $20 to add a decent satin finish in factory cost.
Satin is relatively EASY for a factory and a BIG PITA for me.
And IMO, $100 more for a satin finished blade is STILL "WAY" too much!
I have said it before, I will say it again: Most knife companies offer satin finish as a "Standard" on knives at ANY quality of knife, ANY size of knife and ANY PRICE range of knife!
So, I will NEVER understand, appreciate ( or PAY!) a $270 increase for a satin version.
Nor will I understand, appreciate or pay a $170 premium for a BATACLE to $330 for a NMFBMLE or anywhere in between.
* But, even to accept a $100 premium for satin as a good deal is "Being Trained"!
I firmly believe that $20 premium for small satin knives vs. CG, $30 for medium, and $40 for large is MORE THAN FAIR!.... Heck even $50 for over 10" blades like the NMFBM would be somewhat reasonable.
We "KNOW" that $20 - $40 for satin is "Reasonable" and "Achievable" from Busse because Swamp Rat and Scrap Yard have both provided satin finishes within those ranges.
I would pay $40 for satin and $20 for full convex.
IMO, Tigerhide shouldn't cost more than $20 extra (retail!). But, I am fine with black or tan micarta. I wish the tan were more brown though. I might actually consider Tigerhide at times if it were around $20 (??????).
For those who want hand-shaped, they can pay the extra $60. I will pass.
For those who want to pay the remaining $130 for an LE # etched on their blade, they can have it.
Of course, I can understand that there would be reluctance to offer such a satin option for CGs, because that would likely cannibalize LE sales. But we can always hope, can we not?
Yes. I have "Hoped" for "Reasonably" priced satin INFI as long as I have known about and been buying (and fixing/satin finishing my own) INFI. And with all of the pieces of INFI I have owned (maybe 25 or so - down to 12 at this time), I have "Unfortunately" had to purchase ALL, but one of them as CG. One was "Competition" Grade. But, while I prefer the Competition edge, the competition finish is actually worse than a coating IMO because it looks like crap until you can get to it. Stripping a coating is EASY with a chemical stripper. Stripping the coating only takes about 10 minutes and almost no effort or skill. Making a CG or Competition finish comparable to satin finishes on about 99% of the other knives on the market (especially when having to work around the attached scales) is a PITA!
I LOVE INFI. There are MANY GREAT qualities. So, don't get me wrong. But, I wish I didn't have to buy CG blades that to me come with a big thorn in the side. My Busse knife is awesome knife "BUT".... I have to work my A$$ off to get the knife to how I feel it should be and how most knife companies provide their knives (??????)
I can except that the thumb ramp issue/mod is just my opinion and no maker can make a knife of any design that is going to perfectly please everyone.
* But, satin finishes on blades is a STANDARD in the industry and shouldn't come with such a rediculously high premium.
When you get your thumbramp mod done, post pics if you can! That should be interesting stuff.
I am really looking forward to getting this one stripped and modifying the thumb ramp. Unfortunately, I messed up my back (3 weeks ago today) and I am still jacked up in chairs. I am actually having to sleep reclined in chairs - not so good. So, I don't know how soon I can get out to my shop and work on this.
For the fun of it and since I can't do much else, I will probably take a pic of mine and photo-shop how I intend to modify it. If I get around to the photo-shop concept, I will post a pic to hold over till the real mod is done.
* I don't want my view of the need for this mod to deter those on the fence. The NMSFNO is an INCREDIBLE knife. And most probably won't have much issue with the thumb ramp. That is very likely just me being very picky.
In the mean time, in spite of my feelings about coatings, the NMSFNO is still an AWESOME knife that I can't put down. I have had it here by my side at my desk..... actually - I have almost all of my knives in a set of 6 full ball bearing extension Intermediate chests under my credenza behind my desk. But, the NMSFNO has been "On" my desk at hands reach.
.