I'm getting on the boat. HELP

B

bladeboss

Joined
Mar 6, 2012
Messages
3,530
I'm going to Cabela's very soon, and we all know that they sell knives.
I have narrowed down the list of knives to the 2 main ones that i want, and i really can't decide.
No, i cant get both. :)
Those 2 knives being mentioned are:
Kershaw Skyline
Benchmade Mini Griptillian.

I'm leaning towards the Skyline, but i also want the griptillian.
14c28n VS 154 cm is also eating at me.
I've heard that 14c28n is pretty good, as well as 154cm
The only reason i mentioned the steels is because of the rust factor being put out there. Which resists rust better?
Other than that, what do you think i should get???
 
Mini grip, not even a question. The skyline is a great knife for $30, but the orange cabelas version costs $50...that's delica 4 and mini grip territory and quite frankly, the skyline doesn't hold a candle to either of those 2. On a different note, I would advise going to cabelas simply to handle the knives you're interested in and then go home and order online. You'll save quite a bit of money and be able to get exactly what you want.
 
I like the mini-grip myself and have carried one for the past 4 years. Nothing wrong with the skyline and it has a good following too. I have not compared them directly but I gather that the skyline is a bit slimmer. I thought it might be too slim for me.
 
Cabellas sells the Orange Skyline (they're the only one) and since you're going to be there, you might as well pick one up. My only complaint is no liner on the G10-scale side (which isn't a big issue on a knife that small).

The Skyline is smaller than I expected, but the Mini-Grip felt like a tiny toy (and I like small knives). I'd get a large if I were going to get a grip - and they make a rust-resistant version in X15TN steel.
 
I agree the Skyline and the Mini Griptilian are two very different knives. 154cm steel is going to hold an edge longer than the 14c28n. As for rust resistance the Mini Grip is going to be better because it comes in a satin finish or a black coated finish and the Skyline is bead blasted so it's more likely to rust.
 
They Skyline is a good knife, but the Mini Grip is in a whole different league. I have found it to be a tough little knife. Mine gets carried 5/7 days a week, never cleaned, and takes a pretty good beating. It's been faithful for almost a year now. I have a Mini Grip Tanto, and a normal Mini Grip as a backup. It's been such a good knife. It's just so strong for it's size. It's also the smoothest knife I have under $150, and smoother than some costing more than double still.
 
Thank you all for the help, but with some research i found 2 things.
One thing was that the only mini griptillian that cabelas sells has a "strange" sheepsfoot blade and the thumbhole.
Not exactly what i like.
And the second thing, im always looking for tested designs that last a while, so im going with a Buck 110.
:D thanks anyways guys.:)
 
I think the skyline is overhyped. It's a good knife but i've never been able to see what makes it better than any other kershaw in that same price range. I'm always surprised by how quickly my bead blasted kershaws rust. usually it's just a spot or 2 that can be wiped off but i've got a pit in my leek caused by rust and it's never seen any serious moisture or been carried next to my body. I also get rust around the thumb studs on all my kershaws. As for the mini grip, it's a great knife that'll last you forever. I love the look of the sheepsfoot blade and when i open and close mine obsessively and find that the hole does far less damage to my thumb. As for it being "strange" the hole design is the regular design and it's all you'll find in the majority of stores that carry grips. It seems like a lot of forum members prefer the studded version so you see a lot more pics on the forums. It's all personal preference though so by all means get the one you like. buck 110's are sweet. thats another lifelong knife.
 
I'm confused as to why you have to buy a knife at cabelas, and also how you went from trying to decide between two modern one handed knives to deciding on a more traditional style. Not that the buck isn't a great knife it's just that all three of these knives are so different from one another that I can't imagine what the intended purpose of the knife you want is.
 
BluegrassGuy said:
I'm confused as to why you have to buy a knife at cabelas, and also how you went from trying to decide between two modern one handed knives to deciding on a more traditional style. Not that the buck isn't a great knife it's just that all three of these knives are so different from one another that I can't imagine what the intended purpose of the knife you want is.
Click to expand...
Haha
I dont NEED to buy a knife at Cabelas, but im going there on a mini-vacation for the weekend, either this weekend or next.
So, i figured while i was there, i would buy myself a new knife.
The original 2 i chose (BM and Kershaw) were chosen because its been a while since my last knife purchase, and i wanted to get a knife that everyone seemed to like.
Therefore, Skyline and Mini Grip. were chosen.
As i was going onto the Cabela's website again, (to look at the knives again and try to make up my mind) the 110 was there, in the front of the list.
I clicked it, and realized that i liked the looks of it better than the other 2 i was thinking of.
Plus, it got almost 5/5 stars with 80 ratings, and ive never read anything bad whatsoever of them.
And for your other question, i like to use my knives for everything. Yes, its heavy, but i feel like it will be well worth it.
:)
 
bladeboss said:
The original 2 i chose (BM and Kershaw) were chosen because its been a while since my last knife purchase, and i wanted to get a knife that everyone seemed to like. Therefore, Skyline and Mini Grip. were chosen.

[ ... ]


As i was going onto the Cabela's website again, (to look at the knives again and try to make up my mind) the 110 was there, in the front of the list. I clicked it, and realized that i liked the looks of it better than the other 2 i was thinking of.
Click to expand...

You're learning. :thumbup:
 
I'd say go with the Alaskan Guide 110 they're pretty cool seeing as they feature Bucks superb S30V blade steel and should have a pretty stout lockback all in all while it isn't a real light or particularly easy knife to EDC it would IMO make an excellent addition to your collection if you've got other more EDC type knives.
 
Fyi the sheepsfoot version is NOT the only version cabelas sells. They sell all blade shapes and configurations and sizes and even have an exclusive version in d2 steel in the traditional drop point design.
 
Great choice, going with the Buck.

I own both the Buck 110 and the Kershaw Skyline... you really cannot go wrong with either! You're very right in saying that the Buck is heavy-- I would never carry it without its sheath on my belt. Weight aside, it's a great knife, the kind of knife you smile when you pick it up for the first time. If you decide you like the blade length and have some extra cash, I'd suggest the Skyline as an EDC for when you don't have a belt, if you don't already own alternatives.
 
I just bought my second Alaskan Guide 110 from Cabela's. (1st was stolen :mad:) They had them on sale online for a decent price. I ordered it for "In store pick-up" and had a little field trip of my own. :D What I saved in shipping, I had to pay in taxes, but with the sale price, it was still a good deal.
 
Between those Id say griptilian no question.

Although sometime down the road you could get a Skyline to.

I literally just got home from walmart and bought a skyline there since it was on clearance for $30. Their normally $50 at walmart, I havent messed with it to much but it seems to be a sick little knife. Like previously mentioned it is quite a bit more slim than I thought.
 
I think that is a good pick - mini grip and skyline cover the modern 3" blade, synthetic handled, pocket-clip wearing, one-hander that you already got with the mini ak47 - something like a 110, larger 4" blade modern/tactical folder, slipjoint, or fixed blade covers new ground.
 
Good luck on your trip to Cabala's. I live in MN where Cabela's has two stores. I believe they are headquartered here. The "original" store in Owatonna, MN had a very sparse knife selection compared to the store in Rogers, MN. My point is, not everything on their website is in the store and you might even find that the store will have more than what is on their website. At the very least, you should be able to get your hands on a few knives that you may consider for purchasing in the future. And you should definitely have the opportunity to handle the three knives you have discussed in this thread. You might find that the buck 110 is the right one for you or you might find that something you didn't even consider jumps out at you. Have fun!

Mike
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top