evilgreg
Why so serious?
- Joined
- Dec 25, 2012
- Messages
- 4,092

. . . I have to admit to falling sort of in love with my new Southard.
I've bought a number of Spyderco knives, trying to find the one for me, and ended up selling or gifting all of them except a PM2 that's still in the box that I got a killer deal on. These include a Sage 1, a Sage 2 and a Chapparal among others. Even though I just really didn't click with any of them, I kept trying them out because they seemed to be so popular on the web forums I'd been lurking (like this one). I found them oddly shaped, weirdly big for their size and just generally not for me.
So when my wife, who isn't into knives, suddenly bought me a Southard that she chose on her own, I was simultaneously touched by her gesture, by the fact that she'd researched and chosen a nice knife for me on her own, and horrified that I was going to have to pretend to like a Spyderco knife. I hid my initial dismay (you may have seen my amazing wife thread over on the general forum) and told her I loved it. The thing is, I didn't love it at first sight. In fact, I'd always thought the knife was on the uh, well, fugly side.
I've been carrying it ever since, and while I still think it's not the prettiest beast I definitely don't have to pretend to like it. The Southard is a seriously well engineered chunk of knife, and I'm a little bit horrified to find myself sort of loving it already. I carried a Sebenza for a few weeks and, while I appreciated the craftsmanship and it was a very nice knife, I didn't fall in love with it. I'd had the Southard for about a day when I started figuring out how I could customize it to better fit my EDC requirements.
I do have some minor complaints. The dirt colored G-10 isn't attractive, and I find it overly grippy for my purposes (though that texture would be great for heavy use, I think). The hole in the blade--well, I don't think I'll ever learn to appreciate that trademark Spyderco feature. Also, the Southard is incredibly solid considering how reasonably light it is for its size, but it's a little bit thick in the pocket and slightly asymmetrical.
To hopefully fix most of my minor complaints (baby poo color, rough scale texture, asymmetry, hit with the ugly stick), I put the knife in the mail today and sent it off to Barry H. to do one of his gorgeous looking CF jobs on it. I'm not a Spyderco fanboy yet exactly, but I was really sad to see it go and I can't wait for it to return.
Is the Southard the Spyderco knife for people that don't usually dig Spyderco knives?
Last edited: