I'm on fire. Drawing.

Joined
Apr 14, 2012
Messages
663
I have not been making knife scetches for a year beacuse I've been testing my old designs out. :)

Today I got me som paper and started drawing. I drew these two designs back to back right of the bat. I'm well happt. What do you think? Are they unintended clones of already existing designs?


20130827_212119-1.jpg
 
If they work for you they are fine. There are so few original knives out there today that they are definite "eye catchers". Frank
 
I'd switch the handles. I like the handle on #1, but I'd want it at a lower angle if it stays on knife 1.
 
Peppen108.

Your designs are not particularly innovative but they are pleasing to the eye. Sometimes designs that look like other designs create a feeling of familiarity in the eye of the viewer. This can be a good thing. But that doesn't matter so much. We, as knife enthusiasts, spend a lot of time looking at other people's work. It is natural that we are consciously or unconsciously influenced by these works. As a creator you are oftentimes at the mercy of inspiration. If your creative mind has an itch for a certain line or shape, you must scratch that itch. That is an emotional action. But once the design is roughed out on paper (or on the computer) you can approach it objectively making changes that are more analytical in nature. You have nice designs there. Now you can incorporate suggested ergonomic changes such as MudBug007's, or your own, as well as making aesthetic alterations if you feel they are necessary. When you have those changes made transfer the design to a piece of Masonite board, cardboard or acrylic sheet and cut it to shape so you can feel how it fits in your hand. That will give you the best feedback as to whether or not the handle shape/ angle, blade length or other variables are working well. Then make the darned thing and don't forget to show us the results.
 
Almost any knife design is going to derivative of something that's already been done. I woudn't worry so much about being "different" or "unique" and simply worry about making whatever design you DO decide on the best that it could be.

Don't set out trying to make the "ultimate" knife right off the bat, or you'll "ultimately" let yourself down. Look at some traditional patterns and see why they work. What makes a skinner a skinner? A bushcraft? A chopper? A hunter? etc...

Knives for specific tasks usually have fairly specific features. Build upon that, rather than just trying to make something unique. Then when you make the knife, use it. You'll quickly see what needs to evolve or be changed.
 
Back
Top