Inexpensive belt sander/grinder for beginner? HF or other?

Sharpening puts no where near the strain on a sander as knifemaking.
Bill

No doubt, but leather belts for stropping really do slow it down. Compared to those, grinding and sanding belts really scoot. I do wonder, though, how much of the criticism I'm reading here comes from binding or other quality issues on individual units.

PS: I did find that 20-30 minutes in a 170 degree oven will tighten up a leather belt that's gotten stretched and won't run without binding.

PPS: HF's motor sits inside a plastic shroud with a fan sucking in air, as well as dust. Get a good coat of metal dust, like you knife makers generate in volume, on the inner motor housing and it's like insulating your attic. That small motor, already working hard, will darn near ignite from the lack of cooling. Disassembly is really tedious, so blow it away with compressed air. Make friends with the neighborhood auto mechanic, if you have to, to use his air gun
 
I was just using my HF 1x30 to help flatten out the blade of a gyuto I had been draw-filing. My coarsest belt is a 100, and it was working fairly well, all things considered. I don't think I'd ever be able to do all the grinding on a knife that large with such a small device, but it did a good job removing the filing scratches and then putting on a 320 grit finish prior to heat treat.
 
Back
Top