Is it acceptable to baton with a Bk-11?

Joined
Aug 6, 2010
Messages
73
My 3rd post :)

I was wondering if anyone has had any experience battoning with the Bk-11,
the Becker Necker. I like to use a knife for battoning and I enjoy wood-fires during the winter, but I don't like axes or hawks or hatchets so much (I value
my fingers--heavy weight-training) (also don't know much about axes, hawks,
or hatchets for battoning wood). I was using a knife--um, not an expensive one, actually it was rather cheap--and thin. Well, I've learned how to batton
(and much more since) properly. I have a bk-11 (my favorite knife, btw, it's
excellent--don't like sheath though, the knife rattles).

Can that little necker handle battoning wood? Well, to be specific, I mean fat pine sticks, maple, hickory, oak? Usually pieces already split via axe, and about an inch thick. (Fat pine is my favorite fire-starter--feathers, shavings,
dust, all I need is a good shower of sparks and then I have---FIRE!) (I mainly split the wood via axe first, and cut myself a good long square of wood to cut into thin segments to use as kindling/feather-sticks) Could I use the knife for this without damaging it--and without voiding my warranty. It's a tough little knife--sharp too. I plan on taking my friends camping (they've never been), and I thought if the necker could handle it, I'd take it along with my field-folder. Thank you in advance for your help and taking time to read my lengthy questions.

Sincerly,
DS
 
I would, and I wouldn't have a second thought about it. :thumbup:
I can't see it not being able to handle it.
It is a solid piece of steel after all.

I'm pretty sure Ethan considers battoning covered under general use. Which is covered by ka-bars warranty if I'm not mistaken.

The BK2 is better suited for it though.
 
I've done it through Maple, no problem.

before.jpg


during.jpg


after.jpg
 
The Necker can handle it no problem. It's my EDC right now. I find the bk2 the best batonning knife though.
 
Hi darkseraphane, and welcome to the Becker forum.

As far as batoning with a BK-11, Ethan does it all the time — that must tell you something. Yes, it batons like a champ, although as frontline said, a BK-2 would be better.
 
yeah, i'd go with a BK2 just for the heavy work, and to protect your fingers.

the tactul is actually QUITE good at batoning :) amazingly good! plus it IS a prybar.

just don't baton too much hemlock/etc :> bad knots ;)


Bladite
 
3rd vote for the BK2. Just saw it for 53.99 on ebay by a reputable seller.
Deal spotting removed.
Thanks for the link, but be careful about posting links to sales; if memory serves, it is against the site rules and could get you an infraction.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
3rd vote for the BK2. Just saw it for 53.99 on ebay by a reputable seller.
Deal spotting removed.

Just a word of caution, EnduringEagle: that is considered deal spotting and will draw an infraction from the Super Mods. Please be more careful in the future, as we'd hate to have you draw an infraction, especially when you're trying to be helpful.

Please read the forum rules so this doesn't happen to you again.

I might also suggest that you at remove the price and the link, before a mod decides to do it for you.;)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Absolutely, it's great for one stick fires and the like 3/16ths is plenty thick for good high carbon steel, no matter what the length.
 
I might also suggest that you at remove the price and the link, before a mod decides to do it for you.;)

and don't copy the link either in reples - more work for me ;)


Bladite
 
It was that microsecond of indecision just before you hit the "Explode this post" key that allowed him to sneak in like that.

nah - i was still enjoying my lobster roll :)


Bladite
 
Back
Top