Is there a good benchtop mill?

Joined
Jul 17, 2019
Messages
338
Does such a thing exist? Can anyone recommend one? All I can find on googling is people on machinist forums saying "just buy a Bridgeport", and I know they're probably right. The thing is, I don't have a truck, I don't have a forklift, and my shop is pretty small/full. I've also basically never used a mill so I have no good way to evaluate whether the stuff I see for sale on Facebook marketplace is any good.

That said, I keep ending up trying to do stuff with a drill press and files that would be 1000% easier if I just had a damn mill. So is there a brand anyone likes for a benchtop mill somewhere in the $800-1500 range?
 
Mounted rigidly, and used carefully, benchtop mills are pretty useful.
The Chinese model that all the importers sell is probably the heaviest duty.
The Sherline is a high quality machine, but may run over your limit.
The baseline Taig mini mill starts at $1000. They are nice-I have one.
You have to realize that you will need accessories and tooling, which can raise the cost significantly.
 
I have what I think is the largest bench top mill Jet makes. It is model JMD-18PF. I have been very satisfied with it. I don't remember what it cost.
 
You have to realize that you will need accessories and tooling, which can raise the cost significantly.
That hadn't occurred to me, no, but it's good to know. Thank you! Since I posted this I had the brainwave to try to finish fitting up a sword pommel by hot fitting it which worked very nicely, so my need for a mill is slightly less urgent than it was. But I will definitely file this away.
 
I used a benchtop mill from MicroMark for years (basically a nicer Sieg model). The ones from Little Machine shop now come with all the upgrades and work fine for most knifemaking requirements.
 
Does such a thing exist?
I think so. Not gonna go down the budget/brand rabbit hole, but I will say this; to best achieve your goal, my opinion is that the heaviest, largest machine that will fit the space you've allotted might get you there
 
Check out Precision Matthews. I have had one for more than 7 years and it has done every thing I have asked it to do. You just can't get in a hurry and take too big of a cut. Like has been said you will have as much or more in tooling than a mini mill costs.
 
I recently picked up a mini mill from Little Machine shop. I absolutely love it. It does everything i need it to and it does it with ease!

Mine ran about $2500. They also have a benchtop mill for around the same price.
 
Lol there is that. But then I'd have to figure out how to transport it (no truck), how to get it into the shop (gravel driveway doesn't like rollers), how to move it into place (concrete floor has huge cracks and pits all over). Sadly I don't see a Bridgeport in my future anytime soon, at least as long as I'm working out of my garage.
 
I second the nod to Precision Matthews. After doing a lot of research I went with the PM-728VT Ultra Precision Variable Speed Milling Machine. But they have many different models. Customer service has been good as well.
 
^that's my dream machine
 
What kind of "Stuff" are you doing? I started (and still use) with the 3690 High torque mini mill and found it useful for many opertations, I did buy a full size SouthBend 1024F with DRO for Heavy operations.
 
I went through basically this same thought process when buying a mill about 13 years ago. I started looking at Harbor Freight's options, then Little Machine Shop, Grizzly, and finally Precision Matthews. PM seemed like the best option all around if you wanted the nicest machine right out of the box, but the prices started adding up quick. I figured for what even the new "lower cost" mills would run me, I'd probably be able to find something really nice in the used market.
I ended up finding a Kondia knee mill (bridgeport clone) at a used machinery dealer about 2-1/2 to 3 hours north of me. They had their own truck with a lift gate and we negotiated a fair cash price that included lift gate delivery. It came on a pallet, so I had to tilt the head 90 degrees to get it into my garage door, but the driver was able to roll it with a pallet jack nearly all the way to where it sits to this day. I used a 4 foot prybar to slide it the rest of the way, and carefully knocked the pallet out in pieces from under the machine with a sledge hammer. It only almost tipped over once. ;)

All that to say, if you could get a similar delivery from a relatively local dealer, I imagine you could put some plywood down and use a pallet jack right off the lift gate. I've moved equipment over grass and gravel like this lots of times. If needed, you could even partially disassemble the machine with an engine hoist and a flat cart and then move the pieces one at a time into your shop. It's a pain, but it's one and done (at least until you decide to move...haha)

I'll just add that the final price of my mill was well under 1/2 of what the average brand new benchtop mill would cost me from PM, and still cheaper than even the smallest new models from places like LMS. I should add, however, that over the years I've spent well over the cost of my mill in tooling and accessories, but these are things you can add as you need them. At least get a vise, a collet set, a drill chuck, and a DRO is money well spent.

I don't know what kind of work you plan on using your mill for, but I'll also add that there are times I wish my full sized mill was even bigger. That said, if you're just doing folders and guards and that kind of thing, you'll probably be fine with just about any sized mill at the end of the day. It is nice having some extra size and power when you need it though.
 
I have the smallest Chinese stand-alone mill made. I use it for routing handle materials.shop8.jpg
 
I run 2 PM 25-MV's and have been perfectly happy with them. I bought both used. The first one I got for $800 with about 3k worth of extras which was a once in a lifetime sweetheart deal TBH. The second one I found on FB marketplace for 2K with no extras. Still a great deal IMO. I use one primarily for drilling and some milling and the other is dedicated for milling. Both have DRO's which is a must IMO. Both have been more than adequate in my shop where I primarily make slip joint folders. I've decided that if/when I would ever upgrade it would probably for a larger more advanced benchtop from PM but at this point I haven't seen a need. My advice is there are really good benchtop deals out there where people are getting out of a hobby or just realized they don't need anymore. Just takes some patience and do your homework so you know what you need and what your looking for and you can probably score a nice machine with tooling to get started.
 
Back
Top