Is this NY Knife Co. genuine?

KAW

Joined
Aug 3, 2017
Messages
37
Okay, after lurking about the board for a better part of a year... I'm sticking my big toe in here....
Not that I'm a collector of razors. I'm a local history nut & about two years ago I discovered about the knife manufactures in Ulster Co., NY. The more I learned, the more I got sucked into collecting the knives from those fascinating enterprises. However, last May, I came across on the bay a straight razor with a tang stamp: New York Knife Co. / Walden, N.Y. I have not come across anything even hinting that they made razors. Even more bizarre was the seller's location was in Estonia (formerly part of Russia). Fortunately the price was low enough to take a gamble. It looks great!... but is it authentic?

Then I found a thread on AAPK about Electric Cutlery Co. straight razors... and hope there is a actual connection here. In 1903, the Fuller Bros. of Electric Cutlery Co., Newark, NJ purchased New York Knife Co. and ironically that factory and their Hammer Brand line almost immediately became the primary operation. The Newark plant was closed down in 1910 and the Electric Cutlery Co. line manufactured at Walden was discontinued in 1920.

Apparently, Electric had a product line of straight razors. After "merging" with NY Knife, did they continue the line under the new name (hence explaining the razor in the photo)? ....perhaps still making them in Newark until 1910? ....or did they move the operation to Walden as the tang stamp suggests? ....an inquiring mind wants to know.

zvC3eBoUAqKcCa-YpjTSS4bsoSIf57T76QwbUQFnz4KN_fivyy8lxwGMRc5mQPkuUmEODK_IPed74MwmTr6ju7qsVEOwexlp8AGiNHgpkOdbGeplDSQh6hGbbOyb_q0Mk4aTdCdE--irCs3uU6gb527DztW3vePCn7FfUnaeX3GkFZ554DY0a3KvXo3u-OxepLWZMXtQbK9XLtEoF-vvTJDdKtFJQpWPH0Vp8PRU7qLMBlBv5D7Cirpq02Bq4piaa2JbVCcs0pVu-0-zP24LCgW26RT_GXqwhSuDgDFoOzV5rKBaNRlnjyQk2KUhDct6j3du86-zF1ktlGscZdmXbd1gfYU4Rjv7GBqQD3oSwp82RLmsp4-n5YW9rRcQ0mjROLl6hXQMFQGaVGWgxRaDoq-s3EL54GlT6tNrrs2Q4R0dj9H1_6zZ8Tyk3zUU7IMot6g7WKJG2HhNQfc31ApoOGqElFT47O4DTCEifWwWWEWL-64oLxEQ5Z7ntJxbWl40Qr6Qj26lri20EVaSlWymSBSoTRxhNnkmi_qGtL4yx-bTuL2zlv16ty4rpo0n7zOs8bAOEl6wDljYRXA5QU-37qO2VqLiU_i3-g1Q2W3hGaeKp5_jQdtFiLvLpsiHnl1RvgNq0wF-DJNl4G7_at90bQjHsom7A3ZcdX0ApXdgGJdO8g=w1050-h797-no
BEMsPHOyIAP2Q_eqDCz2uzRs1JYbvrJ6IHhF4V4gn54OzUv57NYEwDAkXFa08OuCGzeqiuFh0Zd4-TVk5EW0-bMwmUpgg5QCGhI4BZxXv-7nWm0u0GD8TbkUdx9zib2AvqWdCTn7R9Y6yKdILsdzzJZ9xzb3Z7abTa8De0E7-D1_HOiYyx24-GkQh1aWDQD1xooc60PNtJc1-k-_ZLrjTBF6dQI4W3aMFZUSVF9dRnrqSqViRyMXBiWdHMiZgSJV7FjIWJGmkudFXd_je7sYl-W1BMjtTh1CGPjyuayqekuEigZeR45MsTB8iZr5ecgrI5g2BJNhkgbtAbOPZD_tgALTvJz0oIXlweY7wE-Fb7PZgrgmM9A55nSkxr3og-YoirekME36qbt-e7MsukgnZVuePr_1-hKEnVpqXu8ypk8ofOre1XyJgJfJU52CRjrW9AJKWKv7TC_utD3GQzYnCalaMC-DeAUmJsOQBtr6n_rJwELEwrURT-VPY5nsv6ao4f5ex9pytYrJUA4dB8FOifAi1wv4yTc71ynq8rG0osQ_a09QKYBjo-tsJNcBJJ11W7zVuc31hBSgfCkNcrnl3bUdV0E7-qSQxjS3iDVFkAorLcYUoMvhcE8D0PUPmihOfg0Kq0Pt9nmm_WsAHfx2jJ3uTHf7GjOpPFf4K7nFphUWHA=w1063-h797-no


’til later….
KAW

"Everlasting Sharp" means…. never having a dull moment.
 
Last edited:
dmZ7FUfxksMeM4xvpgciW2qtDY1sJKEyb6Dm75SgRP7JXMCvMSc4U9uuQ6yWdsqgSPG4Vv-vZfbfFf3HbSS9iGL9fNmIF-bSnvYaIj5gmPAZI7fIWC4wrrANAfWqU-C6WGaIvZ_4CJhKilbKS7YWwo9RKVlgxlEo2nDgTQkiM41u1uHz10koXZl_UtgC2UaZptCObR7qm1QrglUIv3-vXMQyZTvgYo4LY9MnSpBaljhfwfuGlT7nman8wJSpb1jnI4CQi-HFE5B44n1zvXpJiXjYcz977WP1L8AiaEY7GQuRhAx2SYcaKU06cqmKaJgh5kD78ciDBdiZws3CTNaD1oGTAheAvzhwakb3qMF9rEWlJ0Yt4XSlBRwW74xXA6XfRG5RfVKDDiOHbgHbYxOtl5dKIWagrSsGrSE6sg7cCnYlZrQolfN04zsFVMBvX4FZALsJL3qpeuOZCWcCUuzaXiSO4VU0DTpgdAKXsBOoM41r5Mjsjd45CCcZgTLg3r2Di2YszxZqLZjiTs0yqetyJRYXkVHxkhU4swyVy4sFt8ITSoU2AQjBZ9HQN9wCvGXMIAH2Qfg8THFZBryvezqgFFnXJno86OCHaRRmvadKI4MmSoXCxyAyV1IaJwuUXjVpf_N-S7qKQ3i7DYcw3fQYQ50fYhFtyMY-9mGt4YBQgH2fng=w640-h480-no
....continuing with some more circumstantial evidence....
Lo & behold.... I found this photo in the thread on the AAPK board titled....
"Re: Old Fancy Handle Straight Razor`s" posted by Miller Bro's » Sat Mar 05, 2011 7:50 pm.

The knife on the left looks exactly like mine except he states they are Electric Cutlery Co. Razors.
....still hoping its possible they continued making the same razor after the merger using the NY Knife name....



’til later….
KAW

"Everlasting Sharp" means…. never having a dull moment.
 
Last edited:
I can't find a record of them making straight razors, but I think you answered your own question in your second post:)
 
I guess I'm just looking for confirmation.
While the circumstantial evidence helps lower my concern that it is a fake.... at this point it is still just conjecture.

Thanks for posting, Ernie.

’til later….
KAW

"Everlasting Sharp" means…. never having a dull moment.
 
From my (limited) resources they only made knives. If you want good information on straight razors, try straight razor place. I am a memeber there and there are lots of very knowledgeable razors fans on that site!
 
Thank Ernie for the tip.... I'll check it out.

’til later….
KAW

"Everlasting Sharp" means…. never having a dull moment.
 
Back
Top