Hey Joe,
Yeah, I remember those posts - in fact, those were the very posts that got me to buy one to T&E for myself.
Overall, I love the light because it's shock resistance is vastly superior to that of a comparable SureFire (i.e. 6P, D2, M2) For me the other factors (lighter, slightly smaller and brighter) are iciing on the cake...
FWIW, I showed Larry Leach the light on Saturday at the Moo Palace and he (initially) wasn't particularly impressed at first - it does, after all, only look like a polymer 6P. But then I deliberately dropped the light a couple of times onto the concrete floor without any visible effect on the beam's spot. THAT got his attention!
In any case, the tailcap is (admittedly) not as nice as the now standard button on most SureFires. On the flipside, I like how its more watertight and durable. With the addition of the Mad Dog "Woobie", I have a defacto CombatLight - with the full tailcap acting as a pressure switch. Its something I've gotten used to, I guess.
In any case, don't anyone take these postings as SureFire bashing because they're not. I actually still own/use quite a bit of their stuff (i.e. M500A), but I personally think they really dropped the ball by not upgrading the M2 with superior lamp assemblies.
Flashlighoholic YeeDude