Just for fun

I heard several months ago that S30V wasn't available in sizes large enough for swords. But that could have changed.
 
wouldn't s30v or ats34 be too brittle for a sword? i think, any knife steel wouldn't be ideal, right?

not that i'd ever use that thing, i'd put it on my wall.
 
Generally, this is true, regarding knife steels vs. sword steels. A sword steel needs more flexibility than some knife steels. There is much more to this subject, of course, and I cannot speak about the characteristics of S30v or ATS34 in this regard. A sword is not just a big knife. The traditional Japanese makers solved the problem by a differential heat treat, with the edge being harder and therefore more brittle, and the spine left more flexible. Many custom knifesmiths do this today, and this practice is also used for axes and other chopping tools. Many of the less expensive swords on the market are left soft throughout the blade, because, of course, they are for wall hanging, or for reenactors to bang blades together. The custom sword shown here may not be differentially treated; perhaps a steel is used that does not require it, or the design itself may be massive enough to not require much flexibility. I am no expert of course, just an interested student of swords.
 
S30V is plenty tough enough for a sword IMHO. Powder metallurgy has changed all the rules about steel, so you really can't make quick judgements about traditional tools steels versus high alloy steels. I've had A2 swords tested under severe circumstances and pass with flying colors. S30V is at least as tough as A2, maybe tougher. If you doubt that, hold a sword of any steel you like in front of your face, and let Mick hit it edge on with this blade when it's finished. If you live, you might be right about stainless steels. Otherwise... :)
 
Damb! Mick,
I saw those pics and got instant wood!!:D :eek: That has the makings of another one of your work of art blades that make me drool into my lap.;) I wish I had your talant and vision. That is a great looking sword!!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top