Uncle Timbo
, just wanted your opinion, is there really any advantage of a Kephart with a 4.5 to 5 inch blade that I could not just as easily do with a 4 inch blade? Besides splitting fire wood, which I do not do, mostly just everyday chores. I may want to get a Jk Kephart in stainless (154cm) but wanted a slightly longer blade. What are your thoughts?
I can help with that one as I've had multiple options in both size ranges. 1st, I prefer the 5" size which means the LT Wright bushcrafter mark II and kabar Kephart are the two I have in that range, the former being my favorite knife for overall use. For me, it comes to comfort of use for a knee lever technique which I use a lot but have very large legs so the extra length to span my knee/shin is very helpful. Unfortunately, it also means the 90 degree spines can really ticked me off when I'm wearing shorts.
I also find the extra length very helpful when using the knife to flatten a piece of work or work surface. I do this a lot in winter or when it's wet out by putting a flat spot on a log so that I have something to cut against that's solid and it helps keep my knife out of the snow or mud, since I live in a swampy area of MI.
However, for everyday chores, the 4" length is probably sufficient. I often use a 3.5" puukko or similar for everyday type stuff, unless use in the kitchen is needed then I want at least 4".
As an FYI, my standard JK Kephart has a 4.5" blade with about 4.25" having an edge. I think it's my only JK that I didn't ask for anything special outside of handle material. If I were to do it over again, I would probably ask for 3/32" steel instead of 1/8" since O1 is plenty tough at the thinner width and then it would be better for cooking chores. I really like my JK Canadian belt knife that has a convex grind on 3/32" 154cm steel, which I had made with the intent of making it a key part of my kitchen cutlery with the ability to take it to the woods without too much worry of damage from being too thin.
Not sure if you have a JK Kephart yet, but if not, I can send you mine to test out for a bit. I also have a mini Kephart like 22 and that's another one I like for everyday types of tasks. Actually, I've been carrying that one around in the vest the past couple weeks instead of the puukko since my puukko is a bit heavy now that I wear the vest around the house more with the cold weather so that it feels lopsided when sitting and not being active.