kershaw skyline vs. spyderco native

The OD1 has their newer 1428CN (?) steel, and it works fantastic. The OD1 is interesting, it's a deeply hollow-ground 1/8 in thick spearpoint - very thin tip but moderately thin edge and a good amount of spine.

Plus the action is great :D.

I'd keep it, but the Skyline is still my favorite, and I have too many flippers.
 
I have both, Native is a much better constructed knife - this is the S30V FRN version. The Native is a good 40 dollar knife, and the skyline is worth all $25 I paid for it.

The Native S30V FRN is over $122 here in the UK! :eek:

Thankfully, I bought mine new for just over $57 in a private sale, I find it a good, ergonomic and strong knife which has impressed me.

This is my first Spyderco, and I like the quality of the design, materials and construction.
happy0034.gif
 
I have both and I actually just sold my Native with the s30v. The ergos on the handle were nice, but i did not like the design of the blade(as with all spyderco's....i hate that hole thing) and the handle felt cheap. I also am not a fan of lockbacks...that was so pre-flipper! haha.

I have found no difference in edge retention, and actually my skyline is sharper and a heck of a lot easier to bring back the edge. IMHO you should go with the Kershaw. Personally, i think they are a better knife company(i own 4 kershaws and love them all, with a ZT on the way!)
 
Two years have gone by since my first Native arrived here. My wife found the last WallyWorld Native around here last July and gave it to me as a birthday gift that month. Still new, I know I have a spare for when that cheesy riveted FRN handled Native I EDC gives up the ghost. After two years of EDC, and lots of appliance boxes, material, blister packs, etc, it is still as tight as the unused one. Last August did find me touching up the edge with a Spydie Sharpmaker after noting how warm the blade got while dissecting a cardboard box. They were a steal at the Wally World $39.48 price.

I have a Kershaw Zing! I bought there early in this year. I looked over the OD-1, Skyline, etc and was more impressed with the Zing!, so it came home with me. Part of it's back is open and will allow pocket change to stick there, if carried clipless as I do. It resides mostly in a display case. My new favorite Kershaw, although it is larger by far, is the composite bladed 'Junk Yard Dog II', #1725CB, which runs ~$70-$75 delivered via Evil-Bay dealers. It is enclosed - and has a D2 edge married to the Finnish steel flipper-deployed blade, with it's thick G10 scales attached to the substantial SS liner. It is a substantial knife - especially for the price. It displaced my old Blurs from back pocket carry.

I still carry the Buck #347 Vantage Pro more than the other smaller Kershaws and about as often as the Native. That Buck has a great S30V blade, too. Not as short and stout as the Native, but quite a slicer. None are even poor excuses for prybars, as others have said. I guess I'd still lean towards the Native, after all of the attempts to depose it. That Buck would be second, however. I have spent a bundle for proper EDC knives over the years - and the Native may just be the best knife. Of course, for years - decades, actually, I was happy with a Buck 110, or 301 Stockman - or my ancient Vic SAK... but what did I know?

Stainz
 
Owned many Natives. Owned one Kershaw Skyline. Sold it.

It felt cheap, the liner locked up almost all the way over right out of the box. It was someone difficult to flip open without loosening the pivot so that there would be blade play. Yeah I'm not the best "flipper user" but still.

Plus, I've seen many many people complain about the Skyline's bead blasted finish on the blade rusting easily.
 
Back
Top