It is true that we all have different viewpoints. This is why I believe that we should leave the judging and reprimanding to Bill, Yangdu, and Pala. They are the ones who originally designed this forum. They are the ones who made the rules. I personally believe that if one makes a mistake on this forum, that one or more of our moderators should be the one to point it out. I may suggest to an erring forumite that he or she may have made a mistake, but I would leave it up to Bill to make the final decision. The Gurkha policies and views are alien to many of our own. Bill sometimes has a misunderstanding with their ways himself, a good thing he has two of them to confer with. It would be unrealistic to try to understand them completely on our own.
We may disagree with how Bill or his relatives handle certain situations, but I have complete faith in their decisions as fair and just. If Bill can gracefully handle a true troll (the one last November), he can take care of a forumite who meant well but typed in a wrong series of letters. If it doesn't bother Bill or our Nepalese friends, it shouldn't bother us, and we shouldn't assume the role of judge, no matter how many posts we have made. Trying to personally judge and denounce another forumite will breed unneccessary resentment.
Sorry Bill, you made the rules, I expect you to have the final say. I have absolute faith in your judgement.
P.S. GONESAILING, I have a 16.5" inch WWII, nicknamed "Thulo Rato" (Big Red).