I have sharpened the Henkels 4 star for some friends and the got really sharp and were made well. On the other hand, very expensive. I got a henkels eurocraft 4" parer for my parents for $13 and it takes an incredibly sharp edge. I'm talking shaving hair off my arm sharp out of the box and I was able to maintain the edge with an arkansas stone for a while and it touches up nicely. I also have a 4" parer and 6" utility from tramomtina. $14 and $18 respectively at Walmart. Consumer reports rated them 5th behind the Wustolph and henkels. I like them so far at college where I do a lot of stuff with chicken and use them for cutting meats, veggies, potatoes, etc. The edge they came with wasn't as impressive as the henkels. it was very course and the edge was thick, so I used my Lansky to think it out a little. Much sharper now and I can touch them up nicely. The overall finish is decent. they are user knives that are cheap enough to buy and use and if one breaks, oh well, they weren't that expensive. they have held up well under college use so far and are a decent starter set that doesn't cost too much. i would redo the edge, though. Not the best knives out there, but definetly not the worst and they have that traditional design with 3 rivets like the henkels. In fact, they look a lot like the Henkels 4 star or which ever series has the wood/plastic handles with 3 rivets. Have you thought of making a set of knives from Jantz or Texas knifemakers supply? They are relatively low in price, i think with plenty of styles and designs to choose from. You can also personalize them more with differetn handle materials and colors and stuff like that. From the kit that i did from jantz, it was fairly easy to make, but i didnt do a kitchen one with rivets. Jantz has an 11 piece kit that included handle material and rivets and stuff for $70. I don't know how the quality is, but it might be worth checking out.