Knife Rights Maryland Knife Law Preemption Bill Introduced

Critter

Platinum Member
Joined
Mar 23, 2003
Messages
1,787
[Post in General approved by Spark]

At the request of Knife Rights, a bipartisan Maryland Knife Law Preemption bill, SB 653, has been introduced by Senators Wayne Norman and John Astle. The bill has been assigned to the Senate Judicial Proceedings Committee. We will let you know when it's time to contact committee members on this bill.

Last year's tragic Freddie Gray arrest highlighted the kind of problems that arise without preemption. Under Maryland law, Freddie Gray's assisted-opening knife was clearly not a switchblade by standard legal definitions. Even if it was, switchblades are legal to open carry in Maryland and from the arresting officer's account the knife and clip were clearly visible. However, Baltimore has both a complete prohibition of "switch-blade knives" and a unique and unusual definition of a switchblade that might conceivably include Gray's assisted-opening knife, although we would contend that it does not. In any case, if knife law preemption had been the law in Maryland, then only state law would count and there clearly would have been no knife law violation upon which to arrest Gray. (Click for more details on the Freddie Gray knife, his arrest on the switchblade charge and Baltimore's switchblade law.)

Knife Law Preemption repeals and prevents local ordinances more restrictive than state law which only serve to confuse or entrap law-abiding citizens traveling within or through the state. Preemption ensures citizens can expect consistent enforcement of state knife laws everywhere in a state.

Knife Rights passed the nation's first Knife Law Preemption bill in Arizona in 2010 and has since passed preemption bills in Alaska, Georgia, Kansas, New Hampshire, Oklahoma, Tennessee, Texas, Utah and most recently in Wisconsin.


Be the first to know. Get the latest Knife Rights updates:





And, sign up for our FREE News Slice™ Newsletter for more news you need to know.



Knife Rights is making a difference!
Invest a modest sum in a Sharper Future™ to protect your tools and rights.

JOIN KNIFE RIGHTS TODAY!


 
Can we get that in PA too, to do away with Philadelphia's asinine laws? Or does that not work in a Commonwealth, since Commonwealth law encourages different laws from jurisdiction to jurisdiction?
 
Can we get that in PA too, to do away with Philadelphia's asinine laws? Or does that not work in a Commonwealth, since Commonwealth law encourages different laws from jurisdiction to jurisdiction?

The difficulty with doing anything in PA right now is your governor. Get rid of him and we can try again in PA.
 
The difficulty with doing anything in PA right now is your governor. Get rid of him and we can try again in PA.

Yeah, tell me about it. If it's any consolation, I didn't help put him there...

How does that work in a Commonwealth vs a "State" though?
 
I contacted Doug a while ago on the PA issue and after his explanation I can see he is right about the political angle. The previous Governor was an idiot also and played for a different team. PA law changes at a glacial pace. You can't buy beer in any but a select few grocery stores and it is 144 ounces or less only. We just recently got the right to buy less than a case at the beer distributors. That's right. Previously you could only buy a case of beer or more at the special shops that sell beer. A case or more. For no good damn reason.

I'd love to carry an auto but frankly the rest of our knife law is not so bad and our gun law is great. Philthadelphia is a different animal. Honestly though, asinine gun and knife laws coincidentally also reflect places I don't want to go anyway so I don't really mind them in this circumstance. It is stupid that I can carry my glock in philly but not a SAK. Good thing I have no desire to visit philly and if I had a job that required me to I would change professions; not just because of the knife law either.
 
It is stupid that I can carry my glock in philly but not a SAK. Good thing I have no desire to visit philly and if I had a job that required me to I would change professions; not just because of the knife law either.
Is this actually the case, total knife prohibition in the city of Philadelphia? I was unaware of that, and I have to say, I see *lots* of knife clips on a day-to-day basis.
I live in Philly, in a neighborhood that's right on the crest of the gentrification wave, and have not had any issues... even on the several occasions when I've been searched by cops and had my knives discovered (even a few huge ones, that most people would look at and say "You're carrying THAT!?"..... and even late at night, when it's obvious I'm not en route to/from work...).
It might be on the books, but it doesn't seem like the LEOs here in the city are concerned with enforcement to any meaningful degree.
 
In any case, I'm from Maryland originally, and have lots of family still living in the Baltimore metro area, so I'm very happy to see this bill introduced in my beloved home state! :thumbup:
 
Is this actually the case, total knife prohibition in the city of Philadelphia?

Yes. Philadelphia code broadly prohibits all knives in public except in use on the job.

It might be on the books, but it doesn't seem like the LEOs here in the city are concerned with enforcement to any meaningful degree.

Not a problem...until it is. We are certainly aware of instances of it being enforced. Not anything like NYC, however.
 
Back
Top