Knives as gifts.

A number of years ago, I gave my younger brother a knife for Christmas. Nothing terribly expensive, just a little one-blade lockback, since he works in an office I thought it would be appropriate. Last time I was up visiting, he pulled that little thing out to open a package of hamburgers for his grill. Says everybody in the office asks to borrow it whenever they need to cut something.

That was a successful gifting.

Kids I've given them to ALWAYS appreciate it, especially my kids and the nieces and nephews.

My father-in-law has carried the same Gerber LST as long as I've known him. He works in an office, too, and it's light enough for his suit pocket. Just always carries it, uses it at work and home and opens feed sacks and fertilizer and trims the tomatoes and everything. I gave him a little one-blade Schrade peanut to take to work. Cute, likes it, but it's too small to do anything with. Still carries that LST. Gave him a nice small sheath knife I made. Loves it, talks it up whenever knives come up, but would never, ever use it -- it's too nice. :D Still carries that LST.

Last time we were up there, I was sharpening a new knife I had with me, and he pulled out the LST to work on the edge. He just uses the kitchen knife steel. And that thing was dull as heck. So I worked the edge out for him. Man, that thing has been sharpened to death. Lots of life left in it, if you're going to absolutely use it up, but ... it's a fifteen dollar knife, at best, and does what he wants it to, obviously, since he still carries it.

I bought him a Mini-Copperlock this year, in black barnboard. We'll see if it's too nice to use, or if it finally woos him away from that old LST. :D

My dad just about stole a Case Peanut from me last summer, he thought it was so cute, so he got a red bone CV one for his birthday/Christmas. He's been carrying it every day since.

Sometimes it works out, sometimes it doesn't.
 
What is better for a knife knut is not always better for the person who's receiving the gift.

Carbon steel is oftimes a bad idea as a gift. A friend of mine was quite ticked off after a few months when the sweet Queen canoe in 1095 was a bit rusty (at least he used the thing). Gave him a Case stainless steel one as a replacement and he was much happier.

I recently gave my wife a Japanese kitchen knife (she's been wanting one for a while). I was able to step outside my craziness enough to resist the urge to get one from one of the small-time family owned shops and got her a Kasumi (similar to a Shun). She was ticked off because it doesn't have a Granton grind.

Bone, and even more often stag, skeeves out some people who otherwise enjoy knives.
 
I've gifted a few traditional knives away in the past year. Got my little brother a Buck Prince, and gave some of his friends opinels and douk-douks. They actually liked the way the carbon steel took on a patina and the history behind the knives. Most recently I gave my dad a Case peanut in chestnut bone with cv for Father's Day.
 
Nicely resurrected thread. ;)

Regardless, I agree jackknife. I have taken to the Victorinox Farmer in either Silver, Red, or Blue Alox. I've gotten one for 3 guys at work and also just got another blue Alox farmer for a buddy of mine that lives a couple blocks from me. None of them carried a knife before and if I didn't give them a SAK they would use the blade as a makeshift screwdriver. Plus the Alox models are nice stout knives for the money.
 
Never give a knife as a gift. If you do it will “cut your friendship”.

That’s why the recipient must give you a coin. Give a penny, save a friendship. What a deal!
 
In general when you choose a gift, never assume that what you like is what they'd like. Most people are not much into knives but you can do several of them (not all) a pleasure by giving them a knife ONCE, and then neutral/classic/SAK designs are a safer bet.
Still, if you know the other person well, you should know what (s)he likes most, and it may well not be a knife.
 
Back
Top