Knives of Alaska - holes (another try)

Sal Glesser

Moderator
Joined
Dec 27, 1998
Messages
11,746
First, I'd like to apologize to the original poster. The Alaska knives thread was hijacked into a black hole.

I thought to resurrect. Please, no round hole legal arguments. :)

I have not seen Alaka knives folders, do you have pics?

I know that Knives of Alaska has been using a finger hole in their fixed blades for many years. There were others also using finger holes in their fixed blades in Europe. That's why we couldn't get a trademark for fixed blades.

I understand that they make high quality pieces and most fixed blade companies will ultimately include folders.

The hole opener patent has been expired for 6+ years now and opening holes are becoming common.

We just assumed that when the patent expired, companies would see it as an opportunity to try to get creative. A hole opener hole shape is very distinctive on a folding knife, much like the grill on an automobile. We assumed they would become popular in folders and I've encouraged makers to create their own.

Most knife designers have figured out that the important part of a hole/dent opener is the ridge or lobe along the top of the hole. Some have jumped on this to begin their own identity. Jim Wehrs / Doug Hutchins have been using their "bean shaped hole", first at Gerber, and now at Lone wolf, since the mid 90's. Tim Wegner has created his "V-hole" which is also identifiable as a Blade Tech. I noticed that even Swiss Army is playing around with hole shapes. We created the "comet shaped" byrd hole as a consistent identity.

Many companies just use "off-round" shapes, I would assume being respectful of our trademark.

sal
 
Hi Sal,

Just like the Camillus produced Remingtons used a "Cat Eye" hole.

Best regards,

Phil
 
The only Knives of Alaska folder I know of does not use an opening hole.

They have holes in several fixed blades.
 
AL059.jpg


AL003.jpg
 
The latest catalog shows a "cat eye" shaped hole, not round.:thumbup:

I'll try to post a pic tomorrow if no one else has by then.
 
I suppose that it would take a lawyer to determine when an slight ellipse is legally different from a circle.
 
Those are the only ones I see in the catalog I got other than the thumb stud shown above. I don't see any issue here.
 
We got into a big ol' scrape over that hole?!? It isn't close enough to round to be worth bothering over.:D

I think for the next "holy war" I will wait for the pictures and then rip the OP for being an ass. . . , er, not visiting his eye doctor regularly.:rolleyes:
 
Umm.... this looks like the boy who cried wolf here. Sal I believe you were mislead a little. OOPs!
 
They look fine to me.

We did some design work with Phil Gibbs years ago and we used a "Cats-eye" shaped hole for a knife that was to be a "Mantis" line.

sal
 
Most knife designers have figured out that the important part of a hole/dent opener is the ridge or lobe along the top of the hole. ....... We created the "comet shaped" byrd hole as a consistent identity.


sal
Sal, I think that you are still one step ahead of "most" with this comet. I find the comet to be a significant improvment over the round hole when using the thumb or especially when flicking by grasping the blade . The elongated hump in the blade to accommodate the comet does make the knife larger in ways not nomally measured. oli
 
Those Master Guide folders have sort of a Wegner-like look to them. They have what kind of looks like a BladeTech Pro-Hunter blade, mixed with a Spyderco Chinook handle (the butt portion more so than the front).

Regards,
3G
 
They look fine to me.

We did some design work with Phil Gibbs years ago and we used a "Cats-eye" shaped hole for a knife that was to be a "Mantis" line.

sal
Speaking of Mantis, there's a company now using that name, and they do make a couple karambit folders with holes that, at least in their online illustrations, appear round. Again, I realize that illustrations are often drawings rather than photographs, and that either way angle and perspective can make round things look oblong or oblong things look round.
 
Back
Top