Of the two go with the Short fatter one.
I have 5 CS machetes, 12" Barong, 18" Barong, 12" Bowie, 18" Latin and the Magnum Kukri.
The Mag Kukri is the least comfortable/useful.
Warning-The ergos on the long Mag Kukri grip are awful, i have medium/small hands and the grip size is too small. I'm probably just going to re-handle mine eventually.
The grip on the other CS are ok though.
Personally if i had to just pick one machete i'd go with the Bolo style, the Tramontina Bolos can be hand for under $10. Also the Imcasas and Condors are very nice. The Marbles are nice too, but they are actually relabeled Imcasas.
The Marbles Bolo i have came hair-shaving sharp, even the top edge could shave hair!
You should just check out machete specialists and see what they have available there.
I have almost 20 machetes but i'm not an expert on them.
Hopefully Joezilla will pop in here and comment, he's the real-deal Machete guru!
