• The BladeForums.com 2024 Traditional Knife is ready to order! See this thread for details: https://www.bladeforums.com/threads/bladeforums-2024-traditional-knife.2003187/
    Price is $300 $250 ea (shipped within CONUS). If you live outside the US, I will contact you after your order for extra shipping charges.
    Order here: https://www.bladeforums.com/help/2024-traditional/ - Order as many as you like, we have plenty.

  • Today marks the 24th anniversary of 9/11. I pray that this nation does not forget the loss of lives from this horrible event. Yesterday conservative commentator Charlie Kirk was murdered, and I worry about what is to come. Please love one another and your family in these trying times - Spark

Learn a lot, see a little.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hey Caleb, Caesar Lombroso came out with a whole doctrine of "reading people" just by measuring their heads...believe it or not it is total BS, much like your swell little rant. Ever heard of not judging a book by it's cover?

Stick to watching Roadhouse in your parents basement, while stroking your "mini-grip".
 
I don't follow. Suppose the guy carries a Mini-Grip(easy 1 handed opening knife for EDC), an SAK(to use around people for whom a larger folder might be "scary", as well as for the additional tools), and say, a Ka-Bar TDI as a self-defense weapon. None of them are flashy, none of them are the "coolest", none of them are new, and (depending on one's views on self-defense), all are practical. So he carries 3 knives, which according to your statement makes him a "gear queer", yet by your definition of the phrase, he is not.

Summed it up perfectly, well said.

I started to feel bad for the OP, like maybe he was mentally challenged to some degree.

Then I remembered he's the kid who wears the Guy Fawkes mask pretending to be part of the internet grop 'Anonymous' and I immediately felt justified.

(link to post)
 
This is one of my knives. Goes along with your quote: "A wood handle is more show,....."

Well, in this case, you might be right. It will be one of my EDC's, pocket-sheath carry, and definitely for Show. That's why I bought it; I love the beautiful wooden scales and the general design of the knife. But then, the only one who would expect to see it...is ME. I have dabbled in the fine arts and jewelry-making...and I guess it comes through in my knife-selection sometimes.

 
I kinda doubt that much can be gleaned from what knife they carry.
My knife selection usually depends on what I am doing at work.
Since I travel a lot and my average job is probably 3 days and I encounter lots of different scenarios involving carpentry.

Some days I may have 3 sharp tools on my person, other days just one.
Wonder if my wife should be worried on the days I carry three knives?
 
You can really learn a lot about someone by just seeing their knife. I constantly read people's facal expressions, posture, accesories, etc. and I notice a lot. My whole family on my father's side aee good at reading people. Well, ever noticed a person's knife? Think about it. What type of person carries around a Cryo and who carries a SAK? A utalitarian is more likely to have a multi tool than carry a Sabenza. A wood handle is more show, while a darker synthetic leans more to a concealed blade. An inexperienced hunter is going to have a 12" blade while an experienced bushman, has a knife with a 4" blade. Do I even have to talk about a Tanto blade?Pocket clip or not? Is that a Barlow in your pocket, or are you happy to see me? The guy that carries three knives receives my affectionate term, gear queer. A gear queer is someone with the flashiest, not too practical and "coolest", new gear. I can't be the only one to notice these things, right?

I happen to carry a Mini Griptillian, with black scales and an OD paracord lanyard (about an inch long). What kind of knife nut are you?

I live in a small town so my Mini Grip, a pen, and some cah suffice. When I go to Seattle or othe cities I do a lot of walking in, I have a few more items. I carry all but my usual EDC in a backpack. I have; a Guy Fawkes mask, notebook (spirl bound college ruled), folding pocket razor saw, sweatshirt, a good book, cards (I am a magician), and some flash drives. I may or may not carry my iPod and earbuds, depends on my mood. I will add a picture later, I don't have my camera. I just want to know what my fellow knife nuts tote in the urban jungle on a day to day basis. So wat's in your pocket/wallet/pack?

What are we supposed to think of a person who carries a "folding pocket razor saw" , a Guy Fawkes mask, and a mini grip? What does this say about you :confused:
 
Even though Caleb is not getting any love in this thread, I think he is on the right track. Traditional folder guys are different than tacticool guys, who are different than bushcraft guys, who are different than the guys on multitool.org. Its true that there are exceptions and overlap, and a tacticool guy might carry a traditional because his grandpappy gave it to him, so we can't take this stuff too far.

But carrying a knife evinces a certain personality type, and the kind of knife you carry, or the type that you gravitate to does reveal a little about you. Charlie Mike is not going to carry a Sponge Bob folder, and I'm guessing that Gary Graley won't be seen with a Klingon Batleth. Charlie Mike is into bad*ss waved self-defense folders in part because he's a convicted felon and can't carry a gun. Jackknife (Carl) is into Peanuts and Vic Classics - and you'll know the reason why if you have followed his posts.

So there is a nexus between our personality types and what we carry. A strong one. We can't take it too far, but Caleb is on the right track.
 
Caleb, I fully understand your lighthearted post, and I fully agree that certain things about people act as their "tells" as I have heard it playing poker. Anyone who has ever made a living selling, knows you to be 100% correct. The answer to you here is that certain people are always going to show up when hate is handed out. Most of their replies will be judging someone, that is their "tell". Anyone that is so closed mined as to not allow someone to post about what THEY think is correct is simply never going to be the type person that is able to learn. As is the same for a person how thinks everything is fact, will never know right or wrong. You posted this in a forum, that allows free speech, some would rather move it to the "whine and cheese" and Cable, that is their twisted tell. Keep posting, you have some great thoughts, original, which sadly is maybe not welcome. Now join this site for $35 and enjoy all of it and show your support. Take care friend. Now set back and watch me be attacked, I feel the sharks. Was the spelling ok ?
 
So Caleb decides to post this thread about "reading" people. It was meant with good intentions. I think he was trying to say that different knives are carried by different kinds of people, there is no reason to attack him.


And now that I'm defending him, I'm going to get attacked as well. I see a lot of posts about how this is the greatest place on the Internet, and it usually is, but I'm not seeing it in this thread's posts. Come on, people.
 
So Caleb decides to post this thread about "reading" people. It was meant with good intentions. I think he was trying to say that different knives are carried by different kinds of people, there is no reason to attack him.


And now that I'm defending him, I'm going to get attacked as well. I see a lot of posts about how this is the greatest place on the Internet, and it usually is, but I'm not seeing it in this thread's posts. Come on, people.

Yeah, there's a bit of an unnecessarily harsh dogpile going on here, for sure. Asserting that he is mentally challenged, directly insulting him, etc.

His conclusions may have been flawed, and the term "gear queer" was in poor taste and the definition was not well thought out, but two pages of relentless insulting is a little much.
 
As long as we remember he's just a kid. I mean, we were all young and dumb. Hell, I think I still have some dumb left in me. Ask my wife.
 
I could totally see Gary rockin' one of these.

Oh, Gary definitely loves the batleth - no doubt about that. He uses it for Klingon battle rituals, usually while wearing nothing but a vintage kilt. I just said he "won't be seen" with one. He does this stuff in private.
 
This might hold a little water if we all actually EDC'd a single knife, or single style of knife. But many (possibly most) of us here rotate through a wide spectrum of knives, from 4" tactical monstrosities to 2" traditionals. Some people carry big knives simply because they have big hands. Some people choose their carry based solely on local laws. If you try to make too many assumptions with too little information, you will end up getting burned pretty fast.
 
The guy that carries three knives receives my affectionate term, gear queer. A gear queer is someone with the flashiest, not too practical and "coolest", new gear.

And I call you a gay bashing weirdo. Strange that your daily life incorporates clear homophobic rhetoric yet you stare at Men's bulging pants a lot and judge them...

This should be in W&C. Has nothing to do with actual knife questions and clearly contains questionable content.
 
Jeez, talk abut a dog pile.

Yeah, Caleb made some dumb statements in his post, but I hate to think bacon some of the dumb things I said and did as a teenager. Heck, kids specialize in dumb, sometimes. I think Imade it a full time job when I was that age.

But to some degree, Caleb is right, in a very general way. I've been knocking around this rock for a lot of years now, and one thing I have learned is, sometimes stereotyping works. The FBI, Israeli Mossad, Scotland Yard special Branch, all use profiling, as do other agencies because it yields results often. How else would they know that serial killers are most often single white males with a good paying jobs? But is Caleb making accurate statements is another matter. But if you back off and take a very general look, you can tell a little something about somebody by his belongings. Generally. Very Generally.

A car sitting on a parking lot, says something. A lowered Japanese compact with a coffee can muffler and a whale tale on it, is not likely driven by a senior citizen. But the silver box stock Toyota Camry with a book on the back seat titled "The Senior Citizens Guide To Medicare" is not going to belong to that young dude with the stain lee steel stud in his nose and the ink on his arms. Sterio typing does have some validity.

But wood for show??? I'd hate to have to tell the gyrations of hard working construction and frm workers in Europe that Opinels are show knives. Just as I'd hate to tell 20 gyrations of working folks in Finland and other parts of Scandinavia that all those wood handled puuko's are for show. But then again, Caleb is a teenager. How far has he traveled yet? I say cut him some slack and teach him the way of it.

When I was kid, there was this country store, and they had what was called the liars circle. It was the most esteemed old collection of hunters, trappers, loafers, poachers, and chicken thieves the Eastern shore of Maryland had. Us kids loved to be able to sit in on the meetings of the liars circle when allowed, because we'd learn from the old guys. They in turn took great lea sure in teaching us things like knife sharpening, how to jack light deer, and other things they held important. We kept our mouths shut, but sometimes uttered something dumb. That got us a stiff admonishment not to spout that kind of bull hockey, and they then corrected us.

We elders, who's time is growing short on this earth, need to teach the kids on their path from kids to adulthood. RThat included correcting htier BS in a way they learn, and that's not dog piling.

11827315155_3a7b4d855f_c.jpg


Caleb, go back and think about some of your observations, then go check out puuko's, Opinel's and Herters sodbusters. Ya got a few false conclusions there, kid.

Carl.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top