Locking Swiss Army Knives - preferences?

I've got a great one that i traded off a dutch soldier years ago that is a great knife. pretty large for a SAK but it's pretty well put together. nice OD grips and whatnot too, don't know what the name is or if you can buy it off the shelf. and yes, the lock is backwards.

You can kinda buy it off the shelf. The Dutch army knife (DAK)is based upon the German Army Knife (GAK) with the only difference being the eagle on the side of the scales. Both are patterned after the Victorinox One Handed Treker (so is the Swiss Soldier 08, for that matter). All three knives use the same steel and have the same blade configuration. I have seen pictures of a second style of DAK, featuring a second full size blade. Don't know if it is made by Vic, though.

The Swiss Soldier 08 and the GAK are both available for retail purchase from Victorinox. The Soldier has slightly nicer scales and is priced higher that the German counterpart.

Something else to consider is the rescue knife offered by Vic. It also is based upon the OH Treker. If I was going to buy again, that's what I would buy.
 
Last edited:
I had a Hunter with the sliding button release. Now I have a Trekker with the linerlock. I like the linerlock better.
 
I have one of the Ranger series knives with the cross push-button. It works ok for what it is. It lives in my fishing pack that I carry when fishing from shore. The saw does a pretty good job of clearing out pesky branches.

I'm not really sure what's involved in getting stuff like that through customs, but my brother got it for me when he went across the pond to Switzerland.
 
Don't know if I trust the sliding lever type locks. Not enough experience using them.
And I've never liked liner locks of any sort.

I really like the push-lever locks that Wenger (and now presumably Victorinox) used on some of the Evo models like the S10. :thumbup:
 
You can kinda buy it off the shelf. The Dutch army knife (DAK)is based upon the German Army Knife (GAK) with the only difference being the eagle on the side of the scales. Both are patterned after the Victorinox One Handed Treker (so is the Swiss Soldier 08, for that matter). All three knives use the same steel and have the same blade configuration. I have seen pictures of a second style of DAK, featuring a second full size blade. Don't know if it is made by Vic, though.

The Swiss Soldier 08 and the GAK are both available for retail purchase from Victorinox. The Soldier has slightly nicer scales and is priced higher that it's German counterpart.

Something else to consider is the rescue knife offered by Vic. It also is based upon the OH Treker. If I was going to buy again, that's what I would buy.

thanks man... i was going to do a little research on it. i like the knife quite a bit.
 
thanks man... i was going to do a little research on it. i like the knife quite a bit.

No problem. I am in dress slacks alot and I find my GAK is a little large for pocket carry. It works great as a carry knife in the tank bag of my motorcycle though.

I also owned the Soldier 08 model until I decided to gift it to my boss. Like I said, the scales are slightly nicer on the 08. More comfortable too. You can really feel a difference when you grip them. Not a real big difference but, maybe enough to pick the Soldier over the GAK. My favorite is the rescue model because of the extra tools.

Please let me know what knife you end up with.
 
I love the newer version of the Soldier, since I am left handed it is easier to close this one handed.
The liner lock on it has a bit of up and down play but no big deal to me.

The Wenger button locks are really neat but the handles are a bit big and clunky feeling, still a cool knife though.
 
Have the one handed trekker, wenger S10 (like a locking vic Spartan) and the vic delemont S13 (locking camper). As far as lock trustworthiness they all feel pretty decent. They don't seem completely disengage-proof, but you cant just push them closed either. I don't put 100% trust in any locking blade and therefore prefer any blade to have some degree of finger choil... in that regard the one handed trekker wins out of the 3. But overall if you are looking for a locking SAK, you cant go wrong with any of these as long as you have no illusions that they are a heavy use fixed blade.
 
Stopped by the Victorinox store at the mall today to actually put my hands on this stuff. A couple of surprises:

The original slide lock is back in production. I guess Victorinox has more confidence in it than the ones they issued warnings about. Probably the least intrusive system because it sits flush on the back scale. Unattractive, though. Matte scales on all of them.

The Evogrip and Evolution knives held two oddities: They are small - the size of the compacts, and they don't all have locks (I had thought that was one of their defining characteristics). The locking models have have an "S" - as in "Evogrip S18" vs "Evogrip 18". The locks levers are kind of big, but stiff enough that I don't think you'd accidentally disengage the lock unless you're really not thinking. Nice package. But, you might get a small pen blade or a nail file depending on regional distribution, which is painful, since it is not determined by model number.

The New Ranger knives are flippin' huge. I mean big. Not sure what the intent with these is - my pockets aren't that big. As an outdoors only knife they make some sense - really big saw.

The Soldier family with the backwards liner lock actually seemed the most "Swiss Army". The simple lock, though it sticks out a bit, was aesthetically the most in line with the way a SAK is supposed to look and work. Simple and effective, not fancy.

The Vic website does not show all the knives currently available, which is also a pain. One that they had at the store which is not on the site is the Outrider. I believe it was a slide lock, and had a nice mix of tools for the size.


I think it is important to remember that like the first liner lock knives, the SAK locking knives are slipjoints with an added lock. This is really very different from a back lock or Walker linerlock where the lock IS the open position. So I don't think they should be compared too closely.
 
I ended up getting a Wenger S13 (locking main blade, usual stuff, a saw blade and an unfortunate nail file) and a matching S81 gents knife off an TSA confiscation seller on ebay. Both in nice shape for $14 delivered.

The lock itself is quite nice - only the most minor play against the lock, and the lock button is firm and sits between your fingers so it isn't in the way.

Thanks for everyone's input. This is my very first Wenger!
 
I bought a Wenger Evolution S111 with blade lock not long before Wenger knives went out of production. The knife is a cool one. And the model number will tell you if it has a second blade or a nail file. In this case the Wenger 11 is nail file and the Wenger S111 is second blade.

http://www.sakwiki.com/tiki-index.php?page=Wenger+85mm+2+Layer+Models

Wenger%2520S-111%2520Open.jpg

Wenger%2520S-111%2520Closed.jpg
 
Last edited:
Like others said, the 1H Trekker is great.

For the same size and weight, I've been using a Leatherman Skeletool, it has a 1 hand opening liner lock blade, along with pliers and screwdrivers. The stainless version has a partially serrated blade, but the upgraded "CX" has a plain edged 154CM blade. The Skeletool also has a pocket clip.

 
I bought a Wenger Evolution S111 with blade lock not long before Wenger knives went out of production. The knife is a cool one. And the model number will tell you if it has a second blade or a nail file. In this case the Wenger 11 is nail file and the Wenger S111 is second blade.

That nail file in place of second blade is the only thing keeping the Vic Delemont S13 from being my ideal SAK- really liked the idea of a locking SAK, with the Victorinox can opener that can perform Phillips head screw duty, but also really love the small blade on the Vic Camper or Wenger S13 for detail work/whittling.
 
Back
Top