Alright so I now have both the Cold Steel Recon I and the Star-Tac in hand.
I've carried the Recon 1 since Sunday on my flight suit. It certainly does not excel in that role. Far too large to fit in my lanyard pocket, it has to go in a different zipper pocket which makes it hard as hell to get on and off of my uniform.
That being said... I'm very impressed by the Recon 1. Its everything a "fighting" folder should be. Perfect size to fit in the pocket but still has a 4" blade. I haven't put either knife into any serious work so I can't comment much on their performce.
The Recon 1 is pretty difficult to open, I can flip it open I'd say 90% of the time, but in that 10% I actually managed to cut myself on the edge of my finger which makes me think it should have a flipper on it. Unlocking the blade is seriously difficult as well, it takes quite a bit of pressure to unlock it. My finger was quite sore after playing with it for an hour or so.
Overall the Recon is a great knife, for the price I see no problem taking it fishing and other semi sketchy activities around the water where I may lose it. Also the self defense value is priceless, can say walking around New Orleans over the 4th weekend made me wish I had something of the like. Some sketchy homeless encounters a couple times.
On to the Star-Tac:
My first impression of this knife is it made with the utmost quality of craftsmanship. It feels like a piece of art in my hands. That being said my immediate second opinion is on how difficult it is to open the blade. Now I've heard these knives require a break in period but that seems a little ridiculous for the price. Planning on taking it apart and greasing the knife (grease provided by Chris Reeve in the package why couldn't they just grease it???)
I haven't carried this knife on my flight suit yet but it fits perfectly in the usual knife slit. Also the lanyard connected to it makes it smooth to pull out. The clip works great also. Simply a beautiful knife. I'll leave it at that and come back to give it a further review after wearing it a couple days..
Now check out this stone holder and strop I made! Just bought a 2 x 4" from home depot. Had them cut to a foot and a foot and a half. I use my puukko to whittle and strip down the wood to create the handle for the strop. Then sanded both down both with an electric sander and by hand. Stained the wood with a gun repair kit I have. Put in the 3 screws to hold the stone I have in place. The bottom of the stone holder also has a mesh glued on it so it won't move with force pushed against it on a table. I bought a baseball re-grip to both re-handle my baseball bat and put the extra on the strop. Just a little fun!
Also dremeled my name into both
Enjoy