looking for a knife need help

On most knife sites D2 RAT I is about $70 dollars.
Also I believe this price chosen believe ing it was needed for quality, $100 could be stressing the budget.
You give a knife guy this knife for EDC he will love it.
It's not fancy but well made.
IMO you can't beat it
 
The RAT 1 D2 is in the hight sixties on most sites.
I'm recommending this knives.........
1 well built
2 D2 is a great steel used for many years
3 It is knife not made for style but for use.
4 No matter if he is urban, suburban, or rural. This a knife that can be used in a variety of ways.
5 Most people decide on a higher price believing it will mean better quality.
$100 could be stressing her budget.
I bet if given as a gift it will be used for many years and purchase not regretted.
 
On most knife sites D2 RAT I is about $70 dollars.
Also I believe this price chosen believe ing it was needed for quality, $100 could be stressing the budget.
You give a knife guy this knife for EDC he will love it.
It's not fancy but well made.
IMO you can't beat it
Not trying to argue with you. Just trying to give the OP accurate info. The places I tend to buy from and supported by this site are all under $40 for the Rat 1 in D2:

Knife Center: $39.95
Blade HQ: $39.95
Knife Works: $36.95
New Graham Knives: $35.50
 
Last edited:
Massdrop/Ferrum Forge gent, Kershaw Bareknuckle,
 
Not trying to argue with you. Just trying to give the OP accurate info. The places I tend to buy from and supported by this site are all under $40 for the Rat 1 in D2:

Knife Center: $39.95
Blade HQ: $39.95
Knife Works: $36.95
New Graham Knives: $35.50
OK I'm wrong about price.........been a while since I bought mine.
Sorry if I sounded ornery.......
 
A RAT 2 in D2 steel would be nice. Add a Victorinox Cadet and you are good to go for just about anything.

Buck Knives offers a nice slimline 112 Ranger with G10 scales that would also be nice.
 
I was waiting to see if my questions got answered - easier to give recommendations without more info.

If he doesn't have a sharpener I would suggest getting one. I'll second (or 3rd) the recommendation for a Spyderco Sharpmaker. If this blows your budget let us know and we can give other sharpener options. A good knife edge matters a lot for cutting. All knives get dull.

You've gotten some great advice here. I see that you were considering at 3.6" blade. Given that, I'm going to 2nd the recommendation for the Spyderco Manix (picture below). It's an excellent knife, has unique blade lock mechanism that's easy to use and cool to show off, it looks good, works very well, is made by a company that stands behind their products, and it's made in the U.S. if that matters.

9FrGCY1.png


The Spyderco Para 3 Lightweight and Native 5 Lightweight are also excellent. These are smaller than the Manix. The Benchmade Mini Freek or Griptillian (these may be hard to find) are also excellent and also smaller than the Manix. Cold Steel makes some nice knives in this price range which have been recommended.
 
Last edited:
To add another element, alongside the Ontario Rat option, if point of origin isn't a deal breaker, some of the "made in China companies have been really doing a good job at making quality knives that are affordable. Something like a Real Steel Sidus or CIVIVI Incite or Dogma in D2? Knives that still have some fancier styling points to them, not "just" another knife, but still well built from companies that have certainly been dispelling the old "made in China automatically = crap" myth, if anything else.

Or, yet still another option would be to go the sharpener route, like a sharpmaker, and pair with a small keychain knife like a Swiss Army Classic (available in a plethora of patterns, find one that suits him perfectly), or a leatherman cs.

Or, go with a cheaper sharpening system, like a Smith's 3-in-1 field sharpener, (a poor man's sharpmaker if you will), and pair that with a more basic and rugged user knife that still holds some brand recognition like a Basic Ontario Rat, ESEE Avispa (available in a variety of handle color at knifeworks.com), one of the Kershaw CQC's or Natrix, or even a Kabar Jarosz Beartooth... Maybe even pair the cheaper sharpener w/ a cheaper, but still quality rugged basic knife, AND a Swiss Army classic keychain knife that suits his style perfectly. Make it a trifecta?
*(could even with the money saved, pay the little extra to have the knife engraved with his initials or something short & sweet and meaningful at one of the dealers that offer laser engraving services, again, like knifeworks?)

Just a few more options to choose from... obviously you'll know his style and his wants and needs better then us, but tons of great options still to choose from in that $100 or less range to still make a knife knerd smile...
 
I'll go ahead and offer a different point of view than most and then add in my thoughts.

1. Blade steel is (in my honest opinion) THE most important criteria. It is not the be all to end all, but a knife is designed to do one thing and that is to cut. Having premium steel that will hold an edge and keep it for a while is the entire purpose of having a sharpened blade.

2. China? I know we don't discuss politics in this forum but really, I'd stay away from anything made in China simply because you can get a nice knife within your budget that is made in the U.S.A. or Italy, and have a nice warranty in most cases.

3. I'd stay away from the big box store brands - Gerber, Buck, Kershaw, Schrade (Lots of Taiwan and China in here).

4. Stick with the best brands from the US and Italy - Benchmade, Spyderco, Lionsteel, Viper, and Fox.

Here's a decent list that might help.

1. Benchmade Griptilian - An iconic knife that helped launch the Benchmade brand.
2. Spyderco Paramilitary 2 or 3 - An iconic knife that helped launch the Spyderco brand.
3. Benchmade 940
4. Spyderco Manix 2
5. Lionsteel Big Opera
6. Fox Knives Dragotac
7. Viper Free
 
...
Cold Steel Code 4 comes in a few different styles. I like the clip or spear point. Sleek metal scales and the Tri-ad lock is one of the best locks in the business.
https://www.bladehq.com/?search=code+4
This would be my recommendation. It is REALLY good, even putting aside its reasonable price. The steel (S35VN) is excellent, the action is excellent, and the lock leads the industry for reliability and strength. Occasionally, it feels big, with its 3-1/2" blade, but it's so thin, it carries nicely in the pocket and doesn't scrape the hand when put in the pocket next to it. A 3" blade is a good size for most daily tasks, but the 3.5" blade is big enough to cut up fruit on the go where 3" is marginal.

The Spyderco Endela is also a good buy in a high-end knife. I prefer the hole in the blade for opening, because it doesn't catch on things I'm cutting through. (like apples) It does carry the penalty that the blade has to be wider to accommodate it. That's a style call to be made by you.

The Spyderco Manix 2 in BD1 steel is right around $100 and has a better grip than the Endela, and its lock is more fun as well. However, it's more expensive and wider in the pocket, due to that superior grip.

You're a good girlfriend; nice job. It's smart to consult "the experts" before buying. Most people don't bother with it.
 
Back
Top