My girlfriend loves Merrell hiking boots. I, on the other hand, cannot stand wearing anything even remotely close to a hiking boot. They're heavy, cumbersome, etc.
I know it might not be what you're looking for, but I wear the 2nd generation Oakley SI Assault Boots. They've saved my ankles a bunch of times, relatively water proof (haven't tested them in a full on rainstorm), puddles, brooks are no problem. The good thing is that they wear like sneakers but as far as I'm concerned, they offer much of the protection of hiking boots. Good traction too. The downside? Pricey.