I have tan, russet, brown, and light brown. They all leave a different look, and different pieces of maple don't look the same, so you may have to experiment. They can be mixed if needed. I often thin them down and make multiple applications.
Initially, it will look darker than you want, and sometimes have poor stripe contrast. Once rubbed in with a rag, wipe off all excess quickly. Then work it with steel wool a bit, followed by hand sanding with 400 grit to get the proper contrast. It is a very good idea to save some scraps and pieces of the same wood to test on before starting the handle.
TIP:
It is best to build up the dark stripe by applying the stain, rubbing in, then sanding off after it has dried a bit. Repeat as needed, and change the dye color to get the final look. It will look much less crisp ( even dull looking) until it dries fully, and gets the finish on it. When the finish is worked into the wood, it will deepen the color and make the 3-D look that we all love.