Merlin/Harpy: Resharpening easy or not?

Joined
Feb 18, 1999
Messages
6,504
The thread on the Harpy for self-defense got me thinking:
I haven't ever given the Harpy or Merlin more than a passing pick up/put down again. But now I wonder: Are the serrations of that type of reverse-curved edge very much more difficult to resharpen than, say, on a Rescue, etc.?

Also...and I guess I really should examine one...does the blade's shape make the tip a bit weaker than a Delica/Endura blade or not?
Jim
 
Jim,
it depends on what exactly you want to get out of the sharpening process. If you use the Merlin/Harpy for cutting rope, gardening or "harvesting mushrooms", the exact serration shape and ratios (after resharpening) will not be of prime concern to you. In this case it is NOT much more difficult to resharpen than the serrated Endura, for instance. Just follow Sal's instructions on the MF204 SharpMaker video and you're there!!
wink.gif


However, if it's important to have the angle of the serrations correct with regard to the blade's curvature (needed for specialised applications), you need to take some extra time (and know what you're doing during the sharpening process!!)...

With regard to the tip strength: I feel that the Merlin/Harpy's tip might even be a bit STRONGER than the Delica/Endura's tip, because of the thickness of the blade spine in that region of the blade. The Delica/Endura tend to taper to a very thin point very quickly. I MIGHT be wrong in this regard, but I'll have a look at them tonight at home to make sure...

Anyway, in the self-defense sense (which was the thread taht got you thinking about these issues in the first place), the tip strength of the Merlin/Harpy is more than adequate, as the knife will more than likely be used for slashing, rather that thrusting (which is NOT impossible, but that's another story altogether
wink.gif
). I'd suggest that one modify the serration angle of the factory-model Merlin/Harpy a bit, to be perpendicular to the blade curvature at all points. The factory-models' serrations follow the same angle throughout the length of the blade, which is understandable when you realise that these are production knives. It will be very costly to do the serrations otherwise at the factory... Anyway, it's fun to do it yourself!!
wink.gif
wink.gif
 
Heyns:
Thanks for the reply! Yes, I did notice that the serrations on these knives are all directed straight down like you said.

I'll have to really check out one of the Merlins (Harpy may be too much $ for me now) to examine the tip. I guess I jumped to conclusions about the tip strength based on only its appearance. Very interesting!
Jim
 
Jim,
glad to be able to (try to) help!
wink.gif


Please let me know what your opinions are regarding the tip strength!

BTW, have you noticed that the 'older' models of both the Harpy and the Merlin had more "aggressive" tip profiles than the 'newer' versions? I noticed this a while ago when playing (
wink.gif
) with some of my Spydies at home, after acquiring a new Harpy and Merlin... I can maybe post a few pics showing what I'm talking about - I'll just have to get my hands on the digital camera again!
 
Heyns:
I'll have to look for some pictures of the older model Merlin/Harpys. To be honest, I never did have an interest in these models until recently. I'll have to check to compare the profile to the new models.
I wouldn't be surprised if they are changed. The Delica and Endura models are now different in the blades (longer, pointier, thinner, sharper edges).
Jim
 
Back
Top