Their first THRASH album since ...And Justice for All. Death Magnetic ROCKS!!
You know, metal has changed a lot since Kill 'em All through ...And Justice. I remember the shock I felt when I first heard "Enter Sandman" as they basically became a hard rock act simply because they didn't win the Grammy with "One". Bob Rock ruined them. Black album is a good album in it's own right, but it's a lot more mainstream than what Metallica started out as.
I think a lot of folks have very high expectations for Metallica because they were what was considered "heavy" before death metal. They aren't, and never have been, death metal. Death Magnetic has all the elements from Master of Puppets and ...And Justice, but this IS the same band that put out Reload :barf: (which I honestly can say I maybe have listened to twice. Reload is a stinker). Look at the Blaze Baley (SP?) led Iron Maiden and the 3 lame Kreator albums between "Coma of Souls" and "Violent Revolution". How about every Anthrax album after "Stomp 422". Metallica isn't the only band who has a few crappy albums under their name - these same aforementioned bands have rediscovered themselves successfully IMO (still waiting, Anthrax!!).
"All Nightmare Long". "The Judas Kiss". "Broken, Beat, & Scarred". "My Apocalypse". "That Was Just Your Life". Even if you can't look past the atrocity that was Unforgiven II (being taken up AGAIN with Unforgiven III, the weakest track on the album IMO), there is very little with this album that an 80s metal fan would have to complain about if Load and Reload had never happened. It's great to have them back!!!!
I am proud to say I am a Metallica fan AGAIN!! \m/