db, thanks for your support. I'm still not sure that you understand what I am talking about. I mean making of copy of a thread and moving it to somewhere more appropriate (in this case, WC). But instead of leaving a locked copy of the 'bad' thread in the general forum, attracting attention and possibly helping fan flames, I am suggesting deleting ONLY the original copy. Nobody's words are total removed from the BFC site. And the purpose of the Troll thread is defeated.
BTW, I have told Tim and Kit (the other side of this fight) that any similar behavior on their part will receive similar treatment.
Thats only fair. I think they understand that.
The idea that I have not explained very well is very different from total deletion of threads. I am very much against censorship.
Moderation is a tough thing. Each case is just a little different and calls for a different response. This can range from Nothing, pointing a forum member to this information he seeks, posting helpful links, trying to get folks to take themselves and others words a little less seriously, or even locking (and possibly deleting) a thread or post altogether. I would try to do Nothing most of the time. I always try to post helpful information when I have it or know where to find it. I would hope I do not actually have to act like a policeman very much. This forum does police itself very well. Taking administrative action (moving, locking, or deleting threads) is rarely required.
But if a forum member chooses to spread an arguement from one forum to another by taking others posts out of context, and distorting their intent in an effort to create even More flames, does it help anyone to leave the locked thread? What if lots of folks started doing this? A good trolling technique that would stir up a lot of trouble would be to do exactly this. Their threads would be locked. But their purpose would be accomplished.
Such action could only be taken on a case by case basis. In this particular instance, I think Lynn crossed the line so blatantly that transer of his thread back to GBU without even leaving the locked thread would have been appropriate. But maybe not. so I did not do it. I only raised the question. I understand that the word DELETION spells Danger,Bad Form, Unfairness, Mistreatment, Bias, etc. I did not raise this issue lightly. It is very very serious.
I won't delete anything without speaking with Spark, Mike, or other moderators. Thanks for you thoughts
Para