The BladeForums.com 2024 Traditional Knife is ready to order! See this thread for details:
https://www.bladeforums.com/threads/bladeforums-2024-traditional-knife.2003187/
Price is $300 $250 ea (shipped within CONUS). If you live outside the US, I will contact you after your order for extra shipping charges.
Order here: https://www.bladeforums.com/help/2024-traditional/ - Order as many as you like, we have plenty.
Pipe tobacco was a varied lot. Cigars ranged from Cohibas to Davidoffs to Padrons, with a few Fuentes thrown in.
Is that a mustard and poppy seed cheese. My wife and I get that stuff. GREAT pics my friend.
Brian, check out the pic I took of a Protagonist in the Trackrock thread. Damn viscous knife. I suspect it may have a place in your Rings story.
Thanks Jim. I have logged a lot of hours with a Woodsman, and it is one of my absolute favorite models. But I'm not sure I would want to employ it as an offensive weapon, and Aragorn has a long history, though unknown by the Hobbits and people of Bree, of fighting Orcs and Goblins. etc. outside the western borders of the Shire. It is something that he has been doing for decades at the time Bilbo leaves the shire.I had originally planned on a Protagonist for Aragorn as soon as Andy released that model, but then Aragorn, or Strider at the time, is seen by the inhabitants of Bree as being a Rapscallion so the name fits, and the model has attitude. But as soon as I can afford one, because I really want one for myself anyway, I will be picking up a Protagonist, and it will figure in somewhere for sure. Maybe I'll land the right handle configuration and make it Legolas' blade...
Ah, great point. I don't think I would want to employ it as a weapon either. Definitely not a thrusting weapon for sure. I guess I was mostly thinking of the amount of time he spent living in the woods when he accepted his role as Chieftain of the Dunedain and left Rivendell. It always seemed to me that the term wanderer was used in Bilbo's poem in reference to that time of Aragorn's life due to the fact that the Dunedain's kingdom was destroyed and they were forced to wander the wilds. However, all this does take place before his meeting Gandalf and the request to patrol the wilds outside the Shire.
Anyway, please don't see this as a disagreement or a debate. As you already know I'm super interested in this project and very curious as to your approach. Also, I don't get to discuss the books with anybody outside of fan forums where every statement is taken as a challenge and the start of an argument.One of the things that I've always enjoyed about Tolkien's collective works is how he was able to be so thorough in his history yet he manages to leave so much room for reader interpretation. It's always refreshing for me to see another's interpretation of his writing.
I'm not really familiar with the Rapscallion as I've never had the pleasure of seeing or handling one in person but looking at photos and reading the specs makes me think it's a great choice. I also think that a Protagonist with a handle similar to my new GauchoD) would be awesome for Legolas. :thumbup:
Thanks again for undertaking this project man. For me, the joining of Tolkien and Fiddlebacks is just awesome! I find myself looking forward to each post as the project comes along. Again, as I know this is a labor of love for you, if there's anything I can do to help just give a holler.![]()
Hello all... I've lurked here in the land of Fiddleback for some time; it's time to say hello! I really need to score a Fiddleback... such beautiful AND functional knives! Mistwalker, thanks for your wonderful pics and threads; Mr. Roy... you are an artist and master. Those "Protagonist" knives are truly stunning; clip points are my favorites--those are perfect. I'll have to figure out how to obtain one--time is tight! My four little ones keep me from investing the on-line time I need to scoring one--but I'm determined! Heading out camping soon with my Cub Scout-ing son... that would make a perfect addition to my gear.
I am the same way. I always like hearing how others interpret parts of the story. Tolkien leaves lots of room for personal imagery.
You hit on a good point. Since the Fiddleback version of the project is so extensive, there is room to go into earlier times and cover more of the knives in different time periods with different characters.
I agree with your thinking on the Legolas knife. I had originally saw that particular knife as one of the Elven blades. This was an early test shot of a concept idea.
And then this test shot was inspired by the scene in king Thranduil's wine cellar when the guards were drinking.
But I like the attitude Orlando Bloom brought to the character of Legolas. I have read and re-read, listened and re-listened, and the only descriptions Tolkien gives of Legolas' knife is the he carries on his belt "a long white knife" and then later he "takes out his silver-hafted knife". So I think a Protagonist in white with natural, or maybe even OD or black bolsters would be perfect.
When Kyle and I were discussing my thoughts on the knife industry, and ways of defeating the mall-ninja-istic-tacti-cool impact in the knife industry, and how I was just done with black coated blades, black sheaths, and so many of the knives on display at places like Sportsman's Warehouse were wannabe-tactical nonsense. How I missed the days when brown leather sheaths and stag handles were common in display cases, he agreed. He was carrying a knife he had recently made for himself made of forged CPM S35VN, which is a pretty complicated undertaking in and of itself, that had a nickle silver guard, some light colored bone handle, and a swedged clipped blade. I told him I loved that knife. That I really like that steel and was intrigued by the forging procedures it requires. That I would love to have something like it. He just said that he had just gotten the process down after months of working on it. That it was such a complex and time consuming process as of yet that he had no idea how to price it really. He said he would think about it and we would talk more later. About two months later he wrote and asked for my address. He said he liked my thoughts on the subject and liked the idea of playing a role in "lightening up" the image of cutlery, that he had made something for me. This is what showed up. Forged CPM S35VN, Ivory G10, Nickle Silver hilt, stainless and mosaic pins, and personalized to me. He recently moved from Iowa to Michigan and this is the 25 knife he has forged in Michigan. and he lives just off of M37. As soon as I saw it, I knew I wanted something like this for Legolas. Paul Brach is doing an interpretation of a Legolas belt knife for the project, and this knife will also be featured in the calendar in Mirkwood. I think a Protagonist with a similar handle configuration would be very fitting for Legolas.
I remember seeing both of those first photos when you posted them. I instantly thought 2 things. My first thought was "that's where that Gaucho went" and my second was about how perfect the wine cellar photo is.
My first image of Legolas was in Ralph Bakshi's animated version of LOTR. That's the image that has always stuck with me. Joyful by nature but very serious and lethal when it mattered. I think that Peter Jackson took some of his imagery from that movie as well and I also feel that Orlando Bloom did an excellent job.
Tolkien's description of Legolas' knife is exactly what I'm talking about as far as room for interpretation is concerned. It's very general and leaves a lot of room for the imagination. The Protagonist definitely fits with my imagination. Legolas always seemed to know why he was summoned to Rivendale and it makes sense to me that he would bring a knife of specific design. One leaning more towards fighting then woodcraft.
That knife that Kyle made is just outstanding. Wow! Those pins in the bolster. Such a fine piece of work. The combination of white and silver definitely scream Elven. Also, looking at Pauls work, he seems to be a perfect choice for the task of Legolas' belt knife.
I definitely agree with you on the "tired of tactical" mentality. Andy's work is basically what brought me out of the black blade phase and reminded me of one of the things I've always enjoyed about knives. That simple look of well shaped steel.
I gotta say that I've been curious if you had a time line for this project. I wasn't sure if you were keeping it to the four main books or if you were going to dip into the whole cannon of work. One thing I wish there was more writing about is the travels of Legolas and Gimli during the peaceful times after the war ended. I mean, a Dwarf and an Elf as best friends and traveling companions, who woulda thunk it?
I had a long talk with the Tobacconist at the mountain mall in Gatlinburg while I was there. about Tobacco and various pipes. I will definitely be picking up a couple of pipes and some Tobacco from him the next time I am up there. Pippin has a couple of "extra" small pipes he carries as a contingency plan. That gets discussed in Flotsam and Jetsam.
Thanks manIt is a mustard seed cheese called Red Dragon. It's imported from England. I picked it up in The Hofbrauhaus Restaurant and Cheese Cupboard in The Village at Gatlinburg. It's an awesome sharp cheese with a nice bite to it. The Hofbrauhaus was another place I enjoyed very much. The family that runs it are very nice people. The daughters Kayla and Wendy were lovely and very courteous. Kayla, the one pictured here, likes the idea of the project I am working on and since the restaurant hours are from 11 am to 4 pm and she lives close by, she said next time she could hang out after hours or come in early so that I could do my inside shots without disturbing other patrons. She and her mother are both cutlery fans. So I am going to try to come up with something for them. If I can find a way to fit it into the budget next year, I'd like to pick up another thin Gaucho and thin Padre, get them into the shoot with them being used in the cheese shop there, and leave them with them for their help in this project and dealing so well with my odd food requests. It's a sandwich shop, but I wanted my sandwich in components to look otherwise in the photos
![]()
![]()
We need some orc-specific glow powder to make this right.
Brian,
Not a Fiddleback. But by friendship and campfire camaraderie, related by extension. A Carl Rechsteinter dagger. I do apologize in advance for the extreme breach of etiquette, but I couldn't help but see this beauty in your story.
I need to go visit Kayla and get some exotic cheese. What a beauty!
We need some orc-specific glow powder to make this right.
I offered for him to borrow my Warthog with Shadetree Toxic Glow burlap.![]()
Hi there, I was wondering if