Nice...glad that they're so dialed in to the products that they sell.
I run into this same attitude/lack of knowledge with fountain pens, another of my addictions (afflictions?). It's very frustrating.
**Update**
Talked to John, who's the camping manager @ the store, and he understood and sympathized with my story. He said that it was against company policy for them to sharpen any customer's knives there at the store, and that he was very sorry about the way it had happened. He said, "We'll get you taken care of one way or another."
He's going to:
1. Talk to the store manager to see what can be done about the situation.
2. Talk with the individual who was responsible for sharpening the knife.
The way he sees it, there are three options:
1. They can send it back to SpyderCo and have them take care of sharpening it.
2. They can have one of their in-house employees who is well-known for his sharpening skills put an edge back on it.
3. They can replace it with something else (this would be the store manager's discretion).
John took my name and my phone number and told me that if I hadn't heard back from him by 3PM tomorrow, that I should call in and ask to speak with him directly, and that he would have a resolution for me.
So, it would appear that I may have made at least a little headway on a resolution.
Truthfully, I'm hopeful that they'll offer to replace the knife. I don't want to lose this one, because I absolutely love the knife, and SpyderCo doesn't make it in this same configuration anymore. But, if they'll replace it, perhaps I can find something comparable. Noob that I am, though, I'm not even sure what IS comparable to a Tufram ATS-55 Cricket.