My First Six Months - State of my Collection

Joined
Nov 23, 2014
Messages
77
I’m just over six months into knife collecting, so I figured it would be a good time to do a state of the collection. As I said in my introductory post, my first stab at collecting was watches over at WatchUSeek, where people would frequently post their collection talking about how happy they are with it, their goals attained, and where they see their collection moving in the future. I’d like to do the same here.

Just like watches, knives can be organized into categories. Divers, chronos, manual wind and automatics become EDC, fixed, folders, hard use, flippers, etc. My goal was really not to focus on any one category, but to have a well rounded collection. I don’t have unlimited funds to spend (do any of us?) so I’ve had to focus mainly on stuff below $100. So, here is my collection so far.

I suppose technically my first purchase was a Gerber Paratrooper 2. I happened to be browsing the local Canadian Tire and they had it on a steep markdown. It was then that I decided to carry a blade on a regular basis. Shortly after owning it, I picked up a Sharpmaker and I was very, very dissatisfied with how blunt it was even after careful sharpening. There were other big ergo problems with it, for example, due to the large holes in the skeletonized handle, I once sliced the tip of my pinky on it when I reached into my pocket. And I have big hands! I began to research other knives, and it was then that I stumbled onto BladeForums, and the madness began.

Open.jpg


Closed.jpg


My first two EDC purchases happened near simultaneously. I picked up a Kershaw Leek and a Spyderco Dragonfly2. While I’m happy with both those purchases, I learned several important lessons that would impact future purchases. Firstly, I learned the importance of blade shape. Because of the low slant of the Leek, most cutting tasks are performed on a very delicate tip. I prefer to cut with the belly of the blade, and that influenced what shapes of blades I would purchase. In addition, I learned the importance of the shape and style of pocket clips. I am an urban knife carrier, and Spyderco’s wire clip places it much deeper in the pocket in comparison to the clip of the Leek. Finally, I learned that liners do make a difference when faced with difficult cutting tasks, so it is important to know your knife before attempting cuts. I was making something out of a cardboard box for my toddler, and I was doing the cuts with the DF2. I could feel the knife flex in my hand when doing the cuts through the heavy cardboard.

Taking the lessons from the previous two knives, I wanted a slightly heavier duty EDC, yet one that was cheaper than the Dragonfly2. Because of my positive impressions of Spyderco, I looked through their line and picked up a Cat. Interestingly, I always figured it would play second fiddle to the DF2 and only come out from time to time, I have actually gravitated towards it, and it has become my most carried knife so far. I love the blade shape and ergos and would highly recommend it.

sBK10a.jpg


sBK10b.jpg


Next up, I wanted a strong fixed blade. I really wanted to start camping more, and I figured a solid fixed blade would fit in well there, as well as being a cornerstone of a bug out bag, if I decided to make one. Enter the BK-10. Great, great blade, though I must say I haven’t used it at all yet. I badly fell on the ice back in March and broke my leg, and it’s only now that I’m getting back to weight bearing. It’ll be a while before I go on any hikes. Still, it is a beautiful and solid knife, and one that will last a lifetime.

My mom recently picked me up a Spyderco Grasshopper, and it is a nice little folder that I can put in my pocket on occasions where a bigger knife would scare the sheep. It’s a great little knife that sharpens up very well. If you’re looking for a cute little knife to bump your order up for free shipping, you can’t ask for anything nicer.

Going back to watches, a kind of milestone is the first watch that you spend more than $1000 on. I haven’t yet crossed that in the watch world, but I feel that $100 should be a similar barrier in the knife world. There’s an incredible amount of beautiful, functional, and strong knives that you can get below $100. When you cross that $100 mark, you are getting into things that are beginning to be truly special in some way. The workmanship usually takes a step up, and you are able to get into some more exotic steels. Well, this week I crossed that milestone.

Enter the Spyderco Paramilitary 2. There is no company that I have gravitated to (so far) quite as much as Spyderco. I love the three that I have, and I really wanted to get one of their more special knives. In particular, I wanted something that would fulfill the “heavy EDC” role. It seems that every Spyderco fan picks one up at some point in their collection, and I thought it would be a good one to have for the summer. Looking forward to getting it in my hands.

So, overall I’m very happy with my collection. I think that I’ve filled a lot of roles, and there really aren’t any junk knives. So, where is it going to in the future?

In my mind, the next stage is to branch out a bit from Spyderco. This isn’t due to any sort of dissatisfaction with the company, I just want to learn what else is out there, and keep what’s in my pocket more varied. For instance, for EDC I have Dragonfly2 → Cat → Paramilitary2. All are great knives, but they are a variation on a theme. They all share similar blade shapes and styles. I want some more variation in there.

What currently caught my eye were two offerings from Ontario Knife Company. I would like to get both a Rat 2 (black blade) and a Utilitac II. The Rat 2 would give me variation when I would normally carry the Cat, and the Utilitac would give me an option to use it rather than the PM2. Far, far less expensive, so I would be less apt to baby it (though I’m a firm believer that any knife in my collection should be used as intended. Nothing is going to be purchased to simply sit in a safe unused). Because I’m Canadian and ordering from the States, usually there is a flat shipping fee to Canada so I would probably order both at the same time and share the shipping fees. Two great knives for just over $50. Seems like a good deal to me.

Well, I've you've gotten down this far, thanks for reading. What are your thoughts on my collection? Any suggestions on where to go from here?

Thanks!
 
Looks like you are on a great path so far. Nothing is better than learning what you like through actual self experience. I love the Utilitac II. It is much heavier duty than the PM2 for me. I of course love the PM2 but we must recognize the thinner tip. Keep it up and post more pics!
 
My "collection" has swelled and waned...and is now mostly in the waning trend. I wish that I could show the many nice folders and fixed blades that I've owned over the last three yrs or so. However, real life rears its ugly head and I usually end up selling something so that I can buy something else.
Welcome to the forum; I enjoyed your pics.
I suppose my all-time favorite folder is the PM2, and the compression lock. It is just plain fun to operate.
:)
 
You have a very nice collection of knives.

Do you like the BUCK brand? They have some very nice fixed blade and folding knives!

Do you like Grohmann knives?

Cate
 
Awesome start! Since you've been focusing on more budget focused knives I would strongly recommend:
Victorinox
Mora
Opinel
They're all cheap, great ways to try new styles of knives.
 
I've been at it since I was 18... here I am at 33:

[video=youtube;etncFl86K08]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=etncFl86K08[/video]
 
Thanks for your input everyone. I appreciate hearing your feedback regarding how my collection has shaped up to this point.

Looks like you are on a great path so far. Nothing is better than learning what you like through actual self experience. I love the Utilitac II. It is much heavier duty than the PM2 for me. I of course love the PM2 but we must recognize the thinner tip. Keep it up and post more pics!

Craytab - I definitely agree, learning through the process of collecting is important. If you just buy and buy without paying attention to why you like one knife more than another, it will likely mean you just have a bunch of knives that don’t really mean anything. I don’t regret any of mine, although I think the PM2 may be a case of Right Knife, Wrong Time. I know I haven’t even received it, but I think I should have made it my next purchase instead of my current purchase. I think the combo of the Rat 2 and Utilitac II would have rounded out my collection better, as the Rat 2 would rotate along with the Cat as my primary EDC knives, and the Utilitac II would be the knife I would carry for heavier use days. Now, the Cat still sits kind of alone as the primary EDC, and the PM2 kind of sits on its own category. I know I won’t necessarily regret the PM2, as I really want it in my collection, but I think I would prefer it later rather than now.

My "collection" has swelled and waned...and is now mostly in the waning trend. I wish that I could show the many nice folders and fixed blades that I've owned over the last three yrs or so. However, real life rears its ugly head and I usually end up selling something so that I can buy something else.
Welcome to the forum; I enjoyed your pics.
I suppose my all-time favorite folder is the PM2, and the compression lock. It is just plain fun to operate.
:)

Sonnydaze - I’m glad to hear that you’re enjoying your PM2. Despite what I just said, I am very excited to get it in hand!

You have a very nice collection of knives.

Do you like the BUCK brand? They have some very nice fixed blade and folding knives!

Do you like Grohmann knives?

Cate

Catherine_Montana - It’s interesting that you asked about Grohmann knives. I’m actually a Canadian Maritimer, and so live the next province over to NS, the home of Grohmann Knives. After I received my first post university paycheque, I bought my Dad a beautiful Grohmann chef’s knife, which he used the rest of his days. But no, I don’t personally have any Grohmann knives, but thanks for reminding me of them, as I haven’t been to their site since starting to collect.

As for Buck Knives, I have this weird mindset about them. I just can’t explain it, but for some reason I have not gravitated towards them. I suppose I remember this cheap Buck folder I got in grade school that would never keep an edge, and that has tainted my opinion. I know I need to move past that. My cousin has a gorgeous Buck hunting knife, made from S30V, and it will take an edge like no other. I sharpened it for him last fall, and he said it was like a lightsaber when I was finished.

Awesome start! Since you've been focusing on more budget focused knives I would strongly recommend:
Victorinox
Mora
Opinel
They're all cheap, great ways to try new styles of knives.

F250 - I’ve been meaning to pull the trigger on a couple Mora knives, but I’m not really looking for fixed blades at the moment. Eventually, I’d like to pair a smaller Mora (546 or 511) with my BK-10 for camping/hiking.

I've been at it since I was 18... here I am at 33:

[video=youtube;etncFl86K08]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=etncFl86K08[/video]

Charlie Mike - Looking good! I should eventually do a video overview of my collection too. I have the gear, I just need to find the time to set it up.

Thanks to everyone else who commented on my post!
 
Nice to see another one who has started recently on an interest in knives (in my case, I'm only about four months in -- two Opinels, three Leatherman MTs, a Kershaw, two Spydercos, and a byrd so far).
 
Any suggestions on where to go from here?

Thanks!
Great choices so far, btw. I would say everyone needs to at least try-
A pliers based multitool. I have a CRKT Zillatool I love, but woild get the Jr. if I did it again.
A swiss army knife, pick the one with the tools you like most. I like ones with a saw, phillips, and the two flathead/can opener/cap lifter, but ymmv.

A mora- just to second or third. Small fixies seem to be a love hate thing, but for the most part I love em. And everyone should try a mora. On that note-

A Becker Eskabar (Bk14). Maybe the best knife all around I have ever bought. Easy the carry, tough as hell, easy to get stupid sharp, very affordable and does a great job of walking the line of good cutter and sharpened prybar. The skeletonized handle will give you a good platform in paracord wrapping too, its one of my favorite handle materials.

I didnt see an assisted opener on your list (might have missed it) but you should check one out to see if you like them. I like
a/o flippers the best, a good cheapie to check out to see if you like it might be the stainless Kershaw Zing, $20 and is one of my favorite blade shapes for all around usefulness. Wish they made one about 4".

An Opinel #8 in carbone. Cheap great slicer, fun to mod and a good intro to see if you like non stainless.

Svord peasant, same reason as above but a friction folder and just kinda cool.

Buck 110. Its nice sometimes to not carry your folder in your pocket, but in a sheath on your belt, is a pretty damn big folder but kinda classy looking so less threatening than say your pm2 and not a budget buster by any means.

Good luck!
 
First purchase was a Gerber Paratrooper 2? I suspect you mean Paraframe 2... if that's the case, then you definitely won't get an edge to be proud of. If you do, it won't keep it for long.

Your collection is looking good. If asking for suggestions, then perhaps these might get you thinking...

A traditional might be nice. I never did carry one until I was given a Bob Ogg slipjoint. Now I find great joy in the simplicity of the design and the steel. There are thousands of configurations out there, and a trip over to the Traditional Knife forum area might spark something.

Try other manufacturers. Benchmade makes some cool stuff too. Your idea of a Utilitac and Rat are good adds for your lineup.

Try a configuration you've never considered. Myself, I had never considered a chisel grind for a knife, but I figured if I was going to be "into knives", I might as well swim the whole pool. Got a Benchmade CQC7 and beat on it for awhile. I don't have it any more, but I'm very glad I got the opportunity to use it and learn some more.

Balisong. Never thought I'd ever be good at it, and I was right... I still suck at it. But there's something very Zen about it that keeps me cutting my fingers and tearing chunks out of the hardwood floor. You might find it just as annoyingly enjoyable as I do.

Glad to have you along for the ride.
 
Great choices so far, btw. I would say everyone needs to at least try-
A pliers based multitool. I have a CRKT Zillatool I love, but woild get the Jr. if I did it again.
A swiss army knife, pick the one with the tools you like most. I like ones with a saw, phillips, and the two flathead/can opener/cap lifter, but ymmv.

A mora- just to second or third. Small fixies seem to be a love hate thing, but for the most part I love em. And everyone should try a mora. On that note-

A Becker Eskabar (Bk14). Maybe the best knife all around I have ever bought. Easy the carry, tough as hell, easy to get stupid sharp, very affordable and does a great job of walking the line of good cutter and sharpened prybar. The skeletonized handle will give you a good platform in paracord wrapping too, its one of my favorite handle materials.

I didnt see an assisted opener on your list (might have missed it) but you should check one out to see if you like them. I like
a/o flippers the best, a good cheapie to check out to see if you like it might be the stainless Kershaw Zing, $20 and is one of my favorite blade shapes for all around usefulness. Wish they made one about 4".

An Opinel #8 in carbone. Cheap great slicer, fun to mod and a good intro to see if you like non stainless.

Svord peasant, same reason as above but a friction folder and just kinda cool.

Buck 110. Its nice sometimes to not carry your folder in your pocket, but in a sheath on your belt, is a pretty damn big folder but kinda classy looking so less threatening than say your pm2 and not a budget buster by any means.

Good luck!

I kinda agree with some of this.

A plier based multi tool is a good idea. If you think that it will be carried ILO a knife, then buy a Leatherman Wave or something similar. The blade is very easy to open. If you think that the MT will take a back seat to a knife that you carry, then maybe something like a Gerber MP600 is in order. The pliers are super easy to use but the blade is a little slower to open than on the Leatherman.

Victorinox/ Swiss Army: Every knife owner should try a Swiss Army knife. Don't forget their Alox models. Look at the Pioneer series, to include the Farmer and the Electrician. The Pioneer in military dress is what the Swiss issued their troops for years. The smaller Alox Cadet makes a fine inexpensive dress knife. Also, many feel that Victorinox makes the best Multi-Tool out there. Don't forget to consider their offerings for your MT.

Kershaw Zing: One of my favorite knives. I own three and can't see myself without a Zing in my collection. I carry a Zing more than any other knife. FWIW, the earlier US made production is considered the better knife than what is now being offered. Try the stainless model though, it is still a great knife for the money. Also, look at the Kershaw Blur, great knife.

Buck: Every knife collector should own at least one Buck knife. The 110 folding hunter is a classic but if you want something slightly smaller, try the Buck 112 Ranger. Same basic knife, just a little smaller and lighter.
 
Not a bad start to a collection...

Definitely agree every collection should have at least one Buck, be it a classic styled 110 or 112, a slip joint, an open season Skinner, or a vantage avid/force/or pro... Or even a little spitfire or cheap Bantam as a spare utility blade to keep around...

Also, giving the blur a try won't hurt... Same snappy action as the leek, but totallt different knife with Plenty of belly to cut with.
 
You absolutely must get any morakniv.

I second this... Mora is pretty much standard must have blade.. Hard to beat for the money really!

I'd also suggest, if assisted autos are legal for you, an Ontario Knife Co Rat 1a. Sweet inexpensive knife... if autos are a no go.. The standard Rat 1 or 2 are both great as well.

I just started collecting knives as well... About a year and a half ago for me. Good luck! :D
 
Hi everyone! Just thought I'd pop in to say that I made a video of my collection. I'm thinking of starting up yet another knife channel, so I figured I would drop it in there.

[video]https://youtu.be/VDUJxSaTQM8[/video]
 
Spyderco Dragonfly is an excellent edc. all you need now is a machete and you're covered.
seriuosly , a few good knives used regularly covers it.
all else is compulsion.

buzz
 
Back
Top