- Joined
- May 19, 2009
- Messages
- 1,161
The first is a 3.5lb head, about 9.5" total and with a 5" cutting face.
The second is a 2.5lb head, about 8.25" total and with a 3.75" cutting face.
Right off the bat, I tested them with a file to see if the temper were still there... the file (a nicholson mill bastard) skidded on the edges unless decent pressure were applied. Having two GBs and a wetterlings on hand, I can say that the heat treat is definitely similar (a 56-58 hrc edge).
Without further adieu, pictures! :thumbup:
The two heads:
GB stampings (sadly rather worn out on the 3.5):
Weight stampings:
And the profiles:
Tested the temper on each with my trusty nicholson:
I think I'll try to take off the rust with a vinegar soak followed by scrubbing. Thankfully the edges are in fairly good condition, so I won't be having to sharpen out large dings... the 3.5lb does have a bit of an uneven profile (you can see that the upper corner/toe on the right side is a bit more intended than it probably should be).
My original plan for handles was to just purchase a couple of replacements from Gransfors Bruks, but thanks to psp7's measurement, I now know that they probably wouldn't fit the 3.5lbs' larger eye. I'll still contact them to make sure, but right now it looks like I'll have to be ordering elsewhere. Luckily I think I've already found a place online thanks to cckw and the owner has been really helpful. Right now, I'm thinking a 28-30" handle for the 2.5lb and a 36" for the 3.5lb.
Anyways, looking forward to a couple of nice projects :thumbup: Hopefully I can still find time now that classes have started up again...
The second is a 2.5lb head, about 8.25" total and with a 3.75" cutting face.
Right off the bat, I tested them with a file to see if the temper were still there... the file (a nicholson mill bastard) skidded on the edges unless decent pressure were applied. Having two GBs and a wetterlings on hand, I can say that the heat treat is definitely similar (a 56-58 hrc edge).
Without further adieu, pictures! :thumbup:
The two heads:

GB stampings (sadly rather worn out on the 3.5):


Weight stampings:


And the profiles:


Tested the temper on each with my trusty nicholson:

I think I'll try to take off the rust with a vinegar soak followed by scrubbing. Thankfully the edges are in fairly good condition, so I won't be having to sharpen out large dings... the 3.5lb does have a bit of an uneven profile (you can see that the upper corner/toe on the right side is a bit more intended than it probably should be).
My original plan for handles was to just purchase a couple of replacements from Gransfors Bruks, but thanks to psp7's measurement, I now know that they probably wouldn't fit the 3.5lbs' larger eye. I'll still contact them to make sure, but right now it looks like I'll have to be ordering elsewhere. Luckily I think I've already found a place online thanks to cckw and the owner has been really helpful. Right now, I'm thinking a 28-30" handle for the 2.5lb and a 36" for the 3.5lb.
Anyways, looking forward to a couple of nice projects :thumbup: Hopefully I can still find time now that classes have started up again...
Last edited: