My Local Knife Shop...

eisman

Gold Member
Feedback: +35 / =0 / -0
Joined
Sep 9, 2009
Messages
6,847
I'm currently lucky enough to be in Birmingham, AL; a city that's got a good selection of the usual gun shops, pawn shops, sporting goods and hardware stores, and even a couple culinary places; but like most places it's usually hard to find a deep selection of the knives we like. A couple years ago the place I usually drop into when the urge to spend is upon me boasted a good 30' of knives on display. And the guy behind the counter liked what he did and the customers he delt with; even though he was relegated to a corner in the shop.

I'd go in just to BS with them, and show whatever new stuff I had (mostly custom) and occasionally buy a knife. The store sells everything hunting and fishing related, so most of my purchases were spread around, but we still talked a lot about knives.

Then I mentioned the Blade Show. Now they go to Shot, but never had done Blade (which is 2.5 hours away). I talked them into sending the one (main) guy over "for a day". In the two years since that happened the store doubled in size. The knife section has (at least) quadrupled. (I can't take credit for that, I was deployed much of the time.)

They carry a great selection of the major brands (you name it they probably have it) and keep adding to the line up. They're even putting in some traditionals, and two cases of true customs. Now they do the Blade show on the regular calendar, and last week they were talking about on-line sales.

IMG_0015.jpg


IMG_0016.jpg


The point being, talk to your local guys. If Birmingham (which is not a big city) can support this kind of business, most places can. I don't believe the mall stores really reached the sportsman, and every knife guy I know does some kind of "sport". I think retailers fail to understand the market for decent knives. (a case in point, I went to the local hardware store this past week; he's got three knife displays 80% empty. Says he sold his stock at Christmas, just hasn't re-ordered. Who doesn't put stuff that sells back on the shelves ASAP?)
 
A friend of mine has been talking about the knife isle at the Ace Hardware store in Keystone Heights, FL. It's a 30 min drive from where I live but it was a knice day and I didn't have to work so I drove out there to check it out. It was pretty cool. Benchmade, Case, Spyderco, Esse, Opinel, SAK... I was impressed. The guy that takes care of the knife section was cool and on top of the latest blades. He even gave me a Spyderco Sharpmaker demo. They also have a small selection of Maxpedition gear. He told me that he frequents this forum. If you're reading this..Thanks!
I messaged a couple of photos to my buddy so he could see where I was.
IMG_6564.jpg

IMG_6057.jpg

...and yes, the knife selection pretty much goes the whole length of the isle.
 
That's a good selection of knives. If I my ask, what is this shop in Birmingham called? I feel the need to make a pilgrimage into Alabama. Not many good knife shops over here across the Chattanasty River (Ft. Benning/Columbus, GA).
 
I doubt there's a single Benchmade available at a retail store within at least 90 miles of here.

Our hardware store has a single display with a mix of Case, Victorinox, Bear, and maybe Buck. All at ridiculously un-competitive prices.

But... some off topic chitchat...

If Birmingham (which is not a big city) can support this kind of business, most places can.

Birmingham is a HUGE city. About one-quarter of all the people in Alabama live in the Birmingham area - 1,128,047 people according to Wikipedia.
By comparison, our entire county has 12,000.
 
That sure is one heck of a display. We didn't have anything to get excited about here in Richmond until recently when a new cutlery store opened up! It's a great store and I see a lot of my money going to it staying open. :D The gentleman that owns it is a real knife guy and a real nice guy too.
 
Yeah wherebouts in B'ham is it? Also I beg to differ B'ham is a pretty good sized town I mean it ain't Atlanta or Charlotte but its big.
 
That's a good selection of knives. If I my ask, what is this shop in Birmingham called? I feel the need to make a pilgrimage into Alabama. Not many good knife shops over here across the Chattanasty River (Ft. Benning/Columbus, GA).

You got Ranger Joes, Northside Pawn and the other big military supply place. Thats it as far as I know.
 
There's an entire store with shelves like that here in Ft. Worth, TX but the prices are through the roof. That's the problem I usually find with local knife stores. I know they can't really compete with online knife stores, but pushing the price through the roof isn't going to make things any better. I think if they charged $5-10 over online prices they would make a killing.
 
OK, I must have hit a sore spot. Let me be a little more clear; Birmingham is not a big city. It's big for the area, but it's not big. Big is L.A. (city population: 3.8 Million), Birmingham is 220,000 (more or less). You can drive across the city of Birmingham in 15-20 minutes; it takes hours to drive from one end of L.A. to another. (The City of Los Angeles would cover the entire area of Birmingham to Montgomery with overlap on each side. The County would go clear to Mobile.) I've lived in half a dozen suburbs that are bigger than Birmingham (Pasadena, San Jose, Tacoma, St Louis, Vallejo, Burbank) and been through dozens of places around the world that make this place feel nice and fairly small town.

I'm not putting it down, I like Birmingham; but it's not a big city.

It was, once upon a time it was one of the biggest cities in the South. It was bigger than Atlanta. But Atlanta realized it had to grow up to get rich and Birmingham didn't. Now Atlanta's 4-5 times bigger. I need to go to a city; I drive to Atlanta.

Back to the original topic, Mark's Outdoors is a good place to visit. Randy in the knife section is a good guy.
 
Used to have a really good shop about 40 miles away that was worth the drive. The main thing was they had a real knife nut that took care of things. I could never get out of that store in less than 2 hours and sometimes went longer than that. This guy could talk steels, knives, swords, and was up on the industry and had relationships with lots of the manufacturers. I would usually buy something just to support what they were doing and keeping a nice selection of knives where I could see and handle them.

Last time I went, the "guy" was gone - nobody wanted to talk about why (which is the right way to handle it), but the people left didn't know what a Phat Bob was even though they stock Kabar, didn't know what a Speedform II was even after I explained it to them, and when trying to look at knives on display, I had to point - asking for even a Spyderco or Benchmade by name just got me a blank look and a "which one is that?"

I'm not going to embarass them by naming them in case they've picked up their game since then, but Andy, if you read this PM me!
 
I really don't have any good knife shops anywhere near me. The closest one charges double, or sometimes triple what the going price is, and has a horrible selection. The next closest one has about five different knives and nothing of any quality.
 
I moved this to FEEDBACK, so if any of you are shy about deal spotting, well, it is OK to name the stores here, that's what FEEDBACK is for. And you can see, a lot of people would be glad to know the name and address of a good knife shop!
 
I moved this to FEEDBACK, so if any of you are shy about deal spotting, well, it is OK to name the stores here, that's what FEEDBACK is for. And you can see, a lot of people would be glad to know the name and address of a good knife shop!

^^^ This!
 
Thanks Esav. The store I referenced in my above post is called The Classic Edge in Midlothian, VA (just south of Richmond) and Bob is a great source of knowledge and a stand up guy. If you live in central Virginia stop by and show some support for a small business and meet a great guy. PM and I can get you the address and phone number.

Dan
 
I talked to the owner of the shop I usually go to, Edgeworks in Frederick, about putting his knives online for sales. He said the cost of the point of sale software alone would be cost prohibitive. His site includes his custom and semi custom production stock (customs, William Henry, CRK, rehandled Fallknivens etc). It's just him most of the week, and maybe a few helpers on the weekend. You can contact him about those knives, but I don't believe you can buy directly from his site.

The other two stores I visit, Country Knives in Lancaster PA and Willey Knives in southern DE, sell knives online. Willey Knives does not list all of their stock online however.

All three stores are about as local as you can get for me, about two hours away from all three. There is a small shop in Baltimore, on the east side. A couple knife nut buddies who are members have been there, but I've only bought from the shop at knife shows. America Manor House on the east side, a somewhat shady area.
 
I need to go to a city; I drive to Atlanta.

You come to Atlanta for the big city. I assume for when you want to enjoy really bad traffic. :D

Looks like I need to drive to Birmingham if I want to check out some knives.

It amazes me that a metro area the size of Atlanta has no decent knife stores.
There are a few Case dealers with pretty good selections (at full MSRP), but not much else...or not any I have been able to find.
 
Jeez! I'd be like a kid in a candy store and my wife would probably follow me around telling me, "don't touch!"

San Diego is a pretty big place and we've got a couple military bases, but the only thing I've been able to find here locally is the excellent, excellent ( ;) )Bear Grylls Ultimate Survival Knife at the big box stores. No real quality available locally makes me shop the hit-and-miss way online.
 
The store in question in the Birmingham area is Mark's Outdoor Sports in Vestavia. They already had a great knife section, but after it did over a million dollars worth of knife business last year the owner gave the knife manager the ok to double the display area. There is another GB&U thread started recently by Stainz about this same store. I am presently lusting after a Les Baer Premium II in the handguns display case.
 
Back
Top