Zero chanceIs it possible it could be a fake?
OP purchased on amazon and I’ve heard buying knives on there is sketchy.
If OP sends both pieces to Spyderco, they should be able confirm what the likely cause of failure is.
That being said, Maxamet is a low-toughness material and I would surprised if Spyderco finds a material defect or a counterfeit.
Does anyone know if Spyderco provides any special warnings in the box regarding uses that might break the blade?
I just looked through what was included with my Native 5 Maxamet. In the box there was an insert that talks about Maxamet but no warnings were given regarding toughness.
...
I do think Maxamet knives should include a warning about lateral pressure and impact forces.
So nobody thinks that without that huge hole in the blade it might have not happened, I know its blasphemy, but I always thought the hole could be smaller and work as well(and add some strength).
It is well known here that performance while cutting is the primary objective at Spyderco. Designing a blade to withstand much larger loads is easy. Doing that while preserving performance is not at all easy.Spyderco could "easily" design the blade to withstand much larger loads. It is interesting that Spyderco hasn't done that.
It would definitely create value for the customer to tweak the blade grinds for different steels, like they seem to do for H1.
It is well known here that performance while cutting is the primary objective at Spyderco. Designing a blade to withstand much larger loads is easy. Doing that while preserving performance is not at all easy.
Without the hole it would be stronger, whether the OP would have snapped it or not would be harder for us to know. For me the hole couldn't be any smaller and still work as well. I believe knives like the Endura have smaller holes, and they are harder for me to operate.So nobody thinks that without that huge hole in the blade it might have not happened, I know its blasphemy, but I always thought the hole could be smaller and work as well(and add some strength).
Is it possible it could be a fake?
Just as you said Jonny, have a friend in NZ, exact same experience. Had used the knife, not abused, and then, one day, snap, when he least expected it, normal cutting.Mine has snapped exactly like yours did a few years back. Was cutting up a section of conveyor belt, something I had done a thousand times with my other Spyderco knives with no problems. The handle was in my hand and the blade was still in the conveyor belt. Spyderco sent me a new one. I won’t buy another Maxamet blade again.
On a lighter note, the hole didn’t break, only the steel around itWithout the hole it would be stronger, whether the OP would have snapped it or not would be harder for us to know. For me the hole couldn't be any smaller and still work as well. I believe knives like the Endura have smaller holes, and they are harder for me to operate.