I am squarely with the "carry it" crowd. Look how much more character a knife has when it has been time tested and shows the careful wear that someone that appreciates a nice knife gives it.
If you keep it perfect, likely you might pass it on to someone that is also afraid to use it, and it will just be a oddity, an example of a fine knife. But if you use it for a couple or three decades and pass it on to someone, it could be a real treasure for them.
I don't want museum pieces. I bought them with my money, for me. I want to enjoy them. So in the pocket they go!
Robert
Thanks for that quote midnight flyer. I have also been struggling with that notion of being afraid to use expensive knives.