Let me start by saying I am very happy with the M-J, and at $49 it is a steal.
The blade shows a few tooling marks in various places, but in an inexpensive hand forged knife like this, I think it shows character. The only blade flaws that would concern me are two folds/flaws that are at the bottom of each side of the chos. I belive these stress concentrations will lead to blade failure under extreme use. I know that Craig will exchange this knife with no hesitation, but since he offers a life time warranty I think I'll keep it and see if it will fail where I predict. The M-J was purchased as a working knife, and I am interested in seeing how well it holds up under hard use.
The rose wood handle displays some rough carving, which again I think adds character. The tips of the handle are a little too pointy. This will be no problem, as a little work with my dremel tool will soften the points.
The overall construction of the sheath/scabbard is pretty good, except for the frog. This leather (Buffalo Hide?) seems pretty tough, but it is way to thin. Craig I think this really needs to be improved.
The chakmak and the karda are kind of crude, however they are usable. I would be happy to pay a little more for a little better quality here. The karda seems to be very soft, and the finish is kind of rough. Too bad as I think this would have made a great bird/trout knife.
Overall I think this knife shows great promise. I wouldn't hesitate to recomend the M-J to some one who is looking for a good belt knife, and at $49 how can you go wrong.
p1445
I tried to buy the kydex on wednesday, but my company was redoing their employee sales computer system and policies and no one can tell me how long this will take. I'll give them a few weeks, then I guess I'll have to find a new source for the kydex. This knife just screams for a kydex sheath, and I can't wait until I can start making one.
[This message has been edited by p1445 (edited 24 September 1999).]