NC gasforge, knifemaker vs whisper moma open ends

[peppen108]

I'm setting up a small out doors forge and curently have two opinions. I know the prices are high but I'm in Sweden, and we'll that's just the way it is.


Option 1. A NC knifemaket that has been used for 50 hours and welded in. I need to buy this unseen for an equivalent of 450$.

Option 2. A whisper moma open ends new from a local ferier shop for 870$.

I need to make up my mind before the wife catches on to me. So if you have any input please share.

 

[Stacy E. Apelt - Bladesmith]

If you are doing knives, the knifemaker is the right one.

The Momma model is most suitable for blacksmithing and farrier work.

I have a Whisper Lowboy and a Whisper Knifemaker. Both are great forges. I have thousands of running hours on both and they still work like they did when new. Reline every five years or so and you are good to go.

Tip:
Get a stationary bulk propane tank, or at a minimum, a 100# portable tank. The 20# BBQ size bottles will freeze up if used for long periods.

 

[jdm61]

I started off with the NC Knifemaker before I bought my Chile. It works quite well. +1 on the 100 lb tank advice.

 

[Don Hanson III]

I like the whisper low boy better than the knife makers model.

 

[Stacy E. Apelt - Bladesmith]

Me too.

 

[Cody Hofsommer]

I have two whisper Mommas. I have welded lots in both of them. Never used a knifemaker.